The flap over sewer backups on Forbes Avenue in Downtown has claimed a casualty.
After being closed since early January because of backups in the building it leased at 308 Forbes, the Penn Avenue Fish Co. has decided to give up the location altogether.
It is now seeking to procure another spot in the Golden Triangle for the restaurant, with the idea of trying a different concept, co-owner Henry Dewey said Monday.
Penn Avenue Fish occupied the street level space on Forbes for about seven years. But a street and sidewalk reconstruction project outside of its doors for more than two years, followed by sewer backups in the building’s basement, took a toll.
“Trying to rebuild with everything that was going on, we just decided we wanted to do something bigger and better,” Mr. Dewey said.
The 2,700-square-foot space it vacated is now being marketed for lease by the CBRE real estate firm.
Mark Clements, the property owner, said he spent “six figures” repairing the sewer line to the building after the contractor and the city refused to do so.
He said he wasn’t surprised Penn Avenue Fish decided to move. “It was all very amicable. They’ve been great throughout. It’s hard holding them to anything,” he said.
Penn Avenue Fish and another restaurant, Courthouse Tavern, had been forced to shut down because of basement sewer backups that Mr. Clements and Courthouse Tavern owner Mark Depante attributed to $6 million in street and sidewalk reconstruction work done on Forbes between Wood and Smithfield streets.
The city and its contractor, A. Merante Contracting, denied any responsibility for the woes.
The city maintained it was an issue between the contractor and the businesses, and sought to mediate the dispute. Merante attributed the backups to a “pre-existing problem.”
After spending his own money to rectify the problem, Mr. Clements said he has been getting a “decent amount of interest” from prospective tenants. The restaurant is located directly across from PNC’s new headquarters.
“We’re starting new. Everything is fixed and ready to go,” he said.
Mr. Dewey, meanwhile, said Penn Avenue Fish has signed a letter of intent for a new location, although he would not say where.
“All signs were pointing to doing something new and exciting. You have to reinvent yourself in Pittsburgh every couple of years,” he said.
If there was a silver lining for Penn Avenue Fish, it was that the closing of the Downtown site saw its Strip District location “gain a lot of momentum.” That location now has plans to stay open later most days.
Courthouse Tavern at 310 Forbes intends to reopen once the sewer issues have been resolved. Mr. Depante said his landlord has just started working on the repairs.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.