The proposed $27.5 million purchase of the former Art Institute of Pittsburgh building by the city and two of its authorities would represent one of the priciest real estate transactions in Downtown in recent years.
In terms of price per square foot, the sale would rank as the second highest since 2011, beating out transactions involving some of Downtown’s most iconic properties, including One Oxford Centre and PPG Place.
Some city officials, like Controller Michael Lamb and Councilman Corey O’Connor, believe the price is too high — and the city should have looked elsewhere for less expensive space. Councilwoman Darlene Harris says the purchase could harm the city’s financial health.
The only previous sale that exceeded the $174 a square foot that the city, the Urban Redevelopment Authority and the Housing Authority intend to pay for 420 Blvd. of the Allies involved Liberty Center, which sold in December 2016 for $96.9 million, or $184 a square foot.

Tied for second with the Art Institute acquisition is the purchase of the former Westinghouse Building at 11 Stanwix St., which sold for roughly $174 a square foot in February 2017 to M&J Wilkow — the same company selling the Boulevard of the Allies property to the city and its authorities.
The numbers are based on research done by the Jones Lang LaSalle real estate firm and the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.
“If the city pursues this, it will be paying a premium for the building. It raises the question of whether we should be paying this kind of price for our employees. I still maintain it is not necessary for them to be Downtown,” Mr. Lamb said.
Among other transactions in Downtown, One Oxford Centre sold for $147.15 a square foot in 2016. Five years before that, in 2011, the glass castle-like PPG Place complex around Market Square was purchased for $119 a square foot.
Another big property, the 41-story 525 William Penn Place, the fourth-largest office building in Downtown, sold for $72.43 a square foot two years ago.
Some of the buildings that were sold in recent years could fetch more now given appreciation and the tight Downtown real estate market.
The city and authorities are looking to move offices from the dilapidated confines of the John P. Robin Civic Building at 200 Ross St. to the new space to better assist the public and provide more appealing, more collaborative work space for employees.
In addition to the purchase price, they will spend another $10 million to $12 million to build out the shell space. A priority is to create a one-stop shop for permits, licenses, inspections and other city services.
Mr. Lamb has raised doubts about the transaction. Beyond the price, he also has questioned the process — or lack of one.
‘Too many red flags’
The proposed sale was announced two weeks ago, with the URA board voting to approve it last July 16. City council and the Housing Authority board also must OK the deal, with the goal to have that done by Aug. 1.
The controller described the sale as a “very quiet, secret deal that raises too many red flags to me.”
URA officials have said the pace is being dictated by seller M&J Wilkow, which has potential leases it is holding up with the sale pending.
The Chicago developer bought the nine-story building for $10 million in 2014 and has spent another $11 million since in a major overhaul, adding new systems and other amenities and creating open floor plates.
Gerry Dudley, an executive vice president for the commercial real estate services firm CBRE who helped the URA in the search for a new space, has acknowledged that the price being paid is in the middle to upper range of the market.
He added that if some of the leases in new buildings in the North Shore or the Strip District were converted to the equivalent of sales, the cost per square foot would be in the $300-plus range.
Gregg Broujos, managing director of Colliers International, said comparing the proposed Art Institute purchase to recent sales in the market is not really “apples to apples.” He explained that most of those sales involved top-of-the-line Class A office investment sales as opposed to the type of owner-occupier transaction that the city and its authorities are contemplating.
“Typically, when you have an owner occupier who needs to purchase a building for their own occupancy, they are going to pay a premium in the marketplace,” he said.
If the buyers did a cost analysis that shows it is more cost effective to purchase the new space than to remodel the Robin building, “it doesn’t matter what other things have sold for [in] Downtown,” he said.
“The optics make sense. It’s a really nice building. It’s got great floor plates that are efficient and it’s got a bit of parking on the side that is very valuable [in] Downtown. And it’s definitely a more efficient building than 200 Ross,” he said.
‘Least cost, most efficient’
Mr. Lamb is not the only city official concerned about the proposed purchase.
Mr. O’Connor likewise feels that the process is being rushed and that the city and authorities are overpaying for the property at $174 a square foot.
“I feel that’s too high,” he said.
Ms. Harris, the councilwoman who is a critic of Mayor Bill Peduto, said she had “$40 million worth of concerns,” a reference to the up to $40 million the city is planning to borrow to buy the Art Institute property and build out the space. She feared that floating a bond for that much money “would be going back into the situation of needing to be in Act 47” and weaken the city’s financial position.
She also believes that the current Robin Building is a better location because of its proximity to the City-County Building on Grant Street.
“You have to count everything in the cost — what it’s going to cost now and what it’s going to cost in the future,” she said.
Councilwoman Erika Strassburger said she is leaning toward supporting the deal. She likes the concept of the one-stop shop and finds the purchase “a much better deal” compared to trying to renovate the Robin Building.
At Ms. Harris’ request, council has scheduled a post-agenda meeting Monday and a public hearing July 30 on the proposed sale.
In comments last week, Mr. Peduto compared the Robin Building to a “1960s Russian prison.” The city, he said, had hoped to renovate it but found that the costs of upgrading “were more than the costs of looking to get a new facility.”
The former Art Institute building, he added, “became the least cost, most efficient model to use.”
The URA has estimated the cost of bringing the Robin Building up to acceptable standards at $39 million.
The city and the authorities each would own a third of the former Art Institute real estate, just as they do with the Robin Building.
They also may be able to lease out a floor in their new digs to generate more revenue.
With the sale, the former Art Institute building would be removed from the tax rolls. But URA executive director Robert Rubinstein has said that should be offset by the eventual sale of the Robin Building, which will be marketed for private redevelopment.
URA officials have said the search for a new location was concentrated in Downtown to be close to the City-County Building, which houses the mayor’s office, city council and other city offices.
Mr. Lamb has argued that they should have considered less expensive space near Downtown with more parking that could better serve citizens, developers and contractors. He noted that the city’s water and sewer authority moved their offices to the Strip District.
“Why these agencies couldn’t be down there is a good question,” he said.
Staff writer Caroline S. Engelmayer contributed to this story. Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262. Adam Smeltz: 412-263-2625, asmeltz@post-gazette.com, @asmeltz.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.