A judge has rejected an attempt by Pittsburgh International Airport officials to bar the public — and the media — from a hearing Friday to determine whether they had the right to boot the operator of its popular airmall from the terminal.
Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Christine Ward denied the eight-page motion filed by the county’s airport authority Thursday, a spokesperson for the jurist said.
In its motion earlier Thursday, the authority claimed that security-related information to be discussed at the preliminary injunction hearing Friday could jeopardize public safety at Pittsburgh International.
Such hearings typically are open to the public.
The authority, which oversees Pittsburgh International, also argued that it believes some of the data to be discussed is classified as “sensitive security information” by the U.S. Transportation Security Administration which operates the airport’s checkpoints.
In also seeking to seal the transcript of the hearing from public view, the authority claimed that the release of the information could be “detrimental to transportation security.”
Read More
The move comes after the authority earlier this month terminated the lease of airmall operator Fraport Pittsburgh and escorted its employees from the airport, claiming that the company was in default of its contract, in part because of security breaches that impacted public safety.
After filing a complaint in Common Pleas Court over the termination, Fraport won a special injunction from Judge Ward to stay on the job in advance of Friday’s hearing.
In the motion to bar the public, the airport authority maintained that it needed to be able to “openly and thoroughly discuss the security issues at the heart of this contract dispute, and the court needs to gain a fulsome understanding of these issues in order to make its decision” on the preliminary injunction motion.
“Public safety could also be threatened if the airport security-related information is publicly available, as those who wish to do harm to the public may learn details about security practices and protocols that could enable them to undermine security at Pittsburgh International Airport and threaten public safety,” the motion stated.
The authority had detailed some of the alleged security breaches in its own earlier response to the Fraport complaint.
It maintained some of the most serious breaches involved Fraport’s failure to make daily airmall inspections as required under the operator’s contract, leading to instances where metal knives, hammers, screwdrivers, and a pair of scissors were left in places at the airport accessible to the public.
However, Fraport has contended that the authority “misrepresented minor operational issues as material defaults warranting termination of the master lease” and that the agency was looking to “find something, anything” to try to force an eviction.
In a brief filed Wednesday in support of its request for a preliminary injunction to prevent the authority from terminating its lease, Fraport argued that at issue were not “a myriad of so-called ‘defaults,’ many of which were immaterial or contrived in nature” but that it rejected the agency’s offer to buy out its contract for $5 million.
Fraport’s lease runs until the end of 2029.
The authority, Fraport suggested, “decided to take for free by force what it could not buy for $5 million — that is, the ACAA’s exclusive control over the concessions program at the PIT Airport.”
“After never alleging any significant concerns regarding Fraport’s operations for 30 years, over the past 10 months, the ACAA has raised a host of issues that it alleged constituted potential ‘events of default’ under the master lease,” the airmall operator stated.
Fraport attorneys could not be reached for comment Thursday.
“We have no additional comment as the filing speaks for itself. We will proceed as scheduled,” the authority said in a statement Thursday.
Melissa Melewsky, media law counsel for the Pennsylvania NewsMedia Association, said that constitutionally the judicial system and its proceedings are required to be open to the public.
She noted the airport authority would have had a “heavy burden” to meet in order to try to exclude the public.
“They would have to prove their allegations. They just can’t say it might be bad for us,” she said.
Ms. Melewsky also wondered how a contract dispute over a concessions contract could threaten the airport’s security.
“I could see it if it was a contractor who provided security services or security personnel or equipment that had to do with the radar. A concessionaire selling food and drinks? The security risk isn’t readily apparent,” she said.
In its brief in support of a preliminary injunction to keep it on the job, Fraport argued that travelers likely would face “significant disruptions to commercial operations” if it is evicted.
“The ACAA does not have the personnel, know-how, or other resources to effectively carry out the commercial operations or a concession plan at the PIT Airport. Therefore, the public will be harmed by the interruption in commercial operations at the PIT Airport,” it stated.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.