A landmark verdict on real estate commissions could send shockwaves through the housing industry — and fundamentally change how homes in the U.S. are bought and sold. The reverberations are already being felt in Pittsburgh.

A Missouri court on Oct. 31 handed down a $1.8 billion class action ruling that said brokers Keller Williams and HomeServices of America had systematically coerced sellers to pay an artificially high 6% agent commission fee, which is split by the listing and buyer’s agent.

Homebuyers are told that it doesn’t cost anything to have an agent represent them in sales because the seller pays the commission. But when sellers add the commission to the listing price, buyers who finance their home over 30 years could end up paying six figures for the agent commissions.

Other lawsuits followed, some within minutes of the Missouri ruling.

Advertise with us

Locally, a suit was filed last week in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania naming West Penn Multi-List Service and several other local brokerages.

Altogether, the lawsuits could change the way agents are paid — and protect homebuyers from footing the bill for hidden commissions.

And that could have a huge impact on house hunters: For an average priced home costing $300,000 in the Pittsburgh region, homebuyers today will pay at least $18,000 in real estate agent commissions, even though it’s not supposed to cost the buyer anything, according to the new True Cost of Commissions Calculator that aims to expose hidden fees in the real estate industry.

“A seemingly zero commission on a $1 million house usually stealthily reaches $60,000 and skyrockets to a staggering $155,000 when factoring in increased mortgage costs,” said Dawid Siuda, a finance researcher at Poland-based Omni Calculator, which created the calculator in response to the Missouri court ruling. “We wanted to highlight that even if the seller pays the commission, in the end, the buyer pays for it because it’s already put inside the price.”

‘Committed to upholding our core values’

Advertise with us

Minutes after the Missouri verdict, a new lawsuit by home sellers named several other brokerages and accused them of committing a conspiracy, including ExP, Redfin and O’Hara-based Howard Hanna Real Estate Services.

Howard Hanna, the nation’s largest privately owned real estate company, declined to answer questions for this story. Instead, the company provided a statement.

“In light of ongoing legal matters within our industry, we are actively monitoring the situation and will provide updates as necessary,” the statement said. “We will continue to represent buyers and sellers in real estate transactions, and remain committed to upholding our core values and guiding principles as a company.”

The Missouri verdict is currently under appeal.

In relation to last week’s local lawsuit, the West Penn Multi-List serves about 9,000 real estate agents in the Pittsburgh region.

Advertise with us

Other local brokerages included in the recent federal suit include Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices The Preferred Realty; Coldwell Banker Realty; Platt Sotheby’s International Realty; NextHome PPM Realty; Realty One Group Gold Standard; Realty One Group Platinum; and Realty One Group Horizon. Co-conspirators were also named, including the Pennsylvania Association of Realtors.

Filed on Dec. 4, this proposed class action lawsuit is similar to the Missouri lawsuit in that it alleges the defendants enforced the buyer broker commission rule throughout Western Pennsylvania, unfairly forcing home sellers to make an offer of compensation to buyers’ agents. This resulted in home sellers paying between 5% and 6% of the total sales price in broker commissions.

If class action status is granted in the case, the class would include anyone who sold homes listed on the West Penn Multi-List in the past four years using one of the named defendant brokerage companies, and who paid a commission to the buyer’s agent, according to realestatenews.com.

‘The agent pays for more and more’

The Missouri case took aim at a longstanding practice in the real estate industry in which a 6% sales commission is split equally by the listing and buying agent.

Advertise with us

The plaintiffs argued that the National Association of Realtors forces home sellers to pay an inflated commission that is then split between the listing and buying agent. The plaintiffs argued that commission sharing as a condition for access to the Multiple Listing Service was unfair and kept commissions artificially high.

Two firms initially named in the Missouri lawsuits settled out of court for a combined $140 million. Those brokers include ReMax and Anywhere Real Estate, formerly known as Realogy, which is the parent company of Coldwell Banker, Century 21, Sotheby’s International and Corcoran.

In reaching the settlement, the brokers pledged to change their business practices and said they would no longer require agents to be members of the National Association of Realtors.

Keller Williams real estate agent Mike Netzel, an investor in a Keller Williams Realty franchise, said the industry can be challenging for agents.

It’s lucrative for agents who succeed, he said — but for most agents, it’s tough, especially when the market is hot and multiple agents are making offers on properties.

Advertise with us

“What about the agents that don’t get paid anything?” he said. “In multiple bidding situations, everything is being done out-of-pocket by the agent. People don’t realize that. The company pays for nothing, and the agent pays for more and more.”

‘Now questions are being raised’

According to Omni Calculator, buyers are paying the highest price, especially those who finance their home purchase over 30 years. Commissions are a hidden cost borne disproportionately by homebuyers, the company said.

“We were interested in the topic because it looks like the 6% commission has been kept like this for a long time and now questions are being raised about whether it’s supposed to be that high,” Mr. Siuda said. “For example, in Poland, we have commissions of around 2%, and that’s the maximum. The commissions are usually even lower, and you don’t have to use an agent to sell your property.”

Omni Calculator started 10 years ago with the development of a profit margin calculator for business people to quickly solve problems. The company has since developed more than 3,000 free-to-use calculators for everything from finance to physics.

Advertise with us

“This verdict related to the housing market might lead to some actual changes,” Mr. Siuda said. “That’s why we created the calculator — to help people be more aware of the situation and to highlight the topic.”

With wire reports. Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com or 412-779-5834