Six months after three restaurants closed pre-pandemic, more big changes could be coming to Market Square, one of Downtown’s top destinations.

In one part of the square, a Chase Bank branch could be replacing the Bruegger’s Bagel store, which has closed for good.

Next door, a search is on to find another restaurant or bar operator to replace NOLA on the Square, the funky New Orleans-style eatery which announced its closing this month after being shut down because of COVID-19.

Nick Nicholas, the owner of the two buildings housing Bruegger’s and NOLA, said he is hoping to sign a letter of intent with Chase to take the bagel store’s space by early next week.

Advertise with us

Although he has had interest from many others, including fast-food chain Chick-fil-A, Mr. Nicholas said Chase is his first choice to occupy the space. The bank, he said, has “A-plus” credit and could sign a long lease.

A Chase spokesperson declined comment.

Chase would be the second bank to enter Market Square.

Two years ago, Bank of America took a spot in a prominent corner of the square that had been occupied by the Diamond Market Bar and Grill. Mr. Nicholas owns the building and operated the restaurant.

The thought of another bank invading the square upset John Valentine, executive director of the Pittsburgh Downtown Community Development Corporation.

Advertise with us

“This is ruining Market Square,” he said.

Mr. Valentine argued that another bank will take away more outdoor dining space, which he sees as crucial to the square’s vitality. The square also lost that type of seating when Bank of America moved in.

“Every time you lose outdoor seating, you’re going to lose vibrancy,” he said. “Market Square is a gem. It’s sad what’s going to happen.”

David Glickman, director of retail services for the Newmark Knight Frank real estate firm who leases two buildings for his family in Market Square, said banks are attractive to landlords because they pay good rents and are strong tenants.

“It’s unfortunate that banks want into Market Square so badly,” he said. “It would be better to have restaurants and other types of destination tenants because that’s the objective of Market Square.

Advertise with us

“When it was remodeled into a European piazza, the plan was never to have banks. It really, ideally, would be restaurants and destination-type retailers.”

Banks, he added, “go against what Market Square’s about. It’s a gathering place for people. When you have banks, that detracts from the vibe and the tenant mix.”

Mr. Nicholas, who also owns Nicholas Coffee in the square, said he is looking for at least one restaurant or bar to occupy the former NOLA space and the old second floor Perle champagne bar. He sees the possibility of multiple operators in the two-story space, including a possible speakeasy-type set-up in the back of the second floor with an entrance from an alleyway.

“There’s a lot of potential because that’s the only large space in Market Square,” he said.

The Bruegger’s and NOLA closings add to the restaurant vacancies in and around the square, which became a popular dining destination after former mayor Luke Ravenstahl spent $5 million a decade ago revitalizing the space.

Advertise with us

In January, Molinaro Ristorante and Bar, which anchored a corner spot in the square, and Wolfies Pub and Pizzuvio, both of which fronted Forbes Avenue just off the square, shut down.

None of the spaces have been filled, although there are inklings about that changing despite the devastating impacts the pandemic has had on restaurants and retail.

A national sushi chain is said to be interested in the former Molinaro space.

Herky Pollock, a CBRE executive vice president who is representing the possible tenant, declined comment.

The spot, despite its prominent perch at 2 PPG Place, has had a run of bad luck. Before Molinaro, Poros, a Mediterranean-inspired seafood restaurant, closed its doors after several years in the space.

Advertise with us

Lucas Piatt, president of Millcraft Investments — the developer of JLL Center where Wolfies and Pizzuvio were located — said he is working with two or three restaurant/bar tenants that are interested in the spaces.

“Our goal is to amenitize the street and create that outdoor storefront,” he said.

Mr. Valentine, who also has expressed concern about the Market Square vacancies, said it might be tough to fill them during the pandemic.

Succeeding in recruiting new tenants might ride on how many people return to their Downtown offices once the pandemic eases, he noted.

“How many people are going to want to work from home, that’s the key,” he said. “If you have people who want to continue to work from home [after the pandemic], that’s a concern.”

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.