The Pittsburgh Public Schools has gone to court to fight the huge property assessment reductions awarded to three Downtown skyscrapers, including the U.S. Steel Tower, the city’s tallest building.

District officials filed appeals with the board of viewers in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court to challenge the cuts approved recently by the county’s board of property assessment appeals and review.

In addition to U.S. Steel Tower, the district is seeking to roll back the reductions granted to the Tower at PNC Plaza, PNC Bank’s headquarters, and Three Gateway Center, which is being considered for a possible residential conversion. The assessment on U.S. Steel Tower has been slashed by $91.6 million from $233.2 million to $141.5 million for the 2023 tax year and by $81.2 million to $151.9 million for 2022.

At the Tower at PNC Plaza, the assessed value has fallen from $147.2 million to $72.3 million for 2022 and 2023, a reduction of $74.8 million. The assessment on Three Gateway Center has been cut from $62.7 million to $35.5 million for both 2022 and 2023 tax years.

Advertise with us

In all, the cuts on those three skyscrapers alone total $193.6 million for the 2023 tax year and have the potential to cost the school district, the city, and the county a combined $4.4 million in tax refunds, nearly $2 million of that coming from the district.

They are part of a wave of commercial reductions expected over the next few weeks as the assessment board completes its work on thousands of appeals left over from 2022 and 2023.

So far, two other Downtown landmarks — PPG Place and the Union Trust Building — also have received reductions totaling a combined $50.8 million for the 2023 tax year.

Ira Weiss, Pittsburgh Public Schools solicitor, said Monday the district is prepared to “aggressively represent” its interests in the appeals it has filed with the board of viewers over the U.S. Steel Tower, Three Gateway Center, and Tower at PNC Plaza valuations

He expects the district to challenge the other big cuts as well.

Advertise with us

“The reductions are monumental and we don’t believe they’re supported by the evidence of value,” he said. “When you’re talking about these kinds of reductions, there’s a lot to talk about and consider.”

The cuts have been attributed to two intersecting factors — high office vacancy rates spawned by the COVID-19 pandemic and remote work, and a steep drop in the common level ratio, the figure used in appeal hearings to calculate the taxable value of a property.

Commercial office buildings are valued in part on the income they generate. As vacancies increase, they are generating less money, making them less valuable.

The common level ratio, meanwhile, dropped from 87.5% to 63.5% for 2022 and 2023 after a group of property owners sued, claiming the number was artificially high. A judge agreed. The lower ratio can be beneficial to property owners, even in some cases where the fair market value increases.

Peter Schnore, attorney for Hertz Gateway Center LP, owner of Three Gateway Center, declined comment on the district’s appeal of that property.

Advertise with us

In the past, he has said the commercial reductions “are warranted because every property owner, whether large or small, shouldn’t pay more than their fair share of property taxes due to market conditions related primarily to COVID and its impact on office property.

“These properties are entitled to significant reductions.”

Jason Yarbrough, attorney for the U.S. Steel Tower owner, declined comment on the district’s appeal. The attorney for PNC could not be reached for comment.

Mr. Weiss said he understands that market conditions and the common level ratio have played a big role in the reductions and the appeals. But he also accused the assessment board of “mass handling [appeals] like widgets.”

“We believe that these huge reductions will be more-realistically viewed at the board of viewers when there’s a full hearing,” he said.

Advertise with us

All of the reductions were approved at the county assessment board level based on hearing officer recommendations following formal appeal hearings, where evidence was presented regarding a property's value.

Mike Suley, an assessment board member and former county assessment director, took issue with the way Mr. Weiss described the board’s handling of the cases.

He said the reductions occurred after the property owners produced appraisals from state certified general appraisers. The hearing officers who handled the cases at the appeals board level are also state certified general appraisers, he stated.

“They’re professionals with professional credentials,” he said. “I totally disagree with [Mr. Weiss’] characterization.”

Given the high stakes involved, it is not uncommon for commercial valuations to end up in Common Pleas Court. Such cases can take years to resolve, and the board of viewers typically encourages the parties to negotiate a compromise.

Advertise with us

The big reductions and the continuing drop in the common level ratio — it will be 54.5% this year — has triggered calls from Mr. Weiss and others for a countywide reassessment to rectify the inequities. The last such reassessment was more than a decade ago.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com