The widely criticized owner of West Mifflin’s desolate Century III Mall, Century III Mall PA LLC, appealed the borough’s June decision to condemn the building due to myriad safety concerns — just days after parts of the roof collapsed into piles of debris.

The company’s action will set up a court battle and could lead to a chain of appeals between the two camps that would delay officials' goals of demolishing the structure by months or even years.

“It was to be expected,” Councilman Dan Davis said. “All the promises they made haven’t come true.”

Borough council estimated that razing the building would cost $10 million to $15 million, and that number could rise the longer the structure sits vacant and deteriorates. Century III closed permanently in 2019, becoming a magnet for crime and vandalism in the years since.

Advertise with us

Two weeks ago, the mall appealed a $240,000 fine levied for failing to remediate problems involving rampant weed growth, unsafe structures and unsanitary conditions. The company has not paid the fine and is still delinquent on an $80,000 fine levied in 2018.

Century III Mall PA LLC is due in court on Oct. 17 for the fines and local officials hope the condemnation scuffle will be merged into that legal proceeding to “show a stronger case,” Mr. Davis said.

Borough council voted to condemn the mall after a June hearing where police officers, firefighters and code enforcement officers presented evidence of the building’s mounting safety concerns. They flashed several photos — mold, shattered glass, splintering ceilings — drawing outrage from community members. In April, a fire did significant damage to the food court.

Mike Wuerthele, a structural engineer the mall called as a witness, said at the hearing that the mall is structurally sound.

“It’s my opinion that the level of damage could be remediated,” Mr. Wuerthele said.

Advertise with us

Last week, the roof caved in where the fire had raged. The collapse came two months after a trespassing teen fell through the roof and sustained serious injuries. He’s expected to recover.

“This creates more danger,” Mr. Davis said, “if someone gets on the roof and doesn’t realize where they’re walking and where it’s structurally unsound.”

Chief Operating Officer Shawl Pryor said at the hearing that the mall planned to put up a fence around the mall to deter trespassers, but that has yet to happen.

Century III Mall PA LLC bought Century III in 2013 for $10.5 million and pledged to redevelop it, but since then the building has fallen into disrepair.

Mr. Davis said council members have been in talks with county and state officials about raising funds for demolition, but would not disclose details about the conversations.

Advertise with us

Neena Hagen: nhagen@post-gazette.com

Correction, posted May 28, 2025: In an earlier version of the story, the owner of Century III Mall was identified incorrectly, and additional details in the story related to the previously identified owner have been removed.