After nearly a year of controversy, a developer has won a key victory in its bid to bring hundreds of new apartments and a grocery to part of Oakland.
In a 8-1 vote Tuesday, City Council approved a zoning change that clears the way for developer Walnut Capital to begin work on the first phase of its ambitious Oakland Crossings plan.
The lone no vote came from Councilwoman Deborah Gross.
With the decision, Walnut Capital will be able to advance plans for the construction of a 426-unit apartment building and a full-service grocery at the former Quality Inn site at the end of Halket Street adjacent to the Boulevard of the Allies.
The proposed complex represents the first phase of a broader redevelopment that involves 13 acres along Halket, the boulevard, and the former Isaly's site on the boulevard.
“It’s a huge step forward, one we’ve been working on for close to a year,” Walnut Capital president Todd Reidbord said in response to council’s approval.
Read More
The fact that the zoning change was approved on a 8-1 vote, Mr. Reidbord maintained, shows Oakland Crossings has broad support beyond those who opposed parts of the plan, including Oakland Planning and Development Corp. and the Oakcliffe Community Organization.
“You can’t satisfy all but we do think it’s a validation of the work we’re trying to do in growing the city,” he said.
The change approved by council creates a new urban center mixed-use zoning classification. It allows for a base height of 65 feet along Halket. But with bonuses, Walnut Capital can build as high as 120 feet north of Louisa Street toward Forbes Avenue and to 185 feet south of Louisa toward the boulevard.
At the Isaly’s site, the developer is limited to 85 feet bordering Niagara Street but can go as high as 185 feet at the back of the site, which is owned by UPMC. The higher heights concerned some residents and planning commission members.
The proposed 12-story apartment building Walnut Capital plans to build in the first phase comes close to the maximum 185-foot height south of Louisa.
In approving the zoning change, council added an amendment that extended the length from 400 feet to 425 feet for groceries. Mr. Reidbord said the extra space was needed for loading and unloading purposes.
He added all deliveries and trash collection will be done inside the grocery Walnut Capital is planning at the former Quality Inn site. Its partner in the housing and grocery development is the University of Pittsburgh.
Approval of the zoning change sets the stage for a development activities meeting next month during which the public can hear details about the proposed apartment and grocery complex and then make comments.
The proposal then would go before the city planning commission for a public hearing and vote.
If all goes according to plan, Walnut Capital hopes to begin construction on the first phase by year end or early next year.
In voting against the zoning change, councilwoman Gross stated that she didn’t believe the bill went through the proper process. She thought the amended bill should have gone back to the planning commission for a recommendation.
However, the change won the support of council President Theresa Kail-Smith.
"I just want to thank Councilman [Bruce] Kraus for his work on the urban plan. I think he's done a tremendous job trying to balance the needs of the community, both old and new in the area,” she said.
The zoning change resulted from controversy over Walnut Capital’s initial plan, which was advanced by former Mayor Bill Peduto and encompassed 18 acres in Central and South Oakland.
A scaled-down version worked out between Mayor Ed Gainey, who took office in January, and Walnut Capital eliminated McKee Place, Louisa, and Zulema Park from the plan and did away with a proposal to add a new subdistrict to five existing public realm districts in Oakland.
As part of the compromise, Walnut Capital also agreed to make at least 10% of the units affordable to households at or below 50% of the area median income for a minimum of 35 years.
In opposing the zoning change, the Oakcliffe community group stated that it would result in a loss of residential compatibility standards and an “extreme increase in allowable building heights.”
Mr. Reidbord argued the council vote showed that the “vast, vast majority of the people” were in favor of what Walnut Capital is proposing.
“This was not like a narrow victory. There was overwhelming support for this project,” he said.
During a preliminary vote last week, councilwoman Erika Strassburger also voiced concerns about the process but added she was supporting the change because of the need for more housing in the city.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262. Staff writer Hallie Lauer contributed to this story.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.