Two more Downtown landmarks have secured big cuts in their property assessments, adding to a wave of reductions that a school district attorney described as a “feeding frenzy.”
The assessment on PPG Place, the six-building castle-like complex in the heart of Downtown, has been slashed by nearly $36.9 million to $142.5 million for 2023 and by nearly $27.9 million to $151.5 million for 2022.
A few blocks away on Grant Street, the taxable value of the historic Union Trust Building, erected by industrialist Henry Clay Frick, plunged $13.9 million to $46 million for 2023 and $10.9 million to $49 million for 2022.
Together, the cuts, approved by the Allegheny County Board of Property Assessment Appeals and Review last week, will reduce the assessed value of the two pieces of real estate by nearly $50.8 million for 2023 alone.
That’s on top of a combined $193.6 million in reductions for the 2023 tax year awarded in January for three other big Golden Triangle properties — U.S. Steel Tower, the Tower at PNC Plaza, and Three Gateway Center.
Overall, the $244.4 million in reductions on those five buildings could cost the city, the Pittsburgh schools, and the county about $5.6 million in tax revenue or refunds for 2023. For the school district alone, it could amount to $2.5 million.
Read More
For 2022, the assessment cuts on the five buildings total $222 million, resulting in a combined tax loss of $5.1 million to the three taxing bodies.
And with the county’s property assessment board still dealing with more than 4,000 appeals left over from 2022 and 2023, more big commercial reductions could be on the way.
“There’s a feeding frenzy going on now and the assessment board is caught up in that,” said Ira Weiss, the solicitor for the Pittsburgh Public Schools. “This train is racing toward a cliff and we have to slow it down.”
Lingering impacts of COVID
Mike Suley, an appeals board member who served as the county’s assessment director for nearly seven years, said he hasn’t seen reductions of this magnitude since the 1990s.
“It is almost, in my opinion, of biblical proportions,” he said.
He added that the city and its school district aren’t the only ones on the hook for potential massive tax refunds and revenue losses as a result of assessment cuts. The same dynamic is playing out in the suburbs as well, he noted.
As one example, the appeals board last week approved a $5.5 million reduction in the taxable value of a Walmart in Natrona Heights, dropping the assessment to $3.1 million.
Suburban properties “will see significant reductions if the evidence is credible,” Mr. Suley said.
All of the reductions were approved based on hearing officer recommendations following formal appeal hearings where evidence was presented regarding a property’s value.
Driving the commercial reductions are two big factors — high office vacancy rates spawned by the COVID-19 pandemic and hybrid work, and a steep drop in the common level ratio, the number used in appeals hearings to calculate the taxable value of a property.
Sharon DiPaolo, a partner in the Siegel Jennings Co. law firm who specializes in commercial property appeals, said office buildings aren’t the only ones struggling these days.
Many brick and mortar retail stores, shopping centers and malls are also having a hard time because of the rise in e-commerce, she explained. And hotels, particularly Downtown, are hurting because of a drop in foot traffic from pre-pandemic levels.
“We’re still seeing the impact of COVID on commercial real estate. The impact, especially for office, is a once-in-a-lifetime change. It’s a generational change in what the value will be,” Ms. DiPaolo said.
The common level ratio, meanwhile, plunged from 87.5% to 63.5% for the 2022 and 2023 tax years after a group of property owners sued, claiming that it was artificially high. The lower ratio is generally beneficial to property owners.
Dominick Gambino, a former county assessment director who now serves as a consultant to municipalities and school districts, said there’s a simple explanation for the kinds of reductions being awarded.
“This is what happens when you wait 10 years to do a reassessment,” he said. “This is what you get — a big bang.”
Additional reductions
PPG Place and the Union Trust building weren’t the only Downtown properties to see reductions in the latest wave of appeal results approved by the assessment board.
Five smaller office properties on Grant Street, Fort Pitt Boulevard, Wood Street and Fort Duquesne Boulevard saw their assessed value cut by a combined $5.3 million for the 2023 tax year and by nearly $5.6 million for 2022.
In Oakland, the assessment on the Hampton Inn on Hamlet Street fell by $3 million to $6.9 million for both 2022 and 2023. On the South Side, the taxable value of Hyatt House Hotel dropped $4.4 million to $13.5 million for 2023.
Two North Shore properties — One North Shore Center on Federal Street and Four North Shore Center on Isabella Street — saw their assessments cut by $7 million to $5.5 million and $1.4 million to $3.3 million, respectively, for 2023. For 2022, the assessment on One North Shore was sliced by $6.4 million and at Four North Shore by the same $1.4 million.
Mr. Weiss, who has described the current assessment system as dysfunctional, said the Pittsburgh Public Schools intends to appeal the big reductions to the board of viewers in Common Pleas Court in an effort to reverse or minimize them.
“There’s no way in the world that the school district is going to passively accept these kinds of reductions,” he said.
The 2022 cuts approved last week were the result of the so-called second-chance appeals offered by the county a year ago after the common level ratio was cut by a court order.
“The hits are going to keep on coming,” Mr. Weiss said. “There’s no question about it. County Council opened this window and everybody is jumping through it.”
He again urged county Executive Sara Innamorato to launch a countywide reassessment to correct the growing inequities in the system.
Mr. Gambino said that is the only way to stop the current free fall. Big commercial assessment reductions, he added, only increase the burden on residential taxpayers.
Without a reassessment, the current cycle of reductions will just keep repeating itself, Mr. Suley said. He pointed out that the common level ratio, which is used as a tool to even out inequities absent a reassessment, has dropped to 54.5% this year and could go even lower in 2025.
That, he said, could trigger yet more rounds of appeals — and even more big commercial reductions.
“The fact that the common level ratio will continue to drop is alarming,” he said.
Many of the big commercial reductions approved by the assessment board likely will end up on appeal before the board of viewers, where final values are often negotiated between the parties.
“It’s going to look like the Parkway East [at the board of viewers],” Mr. Suley said. “You have all of these appeals. It’s really going to back up traffic.”
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.