Restaurateurs Tracey and Marlon Gist weren’t much impressed by a Downtown spot on Penn Avenue where they considered opening an eatery a year ago.

“It’s too small; it’s not going to work for what we have in mind,” Tracey Gist remembered thinking.

But a closer look revealed plusses that became part of a marketing plan uniquely fitted to a thriving urban core: Within an easy walk, the well-lighted location features bus stops for Greyhound and Megabus travelers, a federal courthouse teeming with hungry lunchtime workers, and a big parking garage across the avenue that’s crowded Monday through Friday with office commuters. All of these are sources of foot traffic, which the Gists tempt with sidewalk sandwich boards listing daily specials.

Word of mouth has been their main advertising strategy, she said. But that’s just part of their success formula: In the works are plans for heat-and-eat meals ready for busy commuters to take home, said Tracey Gist, who also does accounting consulting work.

Advertise with us

Some of the early business efforts have begun paying off.

“We’re starting to get the lunch crowd,” she said.

The Art & Soul Cafe the pair opened in December 2022 on a part of Penn Avenue straddling the Cultural District and Strip District combines Marlon’s passion for artistic painting and Tracey’s love affair with Southern cooking, stretching back decades.

Following in their father’s footsteps in food service, the brother and sister restaurateurs, ages 51 and 56 respectively, started Gist Catering Inc. in 2014 while Tracey Gist ran a restaurant and bar in Beaver County, where the Gists live. COVID-19 shutdowns and building problems at the bar forced a permanent closing, Tracey Gist said, but the catering has continued.

“Catering is really what’s holding it all together,” she said.

Advertise with us

The catering and restaurant sides of the business employ a combined six part-time people, holding down overhead costs.

After the closing of the Beaver County restaurant and bar, the Gists went shopping for a place to open a restaurant in the city when they found the place on Penn Avenue, which already had the sinks and some other features necessary for preparing and serving food. Pittsburgh was a natural choice of locations — 75% of Gist Catering’s trade was in Allegheny County.

The catering business has continued to carry the cafe financially as commuters and hungry office workers discover Art & Soul’s menu of cheesy macaroni, barbecue chicken wings, pulled pork sandwiches, black-eyed peas, collard greens and candied yams.

“It’s all about letting the people know we’re here,” Tracey Gist said. “I don’t want to brag, but we have a superior product.”

A superior product may not be enough. A 2019 study by Ohio State University found that 60% of restaurants fail in the first year, which rises to 80% in five years.

Advertise with us

In addition, evolving remote working trends may crimp foot traffic to downtowns: Just 38% of companies require full-time office work, down from 49% of companies at the start of 2023, according to San Francisco-based software company Scoop Technologies Inc.

“The future may not be fully remote, but it won’t be full time in the office either,” the Scoop October study concluded.

Downtown Pittsburgh has also had its issues, with a rising homeless population and a perception that crime is increasing.

But the Gists aren’t bothered by those things, and their strategy includes creating multiple ways of generating sales — and customer loyalty.

The cafe is BYOB, which misses out on an average profit margin of 75% for alcohol sales compared to 65% for food, according to the Restaurant Resource Group, a Sandwich, Mass.-based trade group. But BYOB also means diners are likely to leave smiling because of a much smaller tab than if alcoholic beverages had been served.

Advertise with us

Here are some other ways they’re generating revenue: The Art & Soul venue can be leased for private parties and Sunday jazz brunches, art openings and Friday evening artistic painting sessions are among the weekly features.

The events also work to make the artistic expression and Southern food dining concept seamless.

“He’s art and I’m soul,” Tracey Gist said about her brother, Marlon, who studied art at Columbus College of Art and Design in Ohio and has spent 25 years traveling to festivals selling his creations. “I can’t draw stick figures.”

“It’s part of me,” she added about food service. “For some reason, it draws me back.”

Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com