Jim Mitchell Jr. is more than a bar owner.
He’s a neighborhood staple, spending all of his 66 years in Pittsburgh and the last 27 working out of the Mitchell Building, Downtown.
He’s a historian, waxing poetic about famous customers including actors Danny DeVito and Liev Schreiber, Pittsburgh-native and pro football Hall of Famer “Danny” Marino, Steelers coach Mike Tomlin and so many more.
He’s the grandson of Constantinos Michalopoulos and son of Jim Mitchell Sr. — who he can talk about forever — and he’s the third-generation owner of Mitchell’s Pub. Taking more than a century’s worth of advice from those who came before him, Mr. Mitchell has ensured that his bar remains an institution of Pittsburgh nightlife.
“People here, they do want to be respected,” Mr. Mitchell said. “People feel safe when they come in here.”
Mr. Mitchell has spent his whole life around his bar, which has rotated from three other locations until it landed at what appears to be its permanent home on Ross Street.
Read More
As a child, he interacted with patrons and kept watch on Sundays when the bar was selling alcohol in a less-than-legal manner (back then, alcohol sales on Sundays were only allowed at hotels, so the bouncer would only allow in customers they knew and trusted).
After graduating with a business administration degree from Westminster College, he came back to the bar under his father’s ownership. Eventually, he took over in 1980, bought the building and has run it ever since.
Mitchell’s has been open for 119 years, cementing its standing as a true Pittsburgh establishment. After Mr. Michalopoulos, who immigrated to Pittsburgh from Greece, opened in 1906, he worked through Prohibition. Jim Mitchell Sr. saw his bar knocked down on Court Place when an entire block was demolished for a city project.
‘We survived and we’re thriving’
Mr. Mitchell has had his own share of troubles. The COVID-19 pandemic significantly hurt Mitchell’s revenues, as it did with every other business that relies on customers coming through the door to socialize.
But that down time also gave Mr. Mitchell the opportunity to revamp his bar.
With a team of employees, Mr. Mitchell gave the bar a face-lift while trying to maintain the feel that regulars had come to love. With a nod to society’s dependence on tech and devices, new outlets pepper the walls around the pub and at the bar itself, and Mitchell’s installed new LED lights, a fresh ceiling, and a stone facade.
“There's a sense of pride that does come with it,” said Sarah Dougherty, the bar’s general manager. “I'm like, ‘Oh, well, I helped build that, and I didn't do that for nothing.’ I care about this place, and everybody knows that. It's like a second house.”
And now Mitchell’s feels like it’s still just hitting its stride again. The pub is picking up traffic again, reminiscent of the older days when judges, cops, lawyers, jurors and others rotated in and out of the bar on a regular and constant basis.

Traffic comes and goes, and it largely depends on the time of year, or if there's a concert at PPG or other events Downtown. He noted that he doesn't make anything off selling food, and profits come from drinks
“COVID was tough. But we survived, and we're thriving,” Mr. Mitchell said. “There are hardly any places left downtown. Now, the economy is starting to come back. We can see it. People are drinking more, eating more. They’re more confident.”
‘I’m probably dying here’
It’s just after noon on a Tuesday, and Ms. Dougherty is serving a man wearing a juror nametag a tall iced tea and a sandwich. Further down the bar, a man in an Atlanta Braves hat is drinking his third IPA.
Mr. Mitchell’s two children — one working in pharmaceuticals and one running a construction company — declined to follow their father, grandfather and great-grandfather into the pub-owning business. And Mr. Mitchell is slowing down a little bit.
“I'd like to slow it down a little more,” he said. “That was the only time I took off. I really want to slow down, spend more time with my grandkids.”
It’s likely that the future of Mitchell’s, somewhere down the road, won’t be determined by a Mitchell.
That’s where Ms. Dougherty comes in.
A 13-year veteran of the bar, Ms. Dougherty has only called out sick once, Mr. Mitchell said. She’s about seven years into her role as general manager. One day, she’ll own the place, he said.
But that day is still a ways off. Mr. Mitchell doesn’t have any immediate plans to give up the bar. But he won’t mind giving up his bar to someone outside the family — because he won’t notice the difference.
“Because I'll be dead,” he said. “I'm probably dying here one morning, and she’ll find me laying there.”
Ms. Dougherty, 36, said she isn’t shying away from the increased responsibility that comes with owning a bar. Other than some slight promotional improvements, she has no interest in changing how the pub operates.
“Everyone genuinely cares about each other here,” Ms. Dougherty said. “That's kind of special to find. That’s why it's also nice working for a family-owned business, because, as people, employees, customers, everybody, they genuinely do care.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.