Shadyside-based Walnut Capital has emerged as the winning bidder to buy and redevelop the bankrupt Pittsburgh Athletic Association’s iconic clubhouse on Fifth Avenue in Oakland.

The offer, unanimously approved by the PAA’s board Tuesday night, is worth “in excess of $10 million,” according to the club’s bankruptcy attorney, Jordan Blask of Tucker Arensberg.

If details of a plan can be worked out and the bankruptcy court approves the deal, it would give the developer of projects such as Bakery Square in the East End control of the stately structure that first opened more than a century ago and drew members from the city’s business and cultural elite.

“With Walnut Capital, we have a local company with great ties to the city. It’s wonderful to have them as the winning group,” said PAA president James Sheehan.

Advertise with us

The club, which filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection in May, has been looking for a way to dig out from under some $8 million in debts while ensuring a future for its membership.

Walnut Capital’s proposal will provide the club with some space in the 106-year-old clubhouse and allow it to retain an ownership interest in the structure, Mr. Blask said. Historic elements of the building will be preserved, he said.

Walnut Capital president Todd Reidbord declined comment on the deal Wednesday, citing a confidentiality agreement. Earlier this month when Walnut was identified as one of the bidders, Mr. Reidbord had said the company was proposing to put offices on the upper floors of the 124,000-square-foot clubhouse, and retail or restaurants on the first level. He called the building “unbelievably beautifully designed and constructed.”

Walnut Capital, a residential and commercial real estate management and development firm, beat out nine other bidders, including the University of Pittsburgh, The Davis Companies of Boston and Downtown-based McKnight Realty Partners.

Details of Walnut’s plan still need to be worked out, Mr. Blask said. “Our goal is to move toward the negotiation of an asset purchase and sale agreement with Walnut, which eventually will become the basis of a plan of reorganization,” he said.

Advertise with us

The condition of the clubhouse has deteriorated over the years as the association struggled with declining membership, which currently stands at about 270.

Redevelopment of the structure “will require a massive upgrade to the facilities,” Mr. Blask said. “The PAA’s exclusive space will be refurbished and returned to its earlier grandeur.”

In the meantime, Walnut Capital will provide alternative meeting and fitness space for the membership, he said.

“We are very pleased with the outcome” of the bidding process, Mr. Blask said. “It’s a bright spot on a couple of years of tough news for the PAA.”

David Lampl, an attorney for the official committee of unsecured creditors, was cautiously optimistic about the deal.

Advertise with us

“With the offer and development proposal we’ve seen to date, we expect to see a substantial dividend paid to unsecured creditors, if not repayment in full.”

Patricia Sabatini: PSabatini@post-gazette.com; 412-263-3066.