The Pittsburgh Athletic Association fended off a sheriff’s sale at its historic clubhouse in Oakland this week, but it still faces an uphill battle to survive amid massive debts, a tarnished image and an exodus of employees.

Most of the club’s roughly 30 workers have either moved on to other jobs or just stopped coming to work in recent weeks because they haven’t been able to cash their paychecks, according to Mike Stout, a retired former steelworker activist trying to help employees get what they are owed. The staff hasn’t been paid for any work after March 15, he said.

Despite the pay issues and the lack of water in the building since service was cut off in early April because of overdue bills — essentially shutting down operations there — a few employees have continued to report to work.

Lead engineer Dave Lavalle, who’s been working at the club for nearly a decade, has been coming in each day to empty the sump pumps that keep the more-than-100-year-old building’s basement boiler room dry.

Advertise with us

“I’m worried there will be an electrical explosion if I don’t come in,” Mr. Lavalle, 53, said earlier this week. “There are high voltage pumps and electrical panels down there [two levels below the street]. If they come in contact with water, there will be an explosion.”

Observers looking at the growing pile of bills think the club is running out of options. Although bankruptcy is a possibility, it might mean the club loses control of the elegant edifice on Fifth Avenue.

“I don’t see how they are going to make enough revenue to cover their operating expenses and their default under their [mortgage] loan,” said George Contis, a real estate attorney in Troy, Mich., and alumnus of the University of Pittsburgh, who has been following news reports about the club’s troubles. “They’re in a bad way.”

The once prestigious social club has sunk deep into debt in recent years as it has struggled with declining membership and an aging facility. The association’s president, Tom Trimbur, president of Trimbur Insurance Agency in Murrysville, did not respond to a phone call or email for this story and has declined to say how many members remain.

Last year, Allegheny Valley Bank began foreclosure actions seeking to collect $2.1 million in principal, interest and late charges on a $2.6 million mortgage obtained in 2008. Court records show the association stopped making monthly payments in September 2015.

Advertise with us

In addition, dozens of claims filed in Allegheny Common Pleas Court show the club owes more than $1 million for unpaid bills. That includes bills for federal and state payroll and unemployment taxes (including Social Security and Medicare taxes), state sales taxes and claims by food vendors and contractors.

In 2014, Unite Here Local 57 won a $142,000 judgment against the club for unpaid pension contributions, court documents show, but so far has been unable to collect. The union that represented most of the club’s employees did not return phone calls seeking comment.

As of January, the club also had piled up some $333,000 in overdue gas, electric and water bills, according to an internal memo obtained by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. The tally, from club general manager Joe Dengler, included $158,000 owed to the Pittsburgh Water & Sewer Authority.

The Allegheny County sheriff’s office had been set to auction off the 109-year-old club’s furniture, paintings, kitchen equipment and liquor license Tuesday as a result of its failure to pay the county’s 7 percent drink tax. The sale was called off the day before when the club came up with $55,000 to cover the bill from October 2015 through August 2016, and signed a consent judgment for taxes still owed in more recent months.

Mr. Trimbur has repeatedly declined to discuss the association’s deteriorating financial condition, but has said the club was working to resolve “tax and fiscal issues” and was counting on an undisclosed amount of lease payments from a hotel being built on adjacent club property to ensure its long-term future.

Advertise with us

Sources inside the club say those payments amount to roughly $20,000 to $30,000 a month.

Mr. Contis said the association possibly could find a “white knight” to buy the clubhouse — which is listed on the National Register of Historic Places and sits on a prime site across from Pitt’s Cathedral of Learning  — and lease it back to the club. Or it could file for bankruptcy protection to hold off creditors, but that move would come with risks, he said.

“Bankruptcy will stop the action of any creditor or lawsuit from proceeding,” Mr. Contis said. “But because Allegheny Valley Bank is the first lien holder, it can petition the court to lift the automatic stay” and proceed with foreclosure.

“More often than not, the bank will be entitled to do that,” he said. “If they do that, there will be no meaningful opportunity for the PAA to reorganize.”

As management mulls its options, employees have been left to fend for themselves.

Advertise with us

Besides bouncing paychecks, workers have had their health care coverage eliminated in recent years, Mr. Stout said.

Mr. LaValle doesn’t know how long he can keep tending to the pumps without being paid. “I can’t keep going like this,” he said. “I have bills to pay, too.”

He said he’s tried contacting Mr. Trimbur, but the club’s president doesn’t return his calls.

Meanwhile, Mr. LaValle received another “rubber” paycheck this week. “I went to the bank and was told there was no money to cover the check.”

Patricia Sabatini: PSabatini@post-gazette.com; 412-263-3066.