After a two-hour hearing Wednesday evening — where dozens of outraged West Mifflin residents and officials poured into council chambers to recommend demolishing the borough’s once-thriving Century III Mall — councilmembers said they would wait to take a vote.

Multiple borough officials described a litany of incidents over the years — including fires, vandalism and health hazards — that continue to vex first responders and strain borough resources.

An official condemnation could allow elected officials to ask the county and state for funds to demolish the crumbling building.

Since shuttering for good in 2019, the mall has spiraled into disrepair. During testimony, Walter Anthony, West Mifflin’s director of community development, flashed dozens of photos — mold covering the floors, ceilings falling in, shattered glass strewn everywhere — drawing gasps from the crowd.

Advertise with us

“I don’t believe there’s a window intact in the mall,” Mr. Anthony said.

While the mall was flagged as “unsafe” by code enforcement officers four years ago, owner Century III Mall PA LLC has yet to fix any problems. The company was previously fined $80,000 for prior code violations related to weed growth  — all unpaid, records show.

Representatives from the mall’s owner turned up to field complaints but provided few details on their plans to remediate the ongoing problems.

Chief Operating Officer Shawl Pryor said the company recently hired security guards to patrol the grounds, which came as news to councilmembers. An engineer hired by the company performed an inspection, but said he could not conclude whether parts of the mall were structurally unsound, despite a raft of evidence presented by West Mifflin officials.

While some of the mall’s deterioration results from a lack of building maintenance, local mischief makers haven’t helped.

Advertise with us

Gregory McCulloch, West Mifflin’s police chief, testified that his department has been dispatched to the mall 177 times since the start of 2019 for trespassing, vandalism and occasional violence.

In some cases, witnesses to break-ins and other crimes don’t even call the police. Chief McCulloch said a maintenance worker on the premises caught a man, armed with a long gun, spraying bullets throughout the abandoned building. Police weren’t informed of the incident until weeks later.

“It’s a horrendous atmosphere,” Chief McCulloch said. “I will not permit my officers, unless it's life or death, to enter that mall.”

And the problems have only snowballed in recent months. In April, a fire tore through part of the food court, laying waste to several restaurants and eateries. Inspectors said the ceiling at the site of the fire is in danger of “imminent collapse.”

Less than two weeks ago, a teenager fell through the mall’s structurally unsound roof, puncturing a lung and fracturing his back. It took officers more than 20 minutes to find the victim and an additional 20 minutes for medics to evacuate him, Chief McCulloch testified.

Advertise with us

The emergency ignited ire among West Mifflin community members.

“That mall used to be one of the prime places to go … now it looks like crap,” Bernice Nylander, a lifelong West Mifflin resident, said to council. “You guys are doing nothing.”

“If one of your kids falls through the roof and is killed, then are we going to do something?”

The mall’s neighbors have felt the ripple effects of its descent into ruin. The adjacent road, a crucial thoroughfare, is now nearly undriveable.

“I had my tire blown out by one of those potholes,” said Ernest Rascati, 53, who lives right behind the mall.

Advertise with us

The ultimate goal of the hearing, borough officials said, is to demolish the ailing structure and pitch the 63-acre plot of land to a developer that could build anew, but West Mifflin would need to solicit funds from the county and the state, because representatives from the mall said they don’t plan on demolition.

It’s estimated that tearing down the 1.2 million square foot monstrosity could cost upward of $10 million — five times the current property value of the mall, according to county assessment data.

So far, borough officials have approached Sen. Jim Brewster and Lt. Gov. Austin Davis, with plans to speak with U.S. Sen. John Fetterman, D-Pa., who has spent much of his political career fighting blight.

As the years wear away and the mall continues to deteriorate, community members aren’t going away.

“I’m actually sick to my stomach,” said Lauren Rowe, an art teacher at West Mifflin Area High School. “My community deserves better and we have seen enough over the past 10  years.”

Advertise with us

Neena Hagen: nhagen@post-gazette.com 

Correction, posted May 28, 2025: In an earlier version of this story, the owner of Century III Mall was identified incorrectly, and the description of prior fines assessed in 2018 omitted the specific code violation, which has been added.