Pittsburgh and Lamar Advertising are sparring over another billboard, this one on the North Side.
The city’s Urban Redevelopment Authority has sued to force Lamar to remove a billboard on River Avenue, claiming that the company is illegally trespassing on the property after the URA terminated the lease.
But Lamar maintains that the URA took the action in retaliation for its “victory over the City of Pittsburgh in other unrelated matters” — an apparent reference to a state Commonwealth Court ruling in August that permitted the company to keep a banner draped over a controversial Mount Washington billboard, one Mayor Bill Peduto has dubbed “an eyesore.”
Lamar contends it has a legal right under Pennsylvania law to remain on the land either as a month-to-month or holdover tenant even though the URA has ended the lease.
An Allegheny County Common Pleas Court judge has tentatively scheduled a hearing April 2 on a request by the URA for a preliminary injunction to force Lamar to remove the billboard, which can be seen from Route 28. The billboard has a pet shelter ad on one side and an ad for a local law firm on the other.
In its lawsuit, filed in January, the URA stated that it ordered Lamar to remove the billboard Nov. 30 after rejecting an offer by the company to buy the property. The billboard company had been leasing the property on a month-to-month basis since the end of 2014.
Read More
The URA stated that it took the step after Lamar failed to respond to a communication outlining the new rates it was proposing to the firm to lease the property.
But despite the termination, Lamar has continued to occupy the property. In the lawsuit, the URA charged that the act amounted to unlawful trespassing and a nuisance and has significantly diminished the utility of the property and stifled potential development.
“Lamar’s actions have been an intentional, unreasonable and outrageous attempt to continue its unlawful use of the property and/or to prevent the URA’s use and development of the property,” the agency stated in the lawsuit.
In seeking an injunction to force Lamar to remove the billboard, the URA argued that the wrongful use of the property has interfered with its “needs and plans for, and use and enjoyment of, its property.”
“This includes, but is not limited to, use or disposition of the property in accordance with the URA’s mission to develop property which creates jobs and improves the vitality of businesses and neighborhoods in the City of Pittsburgh,” it stated.
But Lamar rejected such claims.
“The URA’s purported harm is speculative at best, given that the billboard location is within an area that would very likely not be developed in the event that the property was redeveloped, as it is close to the right-of-way and would ostensibly be located within any required setback depending on the development plan for the subject property and no development is currently planned for the subject property,” it stated.
It added that there was no evidence from publicly available sources that the property was being offered for sale or lease. The company also stated that it had offered to significantly increase its lease payments to keep the billboard.
In its preliminary objections to the lawsuit and requested injunction, Lamar maintained it and the URA “had been operating amicably on a month-to-month basis” regarding the leasing of the property for five years. That changed in September, according to Lamar.
“On September 19, 2019, in response to Lamar’s victory over the City of Pittsburgh in other unrelated matters, the URA sent a lease termination notice to Lamar, stating that the lease shall terminate on Oct. 31, 2019.” That later was changed to Nov. 30.
The company stated that it is still occupying property and paying rent — more than $230 a square foot, or about $15,000 a year total. It contended that the URA “does not have the legal right to terminate the lease.”
As for the injunction request, Lamar suggested that there “is not a sliver of evidence of immediate or irreparable harm” to the URA — one of the conditions for granting such relief — in keeping the billboard up.
Instead, the URA has made “general, self-serving and unsubstantiated averments, by merely stating irreversible harm based on conjecture and speculation,” the company maintained.
URA officials declined comment on the lawsuit, as did Jonathan Kamin, attorney for Lamar.
The clash over the River Avenue billboard comes as the city and Lamar wait to see if the state Supreme Court will accept the city’s appeal of a lower court ruling regarding the controversial Mount Washington billboard.
In August, a state Commonwealth Court panel found that the advertising banners draped over the billboard — an old one for Sprint and the current one for the National Flag Foundation — are legal. The city appealed to the full court, which refused to intervene.
The battle has been waging in the courts for more than two years.
In 2018, Common Pleas Court Senior Judge Joseph James reversed a city zoning board finding that installing the 7,200-square-foot vinyl static advertising banner for Sprint over a nonconforming 4,500-square-foot electronic sign violated a section of the zoning code.
A red, white and blue National Flag Foundation banner replaced the black and yellow Sprint advertisement last spring when Lamar’s agreement with the cellphone company expired.
Mark Belko: 412-263-1262 or mbelko@post-gazette.com.
Updated at 3:14 p.m on March 13, 2020





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.