Pittsburgh is making one last ditch effort to remove the vinyl banner draped over a controversial Mount Washington billboard.
City officials have formally petitioned the Pennsylvania Supreme Court to accept their appeal of a state Commonwealth Court ruling which found that the advertising banners — an old one for Sprint and the current one for the National Flag Foundation — are legal.
The Supreme Court can either deny or accept the petition for appeal. After a three-judge Commonwealth Court panel upheld the right of Lamar Advertising to install the banners, the city appealed to the full court, which refused to intervene.
Jonathan Kamin, an attorney for Lamar, was unimpressed with the city’s latest bid to prevail in the longstanding battle over the billboard.
“We’ve prevailed in the courts four separate times in this matter and believe that we will prevail again, as the billboard has been there for more than 90 years and has the legal right to continue to exist,” he said.
But the city, in its appeal, argued that the Commonwealth Court erred in rendering its verdict in favor of Lamar.
Read More
It maintained that the panel ignored a separate ruling in another Commonwealth Court matter involving the municipality of Monroeville and the billboard company.
In that case, a separate three-judge panel found that electronic billboards and static vinyl billboards could not be substituted for one another because static vinyl signs and electronic signs are different uses, the city contended.
“Only by ignoring this court’s decision in Lamar v. Monroeville — and the distinction between electronic signs and static, vinyl signs — was the panel in Lamar v. Pittsburgh able to reach its conclusion that the [Pittsburgh Zoning Board of Adjustment] erred in its application of the zoning code,” the city asserted in its petition for appeal. “This failure to consider or address the controlling precedent warrants reversal by the Supreme Court.”
In addition, the city argued that the Commonwealth Court panel in the Mount Washington case substituted its own factual findings for those of the zoning board regarding the distinction between “sign face” and “sign structure,” and thus the size of the advertising content on the sign.
That, it stated, is contrary to a past state Supreme Court ruling which limited the standard of review by Commonwealth Court to “whether the ZBA committed an abuse of discretion or an error of law.”
“This mistake by the Commonwealth Court allows Lamar to substantially increase the square footage of advertising permitted on the sign in a district where billboards are prohibited and therefore substantially increasing a pre-existing nonconformity,” the city insisted.
The zoning board is a party to the city’s petition for review by the Supreme Court.
In its decision, the Commonwealth Court panel upheld a ruling last year by Allegheny County Common Pleas Court Senior Judge Joseph James.
Judge James reversed the city zoning board finding that installing the 7,200-square-foot vinyl static advertising banner for Sprint over a nonconforming 4,500-square-foot electronic sign violated a section of the zoning code.
That section stated that nonconforming signs "may not be enlarged, added to or replaced by another nonconforming sign or by a nonconforming use or structure." But like Judge James, the Commonwealth Court panel stated that the record did not support such a conclusion.
The red, white and blue National Flag Foundation banner replaced the black and yellow Sprint advertisement last spring when Lamar’s agreement with the cellphone company expired.
Mayor Bill Peduto, who has been leading the fight against Lamar, had dubbed the Sprint banner “an eyesore.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.