A move by the Allegheny County Sanitary Authority to secure a North Side building over the owner’s objections may have just gotten a bit more complicated.

Jeff Holmes, the owner of the old brick warehouse at 855 South Canal St., is working with Preservation Pittsburgh to get a city historic designation for the building.

Such a designation, if approved, would not prevent Alcosan from taking the property through eminent domain, as it has filed in court to do. But it would prevent the authority from demolishing it or making wholesale alterations to the exterior.

“I want to keep the building and I can’t,” Mr. Holmes said. “The least I can do is make sure the building isn’t going down in the future for a frickin’ high rise.”

Advertise with us

Alcosan filed a declaration of taking in the county’s Common Pleas Court earlier this year as part of an effort to secure the real estate it needs for a regional tunnel system project.

By order of a federal consent decree, the authority is required to reduce the amount of sewage-laced stormwater that flows into Pittsburgh rivers whenever it rains.

Just how much of an impact — if any — a historic designation would have on Alcosan’s plans is unclear. Authority officials did not respond to several emails seeking comment.

Mr. Holmes said Alcosan has told him in the past that it does not plan to tear down the warehouse but rather use it as a base of operations for the tunnel work.

In fact, the businessman, who operates Babcor Packaging Corp. and MrTakeOutBags from the building, has offered to lease the property to the authority while it is doing the project. But Alcosan, he said, has rejected the overture, arguing the site could be part of a construction zone for years.

Advertise with us

Mr. Holmes said Preservation Pittsburgh reached out to him about nominating the building for a city historic designation.

“I figured why not, right?” he said.

Although Alcosan hasn’t indicated it plans to tear down the building, “if they ever did, it’s a little bit of a problem” if there is the historic designation, he said.

In nominating the structure, Preservation Pittsburgh claimed it is historic for several reasons.

The building, used for decades as a community center, has ties to the Allegheny Turner Association that served German immigrants. It was designed by prominent Austrian-American architect Joseph Stiller.

Advertise with us

It also was part of the H.J. Heinz Company North Side empire for seven years before the ketchup maker sold it in 1926.

City Planning Commission members were briefed on the nomination and will vote on it next week. It then will go to City Council for action.

While Mr. Holmes has all but given up his fight to keep the property, he is still battling Alcosan over the proper compensation for it.

According to Mr. Holmes, the authority has offered him $1.6 million, an estimate that includes not only the value of the real estate but compensation for a rooftop cellphone tower that provides income.

Mr. Holmes countered that it is not enough.

Advertise with us

His appraiser has estimated that value at $2.7 million. And that does even include the cellphone tower, which has been appraised at another $310,000. That brings the total property value to $3 million.

Mr. Holmes said his attorney is in the process of exchanging appraisals with Alcosan as part of the negotiations.

The authority is required to provide “just compensation” for the real estate. In a statement in February when the Post-Gazette first reported on Mr. Holmes' battle, Alcosan stated that it was committed to obtaining the property in a “reasoned and thoughtful manner, and through consultation with our designers and engineers.”

And while the authority would not comment on specific offers, it was “committed to fully paying property owners just compensation, and other monies that the owners of the property are entitled to receive” under the state’s property acquisition and condemnation law.

Sometimes that doesn’t amount to much, Mr. Holmes maintained. He said he is entitled to an allowance of $4,000 for an appraisal and legal work. In reality, the appraisal itself cost $4,700, he noted.

Advertise with us

“That’s an example of how antiquated it is,” he said.

Meanwhile, as Alcosan advances plans to take Mr. Holmes’ property, it has assured him that he will not have to vacate the premises for 90 days — starting Tuesday.

While neither Mr. Holmes nor his attorney see that as a hard and fast timetable, the businessman said it comes at a time when he has yet to be able to secure another location for his thriving packaging company, particularly given what the authority is offering.

“Trying to find another building for $1.6 million is not happening. For a company our size, it’s more than $3 million,” he said.

Babcor employs nearly 20 people, many of whom live in the city. Should he venture into the suburbs, he fears he may lose some of those employees.

Advertise with us

While a historic designation might prevent Alcosan from tearing down the building, it won’t prevent it from taking the property where Mr. Holmes has operated his business for more than three decades.

“I don’t know how to stop it and my attorney said I can’t,” he said.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com