One plan to redevelop part of the Garden Theater block on the North Side has taken a hit, but another is moving ahead.
Commonwealth Court on Tuesday upheld a lower court decision that denied a zoning variance to TREK Development for construction of an eight-story apartment building with street-level retail.
At the same time, TREK and Q Development are ready to move ahead with a plan to convert the four-story Bradberry Building into a 16-unit apartment complex. The city’s Urban Redevelopment Authority board is expected to vote Thursday on whether to sell the property to Garden Theater Block LLC, a partnership between Trek and Q, for $30,672.
Commonwealth Court ruled that TREK, in its request for zoning variances to more than double the permitted height and floor-area ratios for the eight-story apartment building, “failed to meet its burden to prove that it was entitled to the variances.”
In 2015, the Zoning Board of Adjustment approved the variances for TREK to build to 97 feet behind historic facades on North Avenue. The code allows 45 feet, which is three stories, but two of the old buildings were built in the 1890s at four stories, and one is 70 feet tall. The argument was made that an old building already exceeds current zoning for height.
The plan was to save and restore the facades because of the historical character of the block. That commitment was to have added $2.7 million to the project.
Read More
Attorneys for the appellant, Stephen Pascal, argued that the facades weren’t necessary and that the money budgeted for facade restoration could have been used for a smaller building.
TREK, the URA and the city of Pittsburgh appealed a reversal of the zoning board’s decision by Allegheny County Common Pleas Court a year ago.
After learning of the decision Tuesday, TREK’s CEO Bill Gatti said, “We have a large investment of time and money and a strong interest in helping the neighborhood solve three decades of blight at an important corner.
“We don’t know what the answer is at this point,” he said. “We expect to confer with city leadership to figure out the next steps. We feel like we’ve exhausted all legal means of solving this problem.”
In its decision, the Commonwealth Court wrote, “While the Board states that the façades of the existing buildings are part of the area’s history and character and that the existing buildings should be preserved, and while URA’s goal to preserve these buildings may be laudable, this is not the type of decision the Board is empowered to make.”
The court determined that TREK’s “appropriate remedy” would be seeking to rezone the site.
“If larger buildings are necessary to make it economically feasible to accomplish that desire [to include historic restoration], then it is the task of that branch of the city’s government responsible for zoning, rather than the Zoning Board, to address the matter.”
While the ruling is a setback, TREK and Q Development are ready to move ahead with work on another part of the block. The Bradberry Building rehab is part of a larger redevelopment that includes the historic Garden Theater itself, which TREK and Q plan to convert to retail and commercial space.
“Regardless of the unfavorable ruling received [Tuesday], we are excited and prepared to move forward with the redevelopment of the Bradberry Building and the Garden Theater,” Mr. Gatti said.
Located at the corner of Eloise and Reddour streets, the 15,548-square-foot Bradberry will be converted into one studio, 11 one-bedroom and four two-bedroom units, with rents ranging from $648 to $1,323 a month. Three of the apartments will be affordable, with two renting at 80 percent of the area median income and one at 120 percent for 15 years.
TREK and Q also plan to restore the building’s original facade, as designed by famed architect Frederick Osterling, shore up the back wall, and renovate the interior. At the TREK-owned Garden, the developers intend to restore the exterior and renovate the interior and re-erect the theater’s vertical sign and rebuild the marquee. They are already in discussions with potential tenants, Mr. Gatti said.
Construction on both buildings could start in April. TREK and Q hope to have the Garden space available to market to tenants this summer. The Bradberry work should be completed by the first quarter of 2018. The total cost of Bradberry/Garden redevelopment is estimated at $5.3 million.
“Something will happen with the Garden Theater; the rest of the block remains an unknown,” Mr. Gatti said.
Diana Nelson Jones: djones@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1626. Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.