The Pittsburgh Planning Commission pushed through a proposal Tuesday to redevelop the former Penn Plaza site in East Liberty over opposition from dozens of affordable-housing advocates who packed the meeting.
But the decision appeared to satisfy no one, not the opponents of the proposed office and retail complex, nor the developer, who complained about the commission unilaterally reducing its height.
In the 4-2 vote approving the plan, the commission restricted the overall height of the buildings to 108 feet, down from the 150 proposed by LG Realty Advisors and the 238 feet the developer said it is allowed under the city’s zoning code.
“I’m disappointed in the process,” said Larry Gumberg, LG Realty president. “I’m disappointed that the planning commission chose to make these kinds of changes and conditions. And candidly, I think it’s inappropriate.”
After a long ordeal that included a court battle to get approval to redevelop the site, Mr. Gumberg said he’s not sure whether the plan, which includes about 200,000 square feet of office space and 50,000 square feet of retail in the first phase, is now feasible.
“We don’t know,” he said. “We’ll have to study it.”
Read More
Commission members decided to reduce the height because they believed 150 feet was out of context with houses bordering the site and buildings in other sections of East Liberty.
“I’m not comfortable with that massiveness at all,” said commission member Sabina Dietrick, who voted against the plan.
Reducing the height was not the only change the commission made.

It also added a requirement for a community gathering space adjacent to Enright Park, which itself was reconfigured and enlarged as part of the consent order reached last fall after the commission had rejected LG Realty’s earlier proposal for the site, which included a Whole Foods Market and 200 apartments.
And in a sign of how much the commission struggled with its decision Tuesday, it passed what it called “a resolution of concern” urging city leaders to give it more power to consider issues such as social, environmental, and economic impacts and housing strategies in making decisions.
Member Jean Holland Dick called the vote a “painful one to make.”
“I think this is a very hard project,” added commission chairwoman Christine Mondor, the other member to vote against the plan.
The decision came at the end of a 4 ½ hour marathon during which nearly 40 people spoke, most of them affordable-housing advocates who railed against the plan.
They urged the commission to vote it down based on criteria requiring that developments show “favorable environmental, social, and economic impact” without endangering public health or safety or general welfare. They maintained the LG Realty proposal did none of that.
The redevelopment has become the flashpoint for demands for more affordable housing in the city and concerns about the increasing gentrification of neighborhoods such as East Liberty and Lawrenceville.
To clear the way for the project, LG Realty displaced more than 200 residents from the former Penn Plaza apartment complex — an affront to many of those who spoke Tuesday.
Some of the advocates urged the city to take the property from Gumberg by eminent domain and use it to build affordable housing for those former residents and others.
Laura Wiens, director of Pittsburghers for Public Transit, called the issue before the commission a moral question, not a design one.
Steve Capri, a North Side resident and a member of a group called Socialist Alternative, described the redevelopment plan as “a slap in the face to all the working and poor citizens of the city of Pittsburgh.”
“The anger with this development is not about a park or about exciting storefronts or shade cover or building heights,” he said. “The community’s anger comes from LG kicking hundreds of people out of their homes, demolishing those homes, and then planning to replace them with no homes but empty boxes.”

LG Realty has countered that the plan would bring more affordable housing to East Liberty.
Under the plan, 70 percent of the new tax revenue generated by the development will go into an East Liberty Transit Revitalization Investment District fund, with 50 percent of that amount being used to build more affordable housing. The rest will go for infrastructure at the site.
Jonathan Kamin, LG Realty attorney, said the development is expected to generate, conservatively, $1.65 million for affordable housing and $1 million for Enright Park improvements in the first phase. The second phase, which would include 85,000 square feet of retail and about 250,000 square feet of office, would provide $1.8 million for housing
“We are acting as an engine to support this housing for the neighborhood,” he said.
But not everyone was sold. After the commission added the requirement for more community space, one East Liberty resident yelled out, “Can I sleep there when I’m priced out of my home?”
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.