Lamar Advertising is urging the state Supreme Court to reject Pittsburgh’s bid to remove a vinyl banner draped over a controversial Mount Washington billboard, calling it “a sad example of the abuse of governmental power.”

In an 18-page response, the company asked justices to dismiss the city’s appeal of a state Commonwealth Court ruling that found the advertising banners — an old one for Sprint and the current one for the National Flag Foundation — are legal.

“This case is a sad example of the abuse of governmental power and the abuse of process,” wrote Jonathan Kamin, Lamar’s attorney. “For more than five years, the city has sought to destroy the billboard which has proudly sat on top of Pittsburgh’s Mt. Washington for more than 90 years.”

The Supreme Court can either deny or accept the city’s petition for appeal.

Advertise with us

Lamar, in its response, left no doubt which way it thought justices should go, noting the company had won previous skirmishes over the billboard in local district court, Allegheny County Common Pleas Court, and twice in Commonwealth Court.

“The city now asks that this court ignore all of the previous precedents, and rely solely on some mythical arguments postulated by its politically appointed [Zoning Board of Adjustment],” Lamar stated in its filing. The board is appointed by Mayor Bill Peduto, who has dubbed the Mount Washington billboard “an eyesore.”

In its appeal, the city had argued that Commonwealth Court erred in finding in favor of Lamar. It maintained that the three-judge panel that decided the case ignored another Commonwealth Court ruling involving Monroeville and the billboard company.

A separate three-judge panel in that matter concluded electronic billboards and static vinyl billboards could not be substituted for one another because they are different uses.

But Lamar contended the city’s attempt to equate that decision with the Mount Washington billboard battle “disregards the undisputed facts in this case, misconstrues the holding in Monroeville, and continues to ignore the Commonwealth Court’s decision and rationale.”

Advertise with us

In the Monroeville matter, the company, in its response, stated that it wanted to remove the existing sign faces on 17 billboards and replace them with 17 new LED sign faces. The change from conventional signage to LED screens resulted in “significant structural alterations” to the billboard, the court found, according to Lamar’s response.

In the Mount Washington matter, the vinyl sign is the same size as the existing billboard face, the electronic aspects of the billboard remain and have not been altered or removed, and the structure itself has not been altered or enlarged, the company argued.

In addition, the city’s contention that the size of the billboard is 4,500 square feet, not 7,200 square feet is a “myth” that “completely ignores the testimony and facts of record, and amounts to a bad faith representation to this court,” Lamar maintained.

It contended that the occupancy certificate issued by the city for the billboard in 1985 measures the structure at 32 feet high by 225 feet in length, or 7,200 square feet, and that the city’s zoning administrator calculated an application fee for a billboard modernization application at $72,000 — or $10 per square foot times 7,200 square feet.

“The city continues to ignore the undisputed facts, its own actions, and its own zoning code and has embraced the ZBA’s misguided theory that ‘the Bayer signage made use of approximately 20’ by 225’ or 4,500 sf of the larger sign structure,’” Mr. Kamin wrote.

Advertise with us

Tim McNulty, Mr. Peduto’s spokesman, declined comment on Lamar’s response.

The red, white and blue National Flag Foundation banner replaced a black and yellow Sprint advertisement last spring after Lamar’s agreement with the cell phone company expired.

business@post-gazette.com