A developer is hoping to reel in opponents with dramatic changes to the design of a proposed 21-story office tower in the Strip District that would replace the building best known for its giant smiling fish sign.

Two months after being rebuffed by the Pittsburgh Planning Commission, JMC Holdings is proposing to carve the structure into four “mini-towers” — including one that would rise two stories higher than the 21 originally envisioned.

Two others “mini-towers” would remain at 21 stories and the other would be 19.

The complex at 1501 Penn Ave. will actually look higher than 23 stories in the middle because of the addition of translucent glass that will glow at night and hide rooftop mechanical equipment.

Advertise with us

JMC made the big changes to the design in a bid to win the approval of the commission, which had complained about the building’s massing and its lack of context with the surrounding neighborhood in rejecting the original plan.

At one point, commission Chairwoman Christine Mondor described the 21-story building as an “elite tower in the sky” and said it did not fit the character of the rest of the Strip District.

Likewise, Commissioner Becky Mingo stated, “This is not a building that says anything about Pittsburgh.”

In materials presented to the commission for a briefing Tuesday, the developer is hoping to change such sentiments. It stated that the building is at its highest on the west end facing Downtown while the smallest of the mini-towers faces the Strip.

In addition, New York-based JMC is proposing to build outdoor terraces at the top of each of the four mini-towers and on a section of the complex that features street level retail and seven levels of parking.

Advertise with us

There also would be balconies on office floors.

That all differs from the original plan, which featured one terrace on the roof of the tower as well as another on top of the parking and retail space.

In all, the tallest of the mini towers would consist of one level of retail, seven levels of parking, an amenity level, and 14 office levels.

With the new design, the idea is to break down the massing and the scale by creating the mini-towers of varying heights and by adding terraces and balconies, JMC stated in its proposal.

In a bid to further dress up the design, the developer plans to indent the corners in each of the towers and make the glass more horizontal and detailed.

Advertise with us

JMC also is paying more attention to the street level in an effort to address commission concerns about a raised colonnade along the Smallman Street side of the building that is to serve as public space.

Some commission members felt the covered colonnade, which included bleacher seating, might not feel welcoming.

To address such issues, JMC extended the bleacher seating and steps the entire length of the Smallman Street frontage and added bleachers to an adjacent plaza.

Furthermore, it increased the width of the colonnade by more than four feet and widened the plaza by 12 feet. It also added an accessibility ramp at the middle of Smallman and made other accessibility improvements.

Neither Matt Cassin, JMC founder and managing partner, nor architect Brandon Haw returned phone calls. Ms. Mondor could not be reached for comment.

Advertise with us

In rejecting the design in September, the commission left the door open for JMC to return with a revised proposal.

The new retail and office complex, which would feature 846 parking spaces and 122 spaces for bicycles, would be built on the site of the former New Federal Cold Storage warehouse.

That bunker-style building will be demolished to make way for the new development, although the foundation will be reused.

The windowless warehouse is best known for the smiling fish sign that hangs on the side facing Downtown. Mr. Cassin has said JMC is “totally open” to suggestions about the future of the sign.

Planning commission members aren’t the only ones who have had concerns about the original design of the new building. Mayor Bill Peduto also has said its massive size doesn’t fit the character of the neighborhood.

Advertise with us

However, the site is in the Golden Triangle zoning district, which allows JMC to build to the height it is proposing.

Mark Belko: 412-263-1262 or mbelko@post-gazette.com.