The way some see it, losing the Downtown YMCA would be a devastating blow to the city. And they are uniting in a bid to prevent that from happening.

A group made up of people who use the Fifth Avenue branch or who are supportive of its mission presented a petition with about 500 signatures Tuesday to Mayor Bill Peduto and Allegheny County Executive Rich Fitzgerald urging them to intervene to try to save it.

The Downtown location is scheduled to close June 8 in a cost-cutting move made in conjunction with the decision by the YMCA of Greater Pittsburgh to file for bankruptcy earlier this month. The struggling Y has said closing that branch could narrow the $1 million deficit it is running annually.

Dave Fawcett, a Downtown attorney and a former county councilman who is part of the petition drive, said the group is asking Mr. Peduto and Mr. Fitzgerald to bring people to the table who may be able to find a way to keep the branch open.

Advertise with us

“From our perspective, the Downtown Y isn’t just another fitness center or gym. It serves really broad constituencies — young people, old people, city residents, business people, people of lesser means. It’s really a great community asset,” he said.

Heather Roberts, a Highmark employee who teaches spin, core, and other classes at the Downtown location, said the branch attracts a wide range of users, from school age children to older adults who enjoy taking advantage of the programs and classes available.

She said members are devastated by the potential closing. “We just want to keep this ball potentially rolling and bring some awareness to the mayor, to city council and hopefully get some talk going,” she said.

In speaking with Ms. Roberts and Felicia Snyder, a YMCA member, after they presented the petition, Mr. Fitzgerald said he wasn’t sure what the city or county could do but vowed to set up a meeting with the various stakeholders.

“I know this is tough,” he told them.

Advertise with us

Mr. Peduto would attend such a meeting, spokesman Tim McNulty said.

The Downtown Y, Ms. Snyder explained, has been “a common denominator” in bringing people together.

“I’m going to sweat alongside somebody who makes three times as much as me, and it’s one of those things where we’re all the same. That unites people in a way that only natural disasters unite people, and it’s one of those things that creates what’s really a foundation of equal footing for everybody. To lose something like that in a city like this is absolutely devastating.”

The issue currently is the subject of mediation ordered by U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Thomas P. Agresti after the Y filed a motion to reject the lease it has with Millcraft Investments. The Y claims in court documents filed in bankruptcy court in Pittsburgh that it is losing about $85,000 a month on the lease.

It stated efforts to reduce or eliminate the losses, including meetings with Millcraft to negotiate “an agreement to exit the lease in a manner that would allow continued operation at the Downtown Y,” have been unsuccessful.

Advertise with us

The nonprofit described the branch as “financially unsustainable, and an inappropriate drain on the resources of the YMCA because the operating loss is grossly disproportionate to the level of service to the debtor’s critical missions.”

It estimated that it could save more than $150,000 a month through rent, utility, and operating cost savings, and a reduction in employee wages and benefits by closing the branch.

Lucas Piatt, Millcraft’s president and chief operating officer, declined comment.

But in the landlord’s court response objecting to the rejection of the lease, Millcraft called the move “premature and improvident” and disputed the claim the Y had tried to negotiate an agreement that would have allowed for the continued operation of the branch.

While the Y did meet with the landlord several times, including once to discuss a rent reduction, “At no time during those meetings did the YMCA indicate a willingness to continue operations,” the response stated.

Advertise with us

According to the document, Millcraft expressed a willingness to work with the Y to pursue “some creative restructuring or re-tenanting ideas,” but it never got the chance before the nonprofit filed for bankruptcy.

It also questioned the motives behind the lease rejection, saying that if the Y has been unable to reduce or eliminate losses, “It is not because the lease is burdensome. Rather, it is because of other operational issues or the failure to fully pursue other alternatives.”

“The debtor should not be permitted to use the lease or the landlord as an excuse for its desire to terminate the services it provides to the approximately 2,000 members of the Downtown Y,” it asserted.

The response stated that the branch occupies 61 percent of the Market Square Place redevelopment, which includes the former G. C. Murphy store, and was the “linchpin” of the historic tax credit financing that drove the restoration, which also includes apartments and retail.

“The development of Market Square Place, including the lease with the YMCA, was the fulcrum for the revitalization of Pittsburgh’s Market Square. Thus, rejection of the lease may have widespread ramifications, which should not be undertaken lightly or on an expedited basis.”

Advertise with us

Judge Agresti has given the two sides until Sunday to try to work out the lease dispute through mediation.

Pamela Haley, the Y’s communications director, said the nonprofit is aware of the petition. But she could not say whether there was a way to reach an agreement to allow the Downtown branch to stay open.

The nonprofit, she said, currently is helping members find other branches.

“We certainly appreciate the support of Downtown Y members. But the discussion with our landlord is ongoing and we already entered into legal proceedings that will help us reorganize,” she said.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262. Adam Smeltz: 412-263-2625, asmeltz@post-gazette.com, @asmeltz.

Updated at 5:30 p.m. May 29, 2018.