The lawsuit seeking to reclaim more than two thirds of the $1 million paid to a regional airline to fly from Pittsburgh International Airport highlights the perils of such subsidies.
To aviation experts, such agreements carry risks — both to the airport extending them and to the airlines that accept them.
In the case of OneJet — the business-oriented carrier that started flying from Pittsburgh International in 2015 — the Allegheny County Airport Authority has gone to court to recoup $763,000 of the $1 million it paid the airline to provide service to 10 destinations, including seven to new markets.
OneJet, in fact, did launch flights to cities such as Indianapolis; Milwaukee; Cincinnati; Albany, N.Y.; Richmond, Va.; Providence, R.I.; Hartford, Conn..; Louisville, Ky.; Kansas City, Mo.; and Nashville, Tenn.
But it suspended service to Kansas City, Palm Beach, Albany, Louisville, and Milwaukee in June; to Providence, R.I., in April; to Cincinnati and Richmond in December; and to Nashville in November. Planned service to Memphis never started.
Now the airline is down to just two markets — Hartford and Indianapolis — in violation of an agreement that required the carrier to maintain round-trip nonstop service at least five days a week for at least five years to the new destinations, according to the lawsuit filed Friday by the Allegheny County Airport Authority.
Read More
Two aviation experts, William Swelbar and Michael Boyd, said Monday they are not aware of any other airport taking action against an airline for allegedly breaching an agreement involving subsidies.
Yet they don’t expect the lawsuit to be the last, given how common such incentives have become and the risk inherent in them.
Mr. Swelbar, who serves on a OneJet advisory board, said subsidies typically involve marginal markets that need to be developed over time. Given the nature of such markets, there’s a chance the service won’t pan out.
“My guess is that this is one of the early chapters in the book,” he said of the authority’s lawsuit, filed in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court. He declined to discuss OneJet specifically give his advisory board role.
In his first public comments on the complaint, Matthew Maguire, OneJet’s CEO, said Monday that the airline plans to incrementally restore the flights it has cut from Pittsburgh as it upgrades to larger 30-seat planes. It typically has been flying seven seaters from the airport.
“Our commitment to the community is there,” he said.
OneJet began using the larger planes to Hartford and Indianapolis in June, and plans to deploy them on two additional routes from Pittsburgh starting in September, the airline said in a statement. It did not identify the routes.
“Once completed, OneJet will offer nearly double the number of seats to and from Pittsburgh relative to any other period in the company’s history. While we won’t comment on our discussions with the Pittsburgh airport, we intend to continue our dialogue and will respond accordingly, as appropriate.”
The authority paid the $1 million upfront to OneJet after reaching the 2016 agreement. As part of the deal, it appears to have taken steps to try to protect its investment.
In an unusual arrangement, one of the authority’s board members, Robert Lewis, has served as a non-voting member of the OneJet board of directors. Whether he shared the authority’s concerns about service with the OneJet board is not known. He could not be reached for comment Monday.
Unclear is how that arrangement will be affected now that Mr. Lewis sits on both the board bringing the lawsuit and the board defending it.
Robert Caruso, executive director of the state Ethics Commission, said the dual roles could present the appearance of a conflict of interest.
In situations where a person serves on boards of public and private entities that do business with each other, the commission advises that person to either adhere to strict abstentions in business dealings between the two or to resign from one of the boards.
Michael Boyd, a Colorado-based aviation consultant, described the arrangement as “brilliant,” saying it shows the authority has someone watching over its investment.
The authority also required OneJet to meet with it quarterly to discuss financial performance, any operational issues and route performance. It also was to provide monthly reports on passenger demographics, behavior and sales.
Despite the attempted safeguards, the service still ended up falling short, according to the lawsuit.
Mr. Boyd said part of the problem may be the OneJet model itself. Short haul regional air travel, he maintained, “does not work as well as it did 30 years ago and in many cases it does not work at all.”
“Just because 20,000 people a year [flew] between Pittsburgh and Albany at one time doesn’t mean they’re there now,” he said.
Despite such reservations, he doesn’t fault the authority for providing $1 million to OneJet in exchange for service, saying it was a “calculated risk that made sense.”
“It was a risk, an option, and it hasn’t worked. That’s the name of the game,” he said.
While OneJet is adding larger aircraft to its fleet, the Allegheny County Airport Authority apparently doesn’t believe that is the answer. In an Aug. 3 letter to OneJet’s Mr. Maguire, Jeff Letwin, the authority’s solicitor, stated that the airline had presented “no clear restructuring plan” to the agency.
“The only ‘plan’ which was submitted was inadequate in its failure to address any of the existing weaknesses including issues regarding management,” Mr. Letwin wrote in the letter, attached as an exhibit to the lawsuit.
“As we have indicated in the various meetings that have occurred over the past couple of weeks, the airplane acquisitions are not the problem. Management continues to be the issue. Therefore, we do not believe an adequate restructuring plan has been submitted.”
In addition to the $763,000 claim, OneJet owes the authority $38,729 in airport charges, spokesman Bob Kerlik said.
Mr. Boyd doesn’t see the authority’s lawsuit as the last one that will be seen on the issue.
With more airports providing subsidies in exchange for certain levels of service, there’s always the potential for litigation when airlines don’t live up to their end of the bargain, he noted.
“That’s why God gave us the court system,” he said.
OneJet is just one of the carriers that the Pittsburgh authority has provided incentives to in exchange for service.
Other subsidies include $3 million over two years to British Airways to serve London nonstop starting next year; $800,000 over two years to Wow Air for flights to Iceland; $500,000 over the same period to Condor Airlines for seasonal flights to Frankfurt, Germany.
The authority also is on the hook for up to $560,000 for two charter flights this month between Shanghai and Pittsburgh, although it is expected to recoup some of that money through ticket sales. Qatar Airways also could end up receiving as much as $1.5 million for two-weekly cargo flights between Pittsburgh and Doha.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.