A $20 million pot of money used to offset rental discounts that lure conventions to Pittsburgh is running dry, leaving local officials scrambling to find ways to replace it.

For the last decade, the Pittsburgh-Allegheny County Sports & Exhibition Authority has been receiving $1.7 million a year from the state to help cover operating deficits at the David L. Lawrence Convention Center.

The money is used in large part to provide discounts to help attract conventions to Pittsburgh, said Mary Conturo, SEA executive director. In essence, the convention center charges less for the space than the amount required to break even.

“The deficit is just related to the competitive market you’re in. In order to compete with other cities to get conventions here, there is only so much rent you can charge,” Ms. Conturo said.

Advertise with us

Use of rent discounts has become a routine practice in the increasingly fierce competition among cities to lure big shows in hopes of boosting tourism and the accompanying spending.

It’s not only happening in Pittsburgh but in some of the largest tourist destinations in the country, said Heywood Sanders, a professor of public administration and interim department chair, College of Public Policy, at the University of Texas at San Antonio. He has studied the economics and impact of convention centers.

“This is everywhere. It’s not just Pittsburgh competing against Philadelphia, Cleveland and Columbus. We’re talking about places like San Francisco and San Diego that have long been considered prime destinations,” he said. “You’re seeing folks competing against one another into the ground.”

The SEA is set to receive two more payments —  slightly smaller at $1.5 million in each of the next two years — from the state economic development and tourism fund. The payments are financed by gambling revenues to help cover the deficit, which averages about $3 million annually.

Ms. Conturo said the other half comes from the county’s 7 percent hotel tax.

Advertise with us

In addition to helping with the deficit, about $1 million of the $3 million annually from the hotel tax is used for small capital projects and $500,000 goes toward repayment of a loan related to the construction of the convention center, which was completed in 2003.

Since its opening, the 1.5-million-square-foot center has twice hosted the National Rifle Association convention. Other large conventions have included the American Numismatic Association, the AFL-CIO National Convention, the National Urban League, and Anthrocon [the Furries] convention. The center also hosted the G-20 summit in 2009.

The top convention last year, at least in terms of direct spending, was Anthrocon, which brought in $7.77 million.

The SEA, Ms. Conturo said, is just starting conversations about ways to replace the state allocation. State Sen. Jay Costa, D-Forest Hills, said he is talking to Allegheny County Executive Rich Fitzgerald, Mayor Bill Peduto, hotels, and the VisitPittsburgh tourism agency about the issue.

Mr. Costa, the Senate minority leader, said he wasn’t able to convince the General Assembly leadership to continue the funding for Pittsburgh’s convention center in the expanded gaming bill passed last year.

Advertise with us

“There was no interest in doing that because the convention center presumably was doing OK,” he said.

The legislature did allocate $1.7 million a year for the creation and operation of a sports commission to help attract high-profile sporting events to Pittsburgh. That money is assigned to the SEA, not VisitPittsburgh, which had been pushing the idea. The funds are expected to be available starting in 2020. There is no specified end to the allocation.

Discounting rents to help attract conventions could end up becoming part of the sports commission’s role, Mr. Costa said.

Craig Davis, VisitPittsburgh CEO and president, said he is aware that the state money used to help cover the convention center operating deficit will be running out in two years. He plans to meet with various officials over the next few months to come up with a solution.

Discounting rents, he stressed, is an important tool.

Advertise with us

“We’re in a highly competitive environment. We do what we have to do to bring conventions in, including discounted rentals,” he said. “We have to compete with other cities who are very willing to provide that.”

Mr. Davis said the SEA is not the only one that pitches in to help offset discounts. He said VisitPittsburgh and the local hotels that benefit from the room nights generated by the conventions also kick in.

“It’s the whole community that is responsible for it. We’re the ones that benefit from these so we’re the ones that help offset it,” he said.

Ms. Conturo said she did not know how many conventions received discounted rents. Mr. Davis said it is not every one. In stronger months like October, local officials are less inclined to provide them, he said.

“Every deal’s different,” he said.

Advertise with us

The benefits, Ms. Conturo said, outweigh the discounts. VisitPittsburgh estimated that conventions at the center last year generated $90 million in direct spending in the region.

“It is a major benefit for the city in that it brings in a lot of visitors,” she said.

Mr. Sanders said rent discounts pretty much have become a fact of life in cities with convention centers. For example, San Diego, a prime convention city, offered $5.6 million in giveaways in 2016, he said.

A 2014 Chicago Sun-Times investigation found that Illinois taxpayers spent $26.5 million over three years to lure conventions to Chicago’s McCormick Place.

“It really raises some serious questions about the use of public money and playing this game,” Mr. Sanders said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Costa said the bigger issue facing the convention center may be deferred maintenance, which could total millions of dollars. Ms. Conturo said a capital reserve fund financed through one-time sources of money and used to pay for such improvements is running out.

“We have to figure out a solution to deal with deferred maintenance,” Mr. Costa said. “If we fix the convention center right, that is going to drive conventions here.”

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.