The lenders behind the sprawling South Fayette Newbury Market redevelopment secured a big chunk of the real estate at sheriff sale Monday, but not before a local developer made a strong play for the land before bowing out.
Thistle Financial Group, the agent for seven lenders involved in the redevelopment, paid $8.5 million for the 11 parcels — 10 commercial and one residential — that were auctioned off, said William Price, the group’s attorney.
The sheriff sale was the result of a foreclosure action that was filed against Newbury Development Associates in June seeking $24 million in principal, interest and fees.
At the time, Thistle also asked that the bulk of the property — a former brownfield along Millers Run and Presto Sygan roads off Interstate 79 — be sold at sheriff sale, with the goal being to take ownership of the site and to continue the development.
That’s what happened Monday, although it didn’t come without some drama.
The Burns Scalo real estate firm jumped into the bidding, offering $8 million for the parcels before Thistle secured them.
Read More
Jim Scalo, Burns Scalo president and CEO, said the firm has an interest in developing the land at the right price and had made the same offer to Thistle months ago.
“We really like South Fayette Township and we think it’s good land,” he said.
Burns Scalo owns the Bursca and Abele business parks in the area and also is developing the 50,000-square-foot Piazza retail complex at the former Star City Cinema site.
While Burns Scalo would have liked to have added to the collection, it wasn’t willing to bid more than $8 million, Mr. Scalo said.
One reason, he explained, is that additional privately owned parcels need to be secured to do a true master development. There also are carrying costs and infrastructure improvements that must be taken into account.
“It just didn’t make economic sense for us [to bid more than $8 million]. We have to make our numbers work,” he said.
Nonetheless, Mr. Scalo said he’s still willing to negotiate with Thistle and the lenders to try to acquire the property.
The foreclosure and sale involved about 65-70% of the site. Overall, the mixed-use development totals about 300 acres and represents about $450 million in investment.
While Newbury Market has been slow to develop, it has landed some big-name tenants, including Top Golf, a high-tech driving range and entertainment venue, and Carvana, an online used car venture that dispenses vehicles from a vending machine-like contraption. The Top Golf and Carvana parcels were not part of Monday’s sale.
BJ’s Wholesale Club also is planning to build a 99,729-square-foot store at the location. Construction could start early next year.
With the property now in hand, Thistle and the lenders it represents have several options. They could continue to develop on their own or partner with someone else to do so. Another option is to sell the real estate.
They could have a potential suitor in Burns Scalo.
“We are interested in working with the lenders,” Mr. Scalo said.
A parcel owned by the Elmhurst Group for an office project was not part of the foreclosure or sale.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.