SHARON, Pa. — It takes no more than 10 minutes to tour the downtown here.

The small Mercer County city on the banks of the Shenango River is home to just under 13,000 people — 12,744 in 2024, to be exact, according to Census data. It’s a quick drive from Ohio and cheaper gas. It has a few blocks of shops and churches that fade into hilly neighborhoods. It’s losing about an average of 100 residents a year.

“It's got a small town feel,” said Jim Bombeck, of the Shenango Valley Chamber of Commerce. “We have some parks, we have a reservoir, we have lakes, all of that.

“But one of the things that has been nice is we can offer you a Penn State education — here in little, teeny, tiny Sharon, Pennsylvania.”

Advertise with us

In two years, however, teeny, tiny Sharon will no longer have that Penn State education. The university’s Shenango campus will shutter, as will satellite campuses in Fayette and New Kensington.

The city, officials acknowledge, will lose a few hundred residents. A campus that heavily integrated itself into the city’s identity — even flying its flag just below the American flag in downtown Sharon — will be empty. And local businesses — including a McDonald’s, a Quaker Steak & Lube, a tiki bar, a few coffee shops, two hot dog restaurants, a candy store and, of course, a local beer distributor — will lose their student customers.

“Everybody will lose something,” said Joseph Altenor, the co-founder of Haitian Sensation coffee shop and Caribbean restaurant across the street from the campus. “We can panic [but] we have to pull it together. We have to stick together. We have to work together better than ever.”

Turning change into opportunity

The economic impact on local communities was not part of the decision-making process when the university decided which of its 19 branch campuses to close, according to its final analysis. But a report commissioned by the university in 2019 found that Penn State added $6.64 billion to the state’s economy, including spending from the university, Penn State Health system and the student population, based on fiscal year 2017. The three Western Pennsylvania campuses slated for closure contributed around $75 million of that total.

That report found that students in off-campus housing, including all students at the Shenango, New Kensington and Fayette campuses, on average spent $8,687 per year in their local communities. Those schools had a combined student population of 1,148 at the end of the 2024-25 academic year.

Advertise with us
Shenango Valley Chamber of Commerce’s Jim Bombeck outside of Chamber office in Sharon on Wednesday, June 25, 2025. “This is another blow," he said of Penn State's decision to close a local campus. "But this is by no means a knockout blow." (Lucy Schaly / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

But many of the smaller municipalities losing campuses say the fallout will be more complicated than just losing students and jobs.

And many choose to look at the coming change as an opportunity.

After all, they say, those campuses should turn into something new, something that also benefits the local economy.

In Sharon, Penn State owns the land used for the Shenango campus, and local investors already have ideas for new uses, said Mr. Bombeck, who studied at Penn State Shenango for two years before finishing his degree at Youngstown State.

The university opened a new Information Technology Cybersecurity Center on campus a year before the board of trustees voted to shut it down. Next steps, with the tech center and the university’s other physical properties, will depend on what the university decides to do with its property, whether that’s selling, loaning or gifting.

Advertise with us

“We will be exploring opportunities related to the center, but at this early stage, we don’t have more to share about specifics,” a Penn State spokesperson said in an email.

PSU commits to local communities

But with uncertainty comes resiliency.

“I'm very disappointed,” said state Sen. Joe Pittman, R-Indiana, who has an office in New Kensington. “However, I think we need to take a step back and ask ourselves what the new opportunities could be. What could repurposing be like? What could it look like, and is there a way to bring the property and the economic investment to higher or better use?”

Darla Williams, owner of Woodpeckers Pub and Grub down the street from the New Kensington campus, said her business has not suffered as enrollment numbers declined over the years. And when the campus shuts down for good, she expects something new will replace the economic value lost.

Penn State also poured millions of dollars into local economies by working with residents on programs and initiatives. Many of them will continue even after the closures, the university said.

Advertise with us
A bicyclist passes Allie’s Sweets & Treats, just a few blocks away from the Penn State Shenango campus, in Downtown Sharon on Wednesday, June 25, 2025. (Lucy Schaly / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

The university’s Corner Launchbox program in New Kensington, which supports start-ups and entrepreneurs, will continue, the school said. The Digital Foundry, a nonprofit that works with businesses to churn economic growth, will also survive the closure, a Penn State spokesperson said.

Students represent more of an economic impact than the money they spend while studying, said Muriel Johnson-Nuttall, the executive director of the Fayette Chamber of Commerce. Businesses in and around Penn State Fayette rely on the university to produce the workforce that drives the local economy, she said.

The closures therefore represent deeper issues.

“When a respected institution like Penn State steps away from a community, it raises red flags for businesses looking to invest or expand,” Ms. Johnson-Nuttall wrote in an email. “It can shift the narrative from one of growth to one of retreat.

“That kind of uncertainty makes it harder to attract new development, harder to retain young professionals and harder to build long-term confidence in the region. For many of us, this isn't just a campus issue, it’s a ‘future-of-Fayette’ issue.”

Advertise with us

Still, the timing of the closures could help local businesses adjust to the change, Mr. Pittman said.

With the university not slated to shut its doors until spring 2027, businesses have two years to prepare for the loss of Penn State students.

“While there’s still a lot of frustration and disappointment, there’s also real hope,” added Ms. Johnson-Nuttall. “People here aren’t giving up. Several ‘plan B’ conversations are already in motion, and there’s growing optimism that this campus can be reimagined into something that more directly supports the needs of Fayette County.”

While the optics of losing the Penn State campus are ugly for Sharon, Mr. Bombeck said, the actual financial burden of the situation will be far from decimating.

The Shenango Valley is used to taking economic hits, he said. Sharon Steel Co., which employed as many as 10,000 workers in the 1960s, spiraled before completely shutting down in 1992.

Advertise with us

Sharon bounced back, Mr. Bombeck said.

The same can happen in two years when Penn State Shenango says goodbye to its last students.

“This is another blow, but this is by no means a knockout blow,” Mr. Bombeck said.