Amazon’s wish list of cities for its second headquarters was narrowed to 20 Thursday, and Pittsburgh can be proud it’s on it.

But the field of participants vying for the e-commerce giant’s next big project is formidable.

There are eight cities that pose the biggest threat to Pittsburgh’s bid, according to oddsmakers, and there was really no surprise they made the cut. Amazon has signaled it would make its final decision based on a few important preferences: that the city has a population greater than 1 million, an international airport, mass transit and government incentives. All eight of these bids appeared to meet a majority, if not all, of those criteria.

ATLANTA reportedly offered an incentive package to Amazon topping $1 billion, including tax breaks and grants. The city of about 470,000 boasts the world’s largest international airport and has a low cost of living. The mayor of Stonecrest, a town right outside of the city, offered Amazon a town of its own named after the company. But residents say its infrastructure and transit system could hurt the city’s chances. “If Atlanta wasn’t an infrastructure black hole, this wouldn’t even be up for debate for Amazon,” wrote one resident on Twitter. Improvements to the city’s transportation are part of the incentive package, though, and Gov. Nathan Deal signaled he would call a special legislative session to consider more incentives if Atlanta was named a top finalist.

Advertise with us

BOSTON released a 218-page proposal to entice Amazon, with its biggest draw being the city’s university sector. Though it didn’t offer details of an incentive package, Boston talked up its talent pipeline, “from the obvious flagships such as MIT and Harvard to smaller schools such as Emerson, Berklee, and the city’s two community colleges,” the Boston Globe wrote. Considered a technology hub, Boston boasts a talented medical sector, too. Its biggest drawback could be its transportation infrastructure, with one resident posting on Twitter, “As someone that drives through and around Boston quite a bit, it is difficult for me to understand how the area's transportation infrastructure — highways, secondary roads and public transit — could possibly shoulder Amazon's HQ2.” Boston has also offered Amazon what it calls “the perfect site,” and was recently in talks with the company about giving up 1 million square feet in office space.

CHICAGO offered Amazon quite the incentive package, totaling about $2.25 billion — including hundreds of millions in infrastructure improvements, investments in education and workforce development and state sales tax breaks. It will also give Amazon free land worth $100 million if the company chooses to build at the Michael Reese Hospital site. To the editorial board of the Chicago Tribune, the city would be the right home for Amazon’s HQ2 because it is a “global business capital, home to major corporations, top law firms, marketing experts and other skilled professionals.” But its weakness could be the state it’s in. Illinois’s financial situation is abysmal, and job growth isn’t very strong in the area.

DENVER has been considered a frontrunner since the beginning of the sweepstakes. Though it isn’t offering Amazon much in incentives, Denver is hoping its pipeline of talented students and high quality of life can draw the company. "The young people that might be in some other city, and looking for where to not just get a job but to build a family, build a life ... they are going to be more attracted to Colorado," said Gov. John Hickenlooper. City officials have expressed concern over the region’s low unemployment rates, infrastructure and high cost of living, but are encouraged about their offer of eight potential headquarters sites.

NEW YORK CITY believes that its big-city allure can draw Amazon, touting its culture, art and communications as its biggest draws. In its proposal, the city offered up four neighborhoods -—the West Side of Manhattan, Long Island City in Queens, Lower Manhattan and the Brooklyn Tech Triangle — as potential spots. The state didn’t release details of its incentives, but signaled it wouldn’t offer special subsidies beyond those available to any company. The state’s economic development arm, Empire State Development, has said it’s willing to offer a generous package of business incentives. High housing costs could hinder the city’s bid, but with a huge talent pool of 300,000 workers in the metro area, the potential for workforce development is there.

PHILADELPHIA is confident it will win Amazon’s second headquarters. Literally. “I just want to say, we’re gonna win this," Mayor Jim Kenney said in October. Pittsburgh’s rival from the across the state has reason to be confident. Its housing is affordable, its transit system is robust and its location is desirable for a company wanting to find skilled workers. The city’s proposal touted its proximity to a number of top 100 universities. It even took shots at Pittsburgh, saying it has more highly ranked universities, a deeper pool of software jobs and a lower cost of doing business. But its job growth and tax climate could hinder its chances.

Advertise with us

TORONTO has not been in the business of begging for Amazon’s headquarters, but finds itself on the short list for its university pipeline and transit investments. Its proposal did not include tax incentives, but offered a site in central Toronto that would be close to the Google Sidewalk Labs. Mayor John Tory conceded in October that the city’s lack of available rental housing could hurt their chances, but said officials would try to “build more affordable housing and more rental housing generally.” Jennifer Keesmaat, Toronto’s former chief planner, tweeted on Thursday what she beleives to be the real reason behind their inclusion among the 20. “Critical to remember that the Toronto Amazon HQ2 bid did not offer subsidies as a way to get at the table,” she wrote. “Our proposal touted our quality of life, openness to immigration and current/forthcoming transit investments as the key reasons to come. #WeDidItRight.”

WASHINGTON, D.C. would be close to home for Amazon owner Jeff Bezos — literally. Last year he purchased the largest home in the city for $23 million. But beyond that, D.C. offers Amazon an urban center with a talented workforce, in close proximity to America’s most powerful people. With an extensive public transit system and a highly-educated talent pool, the nation’s capital could be coveted land for Amazon. But land is hard to come by in D.C., and labor costs are high. To balance those, D.C. officials have said they are willing to offer Amazon significant tax breaks and build them a new “Amazon University.”

Julian Routh: jrouth@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1952, Twitter @julianrouth.

Cities that made the cut Pittsburgh is among the 20 contenders, narrowed down from 238 North American cities that offered bids to Amazon. 20 CITIES UNDER CONSIDERATION