The Society for Contemporary Craft’s “strong first choice” is to stay in the Strip District’s iconic produce terminal, its home for the past 32 years. But that has not stopped it from investigating alternatives.
Even as it negotiates to remain in the nearly vacant old warehouse, the nonprofit has been searching for other potential locations — just in case it can’t reach a deal with developer McCaffery Interests to stay.
Janet McCall, the society’s executive director, said it is a matter of prudence — rather than a sign of how negotiations are going. “To be responsible, we’re looking at several different scenarios even as we pursue our strong first choice, which would be to remain here in the produce terminal,” she said.
The society’s fate could be the key to efforts by Chicago-based McCaffery Interests to gain long-sought control of the terminal to advance a redevelopment that includes a food-centric market, restaurants, brew pubs, outdoor space and other amenities.
In March, the city’s Urban Redevelopment Authority board tentatively approved the transfer of control of the Strip landmark to McCaffery with a condition — the start of talks with the society on a new lease. The group’s current lease with the URA, the building owner, expires at the end of the year.
The issue could come to a head next week when the board meets. That’s when a 60-day extension approved in April to allow for more time to negotiate a new lease ends.
Ms. McCall declined to rate the chances of getting a deal done.
“I don’t know,” she said. “I know that all the parties have expressed a desire to get this resolved in time for the June board meeting. I am hopeful that we can work something out.”
Dan McCaffery, the McCaffery Interests CEO, said the two sides were “in the middle of very productive discussions and I would like to leave it at that.”
Ms. McCall said no additional meetings have been set up with McCaffery at this point, although the society does plan to meet with city officials later this week.
Kevin Acklin, URA board chairman and former chief of staff to Mayor Bill Peduto, said the society is a “valued city asset and we remain engaged in ongoing discussions about their lease status.”
“We believe that McCaffery Interests has made good-faith efforts to present options for the society board of directors to consider in the exercise of their fiduciary duties to the future of the organization, and we look forward to helping them make the best choice for the future,” he said.
The situation raises the question of why the URA, which acquired the produce terminal in 1981, simply did not renew the society’s lease itself to ensure that the tenant would stay regardless of how the building was redeveloped.
Ms. McCall said the society did ask before the URA approved Mr. McCaffery’s plan for the terminal to “consider including us in the disposition in a more formal way.”
“That would have been ideal,” she explained. “I think we would have had more certainty about our future and could do more appropriate planning.”
City Councilwoman Deborah Gross, who represents the Strip, also had urged the URA to extend the arts organization’s lease before transferring control to McCaffery.
Mr. Acklin said the URA had extended the society’s lease several times in the past.
“We started this complex redevelopment several years ago, and presumably at that point in time, the lease end date of December 2018 seemed far enough away that we didn’t need to extend,” he said.
“We remain hopeful the society and McCaffery will come to an amicable settlement and adhere to the condition imposed by the URA board.”
The decision may come down to what is most cost effective, Ms. McCall said.
“We have to look at what is viable and sustainable. We can’t make a decision for the short term, certainly,” she said.
While much has been made of the need for more affordable housing in neighborhoods undergoing rapid redevelopment, Ms. McCall said nonprofits are faced with similar challenges because of rising rents.
“It’s a huge challenge for every city undergoing redevelopment — how to preserve nonprofits and arts organizations who are integral to the culture,” she said.
Ms. McCall noted the society relies on public contributions to sustain itself and wants to use that money to do programming for the community. It wants to make sure any deal it gets makes the best use of its dollars.
“We don’t want to get in a situation where we can’t afford to sustain the rent over the long term,” she said.
The society got its start in Verona in 1971. After outgrowing its space there, it moved into the produce terminal in 1986.
“We certainly have been very grateful to be in the Strip. My greatest hope is that we can stay,” Ms. McCall said.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.