When a small independent coffee shop opened for business on Banksville Road a few years ago, Dan O’Connell knew its days were numbered.
“It was located on the PM side of the road,” he said. “They had the grand opening and there was nobody in line for the drive-thru when my daughter and I drove past at 8:30 a.m.
“There’s an AM and a PM side of the highway,” Mr. O’Connell, vice president of Premier Retail Support in Upper St. Clair, explained. “The AM side of traffic is heading into work. The PM side is the coming home side.”
The coffee shop is long gone. A Dunkin Donuts recently opened nearby on the AM side of Banksville Road and appears to be thriving. Mr. O’Connell said its drive-thru is so busy the right lane of traffic is often backed up with cars waiting in line.
There is an art and science to business site selection that big corporations tend to value, but small business owners don’t always know about.
The odds of success are already stacked against new businesses. According to the U.S. Small Business Administration, roughly 70% of all new businesses survive the first two years. Beyond that, the chances of success fall to about 50% at five years.

Last year, there were 5.07 million applications filed to start new businesses, according to Census data. That marks a 6.2% annual decrease from the previous year and the first time the number of business applications has fallen since 2018.
With the stakes higher than ever, the science around business site selection has had to become more precise.
Gut instincts still play a role in decision making, but the technology around site selection has advanced in recent years to a point where cell phone tracking data has been added to the tool box.
Site selectors now have methods to follow every move consumers make in shopping centers, malls and other retail venues. This kind of historical data on shopping patterns gives businesses an edge when selecting a location to set up shop.
“You can actually look at heat maps of a shopping center that show precisely where the traffic is in that shopping center based upon tracking their cell phones,” said Herky Pollock, executive vice president at CBRE, Downtown.
“The evolution of site selection has gotten so technical that it barely resembles the site selection techniques of yesteryear,” he said.
Location, location, location
It’s not surprising that the most sought after high-traffic corridors are also the most expensive.
There’s no longer much vacant ground to build on in hot retail markets like Shadyside, McKnight Road in Ross or South Hills Village in Mt. Lebanon. And businesses that want to operate there will pay top dollar for anything that’s available.
Finding new land to build on outside the hot spots is no picnic either.
James Wilding Jr., president of Jabe Companies in Carnegie, mostly represents retail chains that want to expand — no small feat today as the inventory for prime retail locations in Western Pennsylvania is scarcer than ever, he said.
“That has a lot to do with the fact that our topography in Pittsburgh is very challenging,” he said, adding that getting building permits is difficult and the cost of building — labor and materials — has skyrocketed.
The higher cost of borrowing money and the lack of labor for building contractors have contributed the slowdown in new construction of retail sites. “It’s harder to find workers, and commodities like steel and air conditioners cost more. Everything is more expensive,” Mr. Wilding said.
“What we’re really facing right now is there’s very little new construction of shopping centers. So therefore, there’s a lot more competition for the space that is vacant.”
The low inventory of prime space available has kept Pittsburgh’s commercial retail market strong despite shifting consumer spending trends, according to the region’s biggest commercial brokers and developers.
“We are seeing perhaps the greatest shortage of retail space in my career, which spans 37 years,” Mr. Pollock, of CBRE, said. “And that is largely due to retailers looking to expand.”
Binders full of wisdom
After three decades in site selection, Mr. Wilding has seen small business owners make some of the same mistakes over and over. One of the most common is paying too much for rent.
“They find locations to rent that are too costly for them to make a profit,” he said.
“Or they choose locations where they don’t have the foot traffic necessary for them to be successful.”
Customers usually make spontaneous choices to visit a restaurant or a retail business, so visibility is the number one factor.
Other businesses — like an insurance office or a dental practice, for example — don’t need to be as visible and can take advantage of cheaper rents off the beaten path, Mr. Wilding said.
Mr. O’Connell, a 30-year commercial real estate veteran, created a three-ring binder with everything he knows about site selection to answer questions he got over and over from the 1,600 franchise owners he used to work with at United Franchise Group.
”I was constantly repeating this same information,” he said, adding that he has personally worked on leases for over 2 million feet of space.
He started putting all of his knowledge together sequentially and it turned out to be hundreds of pages of content. The information is now posted on his company’s website and includes “everything from how you analyze the demographics, what goes into site selection, what goes into a letter of intent, and what terminologies go into a lease.”
“The mature brands know this stuff,” he said. “The mom and pops haven’t a clue. And many of them are signing leases for the first time.”
Sometimes, it’s not about finding the site itself but the language of the lease that can make or break a business.
Mr. O’Connell saw the owners of another small business make a fatal mistake when they opened in Bethel Park a year ago. During the grand opening in August 2022, he noticed the restaurant owners were giving away free beer.
He asked the manager why she was doing that.
“She said it was because, ‘We don’t have our liquor license yet and the rent was ready to start. So, we had to start paying rent and we can’t sell the beer without a license.
“And I said, ‘Why didn’t you have a liquor license contingency in your lease?’ She said she didn’t know about that.’”
The restaurant shut down soon afterwards and the space on South Park Road remains vacant.
“I don’t know if not being able to sell beer was the killing factor. But it’s one of the things that contributed to it,” Mr. O’Connell said.
“They were open less than a year,” he said. “It breaks my heart that they went out of business.”
Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com or 412-779-5834






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.