After the former Civic Arena was demolished in 2012, the city gave the Sports & Exhibition Authority 11 years to use the land for parking while it was being redeveloped.
It turned out not to be enough time.
Whether you chalk it up to delays, the slow pace of development, or other reasons, the SEA was back before the city’s Zoning Board of Adjustment Thursday seeking an indefinite extension of the parking use while the Pittsburgh Penguins continue to redevelop the 28-acre site.
Doug Straley, SEA project executive, said he was “very hopeful” the Penguins would move quickly in transforming the rest of the lower Hill District land so that the requested extension won’t be a long one.
He noted that the Penguins, who hold the development rights to the publicly owned real estate, have started construction on a 26-story office tower to be anchored by First National Bank and are close to kicking off work on a live music venue and 910-space parking garage to be built next to it.
When the zoning board first approved the special exception and variance needed to allow temporary parking in 2012, the number of spaces involved was 862, Mr. Straley said. But with the build-out of streets within the site as well as the office project, that number has been whittled down to 368.
Read More
“Eventually, though, we still believe, like we said originally, that this parking will be developed,” he said. “We can’t tell you the exact time frame of that development but in the end it no longer would be surface parking.”
There are still four parcels below Fullerton Street being used for parking.
Of those four, the Penguins are “very locked in” on two and have already begun the development process, Mr. Straley said. The team has “a concept” in mind for a third, but has yet to submit a letter of intent to start the project.
Mr. Straley did not elaborate on the plans during the hearing and did not respond to an email seeking more specifics.
However, the Penguins have notified the SEA and the city Urban Redevelopment Authority, the owners of the site, that they intend to start the first phase of residential housing on a 3.2-acre parcel bordered by Fullerton Street and Centre, Wylie and Bedford avenues.
That would be in line with the parcels still in need of development.
According to a letter of intent submitted to the SEA, that $115.6 million residential development would feature as many as seven stories containing about 340 apartments plus 21,000 square feet of ground-level retail and 176 parking spaces, with 101 of those reserved for residents.
In keeping with the mandates of a community collaboration and implementation plan, 20% of the units — about 68 in all — would be designated for households at 60% to 80% of the area median income. For a two-person household, that would equate to incomes of $45,540 to $60,720, based on 2022 calculations.
Of the units, the Penguins are planning 251 one-bedroom and 77 two-bedroom, according to the letter of intent. The overall estimated monthly rent would be $1,890.
The Penguins have said they hope to close on the land needed for the first phase by the end of the year.
Mr. Straley said the fourth parcel still used for parking was once reserved for the construction of a new headquarters for U.S. Steel. But that deal fell apart in 2016 at a time when the steelmaker was struggling financially.
He added he hasn’t heard of any new development plans for that piece.
“I think it’s proposed to be office but the office market’s a little soft right now,” he said.
At the least, the SEA would need to retain the temporary parking until the new parking garage is finished in two years, officials said.
“In light of the continuing development and the lack of the construction of the permanent parking, we believe that it is imperative that the interim parking approval be extended until that development is finalized,” said Alex Lacey, attorney for the SEA.
While the SEA asked for an open-ended extension, Mr. Lacey added that the zoning board could limit it to the completion of the parking garage or “some other key development.”
Without an extension, the SEA’s right to use the land for temporary parking would expire on June 14.
Mr. Straley said the zoning board placed the initial 11-year limit on the parking as a way to make sure the land was being developed.
At the time, some community stakeholders raised concerns that the Penguins would be content to simply collect parking revenue from the site since that money accrued to the team.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.