The battle over the controversial redevelopment of the former Penn Plaza site in East Liberty is far from over.

Pennley Park South, the owner of the real estate, has filed an appeal in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court challenging the decision by the city planning commission to limit the height of the proposed office and retail development to 108 feet.

In the appeal, filed late Tuesday, Pennley Park, an affiliate of developer LG Realty Advisors, charged that the decision was illegal and unreasonable given that a height of 238 feet was allowed by right under the city’s zoning code and that it had voluntarily agreed to keep it to 150 feet.

Pennley Park also accused the planning commission of “a confiscatory taking of private property” in separately requiring it to develop a “community room” facing Enright Park open to the public for gatherings of at least 100 people.

Advertise with us

“Can you tell someone if they build a house that they have to put a room in it for the next-door neighbor?” asked Jonathan Kamin, attorney for Pennley Park and LG Realty. “I believe it’s a confiscatory taking.”

The commission, in a narrow 4-2 vote on May 15, approved the proposed office and retail development at the site of the former Penn Plaza apartment complex over the objections of dozens of affordable housing advocates who wanted it rejected.

In doing so, members voted to add the condition restricting the height because they believed the 150 feet was out of context with houses bordering the site and buildings in other sections of East Liberty.

They also inserted the requirement for the community gathering space adjacent to the park, which had been reconfigured and enlarged as part of a consent order reached last fall after the commission had rejected LG Realty’s earlier proposal for the site, which included a Whole Foods Market and 200 apartments.

After the May 15 vote and approval, Larry Gumberg, LG Realty president, expressed disappointment with the additional conditions. He contended that he wasn’t sure whether the proposed redevelopment, which includes about 200,000 square feet of office space and 50,000 square feet of retail in the first phase, would be feasible with the additional conditions.

Advertise with us

But in a statement Wednesday, Mr. Gumberg stressed that LG Realty would be moving forward with the project.

“Our appeal is focused solely on two additional conditions added to that approval at the 11th hour, restrictions that we believe violate the law,” he said. “Our comprehensive plan for the site will result in new commercial and retail development, create much-needed employment opportunities, generate additional tax revenue and contribute to a more vibrant neighborhood.”

In its appeal, Pennley Park maintained the commission had no right to impose the two conditions, stating that its preliminary land development plan met all of the zoning code’s conditions for approval.

“Therefore the planning commission did not have the right to invent standards, which are not in the zoning code, and to impose the unreasonable conditions on the approval of the” plan,” it stated.

Ray Gastil, the city planning director, declined comment, citing the pending litigation. Christine Mondor, the commission’s chairwoman, could not be reached for comment.

Advertise with us

“We’re pleased with the approval but we are obligated to challenge the two unreasonable conditions that were imposed by the planning commission, which were not recommended by staff nor agreed to by the developer,” Mr. Kamin said.

The appeal is the latest turn in the lengthy battle over the property, which has become the rallying point for demands for more affordable housing in East Liberty and other parts of the city.

Pennley Park and LG Realty displaced more than 200 residents from the former Penn Plaza apartment complex to clear the way for the redevelopment.

When the commission shot down LG Realty’s proposal to build 200 market-rate apartments at the site, the developer switched geared, opting for office space instead of residences in the revised plan.

It argued that the proposal would actually bring more affordable housing to East Liberty.

Advertise with us

That’s because 70 percent of the new tax revenue generated by the development would go into an East Liberty Transit Revitalization Investment District fund, with 50 percent of that amount dedicated to building more affordable housing.

None of that did much to appease affordable housing advocates, some of whom urged the city to take the property by eminent domain and use it to build affordable housing for former Penn Plaza residents and others.

In his statement Wednesday, Mr. Gumberg said the proposed redevelopment could generate more than $2 million for affordable housing in the city.

“As a family-owned company with roots here in Pittsburgh, we firmly believe our solution is the right one for the property and the city as a whole,” he said.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.

Updated at 4 p.m. on June 6, 2018.