A developer is ready to advance a final plan for the controversial redevelopment of the former Penn Plaza apartment site in East Liberty.

Pennley Park South, an affiliate of LG Realty Advisors, will brief the city planning commission Tuesday on the proposal. It includes a mix of offices, retail, and parking on the site — but not the affordable housing coveted by opponents of the development.

The briefing will be the first before the commission since an Allegheny County Common Pleas Court judge overturned an earlier decision by the panel to restrict the height of the complex to 108 feet and demanded that LG Realty provide a community or multi-purpose gathering space as part of the redevelopment.

LG Realty’s final land development plan for the $50 million first phase includes 246,090 square feet of office, 54,600 square feet of retail, and a total of 672 parking spaces spread over nine stories.

Advertise with us

According to documents submitted to the planning department, the building will top out at 150 feet — the height the developer pitched in the plan presented to the commission last spring. LG Realty said at the time it was entitled to as much as 238 feet under the city’s zoning code.

But the commission, in narrowly approving the overall plan in a 4-2 vote, limited the height to 108 feet, prompting the court fight.

The redevelopment itself has become a flashpoint in demands for the creation of more affordable housing in the city amid concerns about the increasing gentrification in neighborhoods such as East Liberty and Lawrenceville.

To clear the way for the project, LG Realty displaced more than 200 residents in the former Penn Plaza apartments and demolished the complex — prompting protests and battles with the city.

Countering the criticism, the developer has stated that 70 percent of the new tax revenue generated would go into an East Liberty Transit Revitalization Investment District fund, with 50 percent of that amount being used to build affordable housing in the area.

Advertise with us

Larry Gumberg, LG Realty president, said Friday the phase one redevelopment is expected to produce about $3 million toward the fund, with two thirds going for housing. The other $1 million will go for Enright Park improvements.

“The bottom line of what this development is going to do is it’s going to create an affordable housing trust fund — a substantial amount of money for the affordable housing trust fund,” he said.

LG Realty at one point had landed Whole Foods to occupy the phase one retail space but the grocery chain backed off following the controversy over the displacement of residents and the plan itself.

Mr. Gumberg said Friday that he hopes Whole Foods will return to the project. At this time, LG Realty has not lined up any tenants to occupy the eight floors of office space in the new building.

Crystal Jennings, a member of the Penn Plaza Support and Action Coalition, said she is hoping to get LG Realty to commit to a mix of housing at the site in the second phase of the development.

Advertise with us

The developer has yet to determine what the second phase will include.

“People who lived in that community who got displaced should be able to return back to where they came from,” she said.

LG Realty also should consider renting some of the office space in phase one to minority businesses or local organizations. She questioned whether the company will be able to fill all the space.

“We think it probably will be sitting vacant for awhile like some of the other commercial properties in East Liberty are sitting vacant,” she said.

Ms. Jennings also urged LG Realty to be more engaged with the community in determining what will go in the second phase of the development.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.