If the circumstances in the state next door are any indication, a new plan to install public restrooms in Pittsburgh’s Downtown may be flush with its share of hurdles.

The city of Columbus, Ohio has been sued by a downtown property owner claiming that locating a public restroom close to its business will drive away customers.

It’s a situation that Pittsburgh stakeholders might want to consider as they move ahead with a plan to install three trailer-like public restrooms in Downtown in a bid to curb public urination and defecation and to provide relief for visitors, workers and residents.

John Valentine, the executive director of the Pittsburgh Downtown Neighbors Alliance, acknowledged Monday that officials must be careful in deciding where the restrooms should go.

Advertise with us

That means balancing the interests of the homeless, businesses and restaurants, residents and others with a stake in what happens in the Golden Triangle.

“Everybody is really considering the homeless. They’re down on their luck. We don’t want to hurt them. We want to help them,” he said.

“On the other hand, we have to think of the business owner who invested $1 million in their business. We can’t hurt their business, either. People who go to restaurants aren’t going to want to go there if there’s a restroom in front of it or right next to it.”

Mr. Valentine was instrumental in getting Point Park University to do a study last year that addressed the need for public restrooms in Downtown. As a former restaurateur, he said he wouldn’t want one next to his restaurant.

“I would say the key to making it work is doing due diligence in finding the right locations, what makes the most sense from a homeless person’s point of view ... and also from a business person’s point of view,” he said.

Advertise with us

The Allegheny Conference on Community Development, the Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership, and other stakeholders, including Mayor Ed Gainey, announced last week that three public restrooms will be installed next month in the central business district as part of a six-month pilot program.

Just where they will go has yet to be determined.

In his remarks last week, Jeremy Waldrup, CEO and executive director of the Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership, said the restrooms would be located in high-traffic areas where they would be “very visible and utilized.” He did not respond to a request for comment Monday.

Mr. Gainey also stressed at that meeting that officials are considering locations where the restrooms wouldn’t “infringe on business.”

The restrooms will be open and staffed from 7 a.m. to 11 p.m. daily and equipped with running water, heat and air conditioning. The goal is to use the six-month pilot program as a launch pad to make the facilities permanent.

Advertise with us

Last year’s Point Park study on public restrooms recommended putting them in high-traffic areas such as Market Square, the Cultural District, transit hubs and Mellon Square.

Heather Starr Fiedler, chair of Point Park’s department of community engagement and leadership who led the study, said locations near the bridges leading to the North Shore stadiums also could be good.

The public restroom initiative will be funded as part of at least $2 million raised by the Allegheny Conference in a bid to address issues like safety, cleanliness and lewd behavior in Downtown.

Money also will be used to fund the Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership’s clean team, improve health outreach efforts, increase programming in Market and Mellon squares, and enhance public realm lighting.

Ohio’s capital city is spending more than $2 million in federal COVID-19 relief dollars to install three public restrooms by this fall.

Advertise with us

It originally earmarked $875,000 in 2021 to fund five public restrooms. But two years later, the costs have ballooned and the number of toilets has been cut by two, according to WOSU public media.

Earlier this month, the Tonti Organization, through affiliate Broad and High Corp., sued to prevent one of the Portland Loo restrooms from being installed in a public right-of-way next to its property at North High and West Lynn streets.

The prefabricated Portland Loo model is made of stainless steel with one toilet inside and a wash station outside. It typically is set up on street corners, WOSU reported.

In the lawsuit, Tonti maintained that its property is located in a “highly desirable area for future improvement and development” and that putting a restroom so close by will jeopardize its ability to “develop the property in the future.” It also claimed that construction will block access to the real estate.

Given that, the suit argued, “clear and convincing evidence exists that loss of access to plaintiff’s property will result in damages to plaintiff through the loss of customers and business income.”

Advertise with us

It further charges that locating public toilets so close imposes undue burdens and restrictions on Tonti’s property and essentially amounts to a government taking without compensation in violation of the U.S. and Ohio constitutions.

The two other public restrooms proposed in Columbus are to be located at West Long and North High streets and at North Third and East Broad streets.

While the Allegheny Conference and the PDP hope to install the Downtown Pittsburgh restrooms next month, an exact timetable has yet to be developed.

Placing them will be the real balancing act, Mr. Valentine emphasized.

“I think we really have to look and see what makes sense,” he said.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com