Free riverfront land. Billions of dollars in incentives. No state income tax. Those were some of the enticements offered to Amazon in the bidding for its second headquarters — by cities that didn’t even make the cut.

The online retailer left a lot on the table by spurning such offers. In doing so, it could force the 20 cities, including Pittsburgh, still remaining in the coveted HQ2 sweepstakes to raise the stakes.

Or it might be a signal that incentives alone aren’t that important to Amazon in deciding where HQ2 will go.

The e-commerce giant released its list of the 20 remaining contenders for HQ2 Thursday, culled from the 238 proposals it received last fall. The top 20 list left some cities jubilant and others devastated.

Advertise with us

Some of the disappointed ones released details of their bids after the decision or had done so beforehand.

If nothing else, the failed proposals showed the lengths to which some cities and states went to try to land the prized economic development project, with its promise of up to 50,000 jobs and $5 billion in investment.

Jacksonville, for instance, offered Amazon 200 acres of downtown waterfront property for the headquarters for free, hoping the company’s presence would generate a return for taxpayers and other benefits.

Detroit, a one-time favorite by some for HQ2, advanced a package that included $120 million in state aid to train tech workers. Amazon would have been able to keep all new state income taxes its workers generated for 10 years and half of those taxes for another decade.

The company also would have been able to operate in Motown for 30 years without paying real estate, personal property, city income or utility users taxes.

Advertise with us

In Missouri, the state pitched $2.42 billion in incentives to Amazon as part of a plan to build an “innovation corridor” for the company between St. Louis and Kansas City, neither of which made the HQ2 second round.

There also were enticements to locate the headquarters in a distressed area of St. Louis and proposed income tax reductions for Amazon employees who relocated to Missouri.

Kansas City also offered tax credits, abatements and low-cost financing, although the total dollar amount of the package has not been disclosed.

Cincinnati, meanwhile, dangled $910 million in city incentives to Amazon based on the number of jobs being created.

If that’s what the also-rans offered, what will the remain contenders have to pony up?

Advertise with us

Among those left in the competition, New Jersey is proposing $7 billion in subsidies.

Maryland is offering more than $3 billion in incentives as well as another $2 billion minimum for road, transit and other infrastructure improvements. While Baltimore didn’t make the cut, Montgomery County remains in the running for HQ2.

Pennsylvania is believed to be offering at least $1 billion, although that has not been publicly disclosed.

In an interview last week, Dennis Davin, state community and economic development secretary, told Pennlive.com that the incentive package being offered is likely the biggest ever for Pennsylvania.

He would not say how it compares to the $1.65 billion in tax credits awarded to Shell to build its $6 billion ethane cracker plant in Beaver County.

Advertise with us

Greg LeRoy, executive director of Good Jobs First, a Washington, D.C.-based nonprofit promoting accountability in economic development, fears that round 2 of the Amazon sweepstakes will pressure cities and states “to give away more of the store.”

He has called the top 20 list a public relations stunt designed “apparently to extract the largest possible subsidies from its chosen site.”

That’s despite the fact that incentives, in his mind, “will be somewhere between marginal to irrelevant” in Amazon’s decision, noting that state and local taxes combined equal just 1.8 percent of a company’s cost structure.

A much larger factor, Mr. LeRoy believes, will be the availability of executive talent, a sentiment expressed by some site selection experts as well.

Nonetheless, “saying that subsidies are marginal or irrelevant doesn’t mean Amazon won’t go to great lengths to get as many as it can,” Mr. LeRoy said.

Advertise with us

Mayor Bill Peduto and Allegheny County Executive Rich Fitzgerald have refused to release the Pittsburgh proposal or the incentives being offered.

But like Mr. LeRoy, Mr. Fitzgerald argued that the cost of doing business, the cost of land and office space, quality of life, and the available talent pool will be much bigger factors than money.

“What we have said from day one is that this is not a bidding war. Taxes are going to be one component, probably a minor component, of the decision they make,” he said.

But he also noted that HQ2, wherever it lands, will be a huge generator for state and local governments. In Seattle, where Amazon has 40,000 employees, the company estimates it has created an additional 53,000 jobs as a result of direct investments and helped to spur another $38 billion in investment in the local economy.

The company has begun reaching out to the 20 remaining cities to formally notify them that they made the cut. Mr. Fitzgerald would not say whether local leaders have talked to the company.

Advertise with us

He expects any discussions will remain secret, just like the region’s proposal.

“I talk to developers every day. Those discussions aren’t public. This won’t be, either. Discussions will be private until we make an agreement. At that point, they will become public,” he said.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.