The bankrupt Pittsburgh Athletic Association has a suitor for its iconic clubhouse right in its own backyard.
The University of Pittsburgh has emerged as one of the bidders for the iconic Fifth Avenue building, as the club, faced with millions of dollars of debt, looks for a way to survive.
Joe Miksch, a Pitt spokesman, confirmed Tuesday that the university is a bidder for the historic 124,000-square-foot Oakland clubhouse, which opened in 1911. Pitt’s interest is understandable, given the building is located in the heart of its campus, directly across the street from the Cathedral of Learning.
Pitt may be facing some tough competition for the building. The Post-Gazette has learned that Pittsburgh-based developer McKnight Realty Partners and The Davis Companies of Boston are among the others that have submitted proposals for the venue.
Mr. Miksch declined to reveal any details of the university’s proposal.
McKnight and The Davis Companies, both of which have been active in development in Pittsburgh, are believed to be proposing a mix of office and fitness space as part of their plans for the clubhouse.
Read More
Both also would keep the PAA in part of the building.
Izzy Rudolph, McKnight vice president of development, and Jonathan Davis, The Davis Companies CEO and founder, declined comment.
Among its holdings locally, McKnight redeveloped and owns the former Gimbels building in Downtown. It also is owner of 610 Smithfield, the Grant and Henry W. Oliver buildings, adding a hotel to the latter as part of its redevelopment. It currently is partnering with Millcraft Investments to build a 582-space parking garage and 87 condominiums at the former Saks Fifth Avenue site on Smithfield Street.
The Davis Companies spent $100 million redeveloping the Union Trust Building on Grant Street after buying it at sheriff’s sale for $14 million in 2014. It also was selected by the Pittsburgh Parking Authority to do a $175 million mixed-use development at Ninth Street and Penn Avenue that would include up to 185 high-end condominiums, 30,000 square feet of street-level retail and a new 935-space garage.
The proposals by Pitt, McKnight, and The Davis Companies were among 10 the PAA received for the clubhouse, according to documents filed in U.S. Bankruptcy Court in Pittsburgh earlier this month.
Association officials are seeking a buyer or a development partner for the building in a bid to pay off debts and rectify financial woes. Any plan ideally would allow the PAA to remain in the structure, which includes dining and banquet facilities, an indoor pool, basketball and squash courts, and a 16-lane bowling alley.
The field of potential developers since has been narrowed to seven, according to David Lampl, an attorney for the official committee of unsecured creditors.
While declining to identify those remaining, he said the PAA is actively engaged in the marketing process and “we’re at the stage of considering the highest and best final offers.”
“I can say we are very encouraged by the process,” he said, adding the committee is confident it will receive a “meaningful viable proposal in a very short period of time.”
Mark Popovich, senior managing director of HFF, which is marketing the property for the PAA, said all of the remaining proposals involve the clubhouse and the property’s hotel ground lease.
All include an investment amount, an ownership structure that would keep the PAA as a partner in the deal, a redevelopment plan for the building, and amenities and facilities for PAA members, he said.
The finalists are pitching either offices or residential in the redevelopment plan. Three of the bidders are from out of town and the rest are local, Mr. Popovich said. He declined to identify them.
“They’re all qualified groups with a strong track record. I have zero concern of their ability to execute,” he said.
Mr. Popovich said HFF sent out marketing materials to 10,000 groups, with 150 expressing enough interest to sign confidentiality agreements. It conducted more than 30 tours of the building.
“It was one of the best responses we ever received on anything we’ve ever taken to the market,” he noted.
The hope is to select a buyer and to submit a letter of intent to U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Jeffery A. Deller by Sept. 18 so he can review it at a status conference set for Sept. 19.
“The goal is to make the creditors whole and at the same time ensure that the PAA has a future,” Mr. Popovich said.
In filing for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection May 30, the association estimated its assets at $9.32 million and liabilities of $7.89 million.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.