A developer has hooked the Pittsburgh Planning Commission with the big changes it has made to a Strip District office tower that will replace the building best known for the giant smiling fish sign on its side.
Nearly three months after rejecting the original design, commission members unanimously approved a revised rendition Tuesday that clears the way for the project to begin.
Developer JMC Holdings won over the commission by replacing the 21-story block-like design with four “mini-towers” ranging from 19 to 23 floors with rooftop terraces on each.
In addition, JMC extended the bleacher seating and steps that are part of a covered colonnade that runs the length of Smallman Street and widened an adjacent plaza.
It did so to address commission concerns that the colonnade, which is part of the city’s public space requirements for the building, might not feel welcoming to visitors.
In rejecting the original design, commission members complained about the building’s massing and its lack of context to the surrounding neighborhood, with its low-slung buildings and gritty vibe.
Read More
On Tuesday, Commission Chairman Christine Mondor, who had likened the original design to an “elite tower in the sky,” had a more generous view of the revised plan.
The developer, she said, ended up “making lemonade out of what might have been considered a lemon by some.”
“The changes that you made, it shows that you were listening to our concerns and that you embraced some of the limitations that those concerns might have represented and kind of turned them to amenities in the building, whether it’s the outdoor spaces that you created on the tower or the sensitive integration of the wheelchair areas in the steps on the ground level,” she said.
Ms. Mondor was the only commission member to address the revised design Tuesday.
However, at a briefing two weeks ago, Becky Mingo, another member who criticized the original design, liked the makeover, saying it “begins to sort of make this building a building that can be about Pittsburgh.” She voted in favor of it Tuesday.
In the redesign, New York-based JMC positioned the 23-story mini-tower to face Downtown, while directing the smallest one at 19 stories toward the Strip. The two other towers are 21 stories.
The developer added the terraces to the rooftops as well as balconies on office floors.
“I truly believe the net result for us is a better building,” said Matt Cassin, JMC founder and managing partner.
“On balance, we’re really pleased and even more enthusiastic than we were when we started the process.”
Even after the revisions, the complex at 1501 Penn Avenue still would dwarf all others in the Strip by far, where the next tallest building is about 10 stories.
It actually will look higher than 23 stories in the middle because of the addition of translucent glass to hide rooftop mechanical equipment.
That feature will “gently glow at night” and can change color, architect Brandon Haw said, promising that it wouldn’t become “some sort of eyesore beacon with light pollution everywhere.”
He added that he hopes the complex will set a “good precedent” for future development in the area. The site is in the Golden Triangle zoning district, which allows JMC to build to the height it is proposing.
The retail and office project, which also will feature 846 parking spaces and 122 spaces for bicycles, will be built at the site of the former New Federal Cold Storage warehouse.
That bunker-like building with the giant smiling fish on the side facing Downtown will be demolished to make way for the new complex, although the foundation will be reused.
JMC plans to start taking down the building early next year, Mr. Cassin said. It hopes to have the complex built in 2023, but will wait until it secures a tenant for some of the office floors before starting work.
The developer has been open to suggestions about the future of the sign.
“We know it’s an important, iconic sign. We want to see it find its rightful home,” Mr. Cassin said.
Also Tuesday, the commission approved plans for the construction of a 114-unit boutique apartment building at Penn Avenue and 32nd Street in the Strip.
The commission also was briefed on the buildout for the new Target store in the former Kaufmann’s/Macy’s building on Smithfield Street. The new store bordering Smithfield and Fifth is expected to include a CVS pharmacy as well as some underground parking.
Representatives for the Minneapolis-based retailer said window treatments and other elements of the design will pay homage to the old department store’s famous clock at the corner of Fifth and Smithfield, a meeting spot for generations of Pittsburghers.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.