The shock of rising interest rates has put a dent in Western Pennsylvania’s booming residential real estate market in the past year, sending sales volume down more than 15% over the 12 month-period that ended in August, according to home listing service West Penn Multi-List.
And that, in turn, has left a surplus of real estate agents looking for properties to sell.
There are now just under 5,000 active home listings in the 17-county region, according to the listing service. Yet the number of licensed real estate agents in the West Penn Multi-List is higher than ever — more than 8,300.
“I don’t know how any of these agents are making money because that comes out to less than one listing per agent,” said Charlene Haislip, an agent at ReMax Realty Brokers in Squirrel Hill.
It’s a national problem that has consumer advocates questioning whether the standards to get into the industry are high enough, while some local agents and brokerages shrug off the impact of the sheer numbers of real estate agents, saying the established ones will be fine.
While the pace of transactions has slowed in Pittsburgh’s housing market, homes are still holding their value for sellers.
Read More
According to West Penn Multi-List, the sales volume for residential real estate from August 2022 to August 2023 is down 15.36%. However, the average sales price during that period remained essentially flat — down 0.51%.
The average sales price for homes in Pittsburgh this year is $261,492 compared to August 2022, when it was $262,840, according to West Penn Multi-List.

“We’re clearly seeing that there’s still an under-supply of properties and certainly still a high demand,” said Chris Murphy, owner of ReMax Select based in Cranberry. “If we started seeing the average sales price go down, that would indicate we’re having less demand.”
In 30 years as a real estate agent, Mr. Murphy has never seen so many people ready to buy houses with cash.
“Why is that?” he said, although he knows the answer. “There was so much pent-up buyer demand after COVID and sellers had huge appreciation in their properties. So, they sold their homes and were able to buy another one with cash.”
Home prices are keeping steady thanks, in part, to cash buyers who are not affected by rising interest rates.
But the real estate industry as a whole is wrestling with new challenges that can also be traced back to the pandemic.
The surplus of real estate agents is one of the most obvious.
With help from record low interest rates, the pandemic unleashed the pent-up buyer demand that resulted in record high transactions and pushed home prices to the moon, which in turn led to an explosion in the number of people going into real estate sales.
Established agents ‘still doing extremely well’
In the face of rising interest rates and fewer home sales, membership in Pittsburgh’s trade group for real estate agents continues to increase, according to John Petrack, vice president of the Downtown-based Realtors Association of Metropolitan Pittsburgh.
“Usually when we see a downturn in sales, we see a downturn in membership,” Mr. Petrack said. “Yet this year, our membership has still increased slightly, which is kind of interesting.”

Membership in the real estate organization currently stands at 3,370 and has been climbing for the last few years, Mr. Petrack said.
“The last time we got over 3,000 was in 2007,” he said. “Last year, we broke the 3,000 mark for the first time since the Great Recession.”
The West-Penn Multi-List covers a far wider geographic territory: 17 counties, to the West Virginia border, Ohio line, up to Erie County and as far east as Somerset County.
West Penn Multi-List membership stands at 8,317, up from about 8,100 last year. And the most well-established agents don’t appear to have been affected by the influx of newcomers to the industry.
“More and more members that I speak with are still doing extremely well,” Mr. Petrack said. “Obviously, they’re all complaining about the lack of properties on the market.
“The only thing I can garner from that is that someone that has established themselves is still doing relatively good.”
Ms. Haislip earned her real estate license in 1999. At this point in her career, most of her business comes from repeat customers and referrals from customers.
“I’m doing this year pretty much what I did last year, the year before that and even the years before the pandemic,” she said, adding that she handles between 20 to 25 transactions a year, with roughly half representing buyers and half representing sellers.
“I’ve not experienced any difference whatsoever,” she said. “I’m very consistent that way.”
The reality is that in most every real estate company, about 50% of the agents sell no homes a year, said Mike Netzel, a team leader at Keller Williams Real Estate in Pine. “Its been that way in the industry as long as I’ve been in the industry.”
He said there may be a financial motive to encouraging agents to maintain their licenses even when they make no sales. Real estate agents are independent contractors working solely on commission, yet trade associations impose fees on them just as unions do.
“The National Association of Realtors, the Pennsylvania Association of Realtors and the Realtors Association of Metropolitan Pittsburgh all have the unfettered ability to mandate fees on licensees,” Mr. Netzel said. “So, in that regard, some people are making money off them.
“You can also say that in this business it doesn’t cost the broker much to have somebody there (since agents work for 100% commission). So, why would you get rid of them?”
Easy to get licensed, hard to land consistent sales
The surplus of real estate agents is a national problem under scrutiny by consumer advocates.
The Washington, D.C.-based Consumer Federation of America last week released its second report on the imbalanced real estate industry, titled: “A Surfeit of Real Estate Agents 2: Is Entry Too Easy?”
The report documents how easy it is to obtain a real estate license, which only requires taking a course and passing a state licensing exam.
Although requirements vary slightly by state, the CFA concludes the whole process takes a median of nine weeks and costs a median $600 — a mere fraction of the time and expense needed to practice almost all other financial services occupations, which often require a degree and special training.
In Pennsylvania, real estate license applicants must take two mandatory classes that cost an average $350 each, plus buy a book that costs $40, according to Mr. Petrack.
“Once you get licensed and join a firm, you have a variety of up-front costs related to the multi-list business, business cards, errors and omissions insurance, etc.,” Mr. Petrack said.
It is even easier to earn a real estate sales license than to practice many manual occupations, from plumbing to hairdressing, which usually require an apprenticeship of more than 1,000 hours as well as coursework, the CFA said.
“There’s widespread agreement that required state courses and exams do not adequately prepare licensees to sell real estate,” said Stephen Brobeck, a CFA senior fellow and author of the report. “I recently earned a real estate sales license and am neither qualified nor capable of facilitating home sales on my own.”
According to the Consumer Federation of America, about 1.5 million real estate agents compete to sell 5 million to 6 million homes a year and earn a median net annual income of about $25,000.

As the owner of 13 ReMax Select offices in Western Pennsylvania, Mr. Murphy has made it company policy to have a strictly full-time real estate sales force.
“There are no part-time teachers here,” he said. “They have a place in the real estate business. Just not at ReMax Select brand.”
He said part-time agents usually also have a spouse supporting the family.
“My agents are usually breadwinners in their family,” Mr. Murphy said. “My competitors have great agents, too. But it’s culturally different at my company. They have to make a living.”
Some agents who start out selling one or two homes a year go on to greater things, Mr. Petrack said.
“Sitting in this industry for over 40 years, I will tell you there are new people in the business only doing three transactions the first or second year who end up being superstars down the road.”
But the part-time agents who flooded the market in the past three years nibble away business from true professionals, Mr. Murphy said.
“They may sell one or two homes a year. But you look at that,” he said. “That’s 3,000 or 4,000 agents that sold one property. That’s a lot of properties. “
His agents — like most in the industry — work on 100% commission. And they’ve found more success being on the listing side of the transaction, especially in markets where multiple buyers are bidding for a home.
In that scenario, only one buyer’s agent wins. But the listing agent has a guaranteed win.
“Not to say we don’t work with buyers,” Mr. Murphy said. “We certainly do. But not someone who wants a home — someone who needs a home. Meaning: you’ve got to work only with buyers who are serious about it.”
Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com or 412-779-5834






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.