A Toronto developer is walking away from a controversial condominium development at the Irish Centre site in Squirrel Hill, about two weeks after the Pittsburgh Zoning Board of Adjustment rejected the plan.

Craft Development Corporation has decided against appealing the board’s ruling to Allegheny County Common Pleas Court, bringing an end to its attempt to redevelop the vacant property.

In an Oct. 30 decision, the three-member board rejected the variances needed for the eight-story building.

Craft wanted to build to nearly 88 feet in a zoning district where the maximum height permitted was 40 feet. It also sought to develop in a parks district where multi-family residential is not permitted. In each case, the board said no.

Advertise with us

The developer, it stated, “was unable to present sufficient, credible evidence to meet its burden with respect to all of the legal standards that apply to both use and dimensions variances.”

Asked why Craft decided not to appeal, Luigi Buordolone, a company co-owner, stated, “I think it’s fairly self-explanatory given the neighborhood and the decision that was rendered. So we’re just not going to get involved.”

The ruling was a big victory for opponents of the 160-unit project, including Frick Park Friends, a group made up largely of Swisshelm Park residents who live near the Irish Centre site.

In a statement, Frick Park Friends said Wednesday that it was “very pleased” that there would be no appeal and that it was looking forward to “having someone purchase the Irish Centre property for use complying with Park zone guidelines.”

Since it won’t be appealing, Craft won’t follow through with the purchase of the Irish Centre site at 6886 Forward Ave., leaving the future of the property in limbo.

Advertise with us

As controversy swirled about the proposed condo development, Phipps Conservatory and Botanical Gardens submitted a plan to the zoning board in September to turn the Irish Centre site into a nursery and space for a program to bring fresh produce to city food deserts should the panel reject the Craft variances.

But Jim Graven, Irish Centre board president, said Wednesday that his group has heard nothing from Phipps since it sent its letter to the zoning board two months ago outlining its plan.

“To the best of my knowledge, there has been no communication,” he said.

Mr. Graven added the Irish Centre property was on the market for a year and half before Craft became involved. During that time, Phipps never contacted anyone about interest in the real estate, he said.

It was only after Craft reached an agreement for a possible reuse of the property “that somebody from Phipps called me and expressed an interest,” he related.

Advertise with us

A spokesman for Phipps did not respond to an email seeking comment.

In its decision, the zoning board stated that it did not consider the Phipps letter in its deliberations, explaining that the missive “did not assert any direct, substantial or immediate interest related to the application at issue.”

In its statement, Frick Park Friends urged Phipps to pursue a purchase.

“Our sincere hope is that Phipps and the Irish Centre can come to an agreement since it would be a win, win, win. The Irish Centre would sell their property, Phipps would be able to implement a great program, and Frick Park would have an environmentally focused land steward next door,” it stated.

“Phipps’s proposed plan for the parcel fits within the zoning, would have minimal impact on the character of the area and Frick, and would be a benefit to the entire Pittsburgh/regional community ... we really couldn’t ask for a better outcome.”

Advertise with us

Irish Centre officials, Mr. Graven said, will continue to try to market the property, which includes a two-story community building, a two-story house, an in-ground pool and surface parking.

“The problem is that there’s so much to be done with that facility. It would be difficult for us to do it. It needs a lot of investment,” he said.

At the same time, he noted that officials are in no hurry to sell the property.

“It’s unfortunate,” he said. “I spent a lot of years trying to save the Irish Centre.”

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com