When the DeMartino brothers opened a restaurant in Champion Plaza in January 2020, they aimed to pay homage to the Blue Line, a local trolley that had made its way between Downtown Pittsburgh and South Hills Village every day since 1987.
The Champion Plaza on Brownsville Road once was a haven for local workers, including coal miners, with businesses that provided daily services and offerings ranging from clothing to hearty food — the basics and a touch of comfort for everyday working people. Keeping with that tradition, the DeMartino brothers hoped to establish a space that would support local residents and commuters just passing through.
“We very much wanted to be a part of the community,” said Tony DeMartino, 57. “We settled in and the Blue Line Grille is where the trolley station was. But when we opened, they renamed it the Silver Line. I always tell people, the shirts were already printed. Though, really, there was nostalgia there with the Blue Line trolley and being at the end of the route.”
The Blue Line Grille officially closed its doors Dec. 31. While regulars said they were saddened by the closure, Mr. DeMartino said he and his brother do not see their venture as a failure.
“It was an almost four-year run, a very nice run,” he said. “It definitely was a rewarding experience and I think we got a lot of nice responses from the community. That's what we really tried to hang our hat on here: the service and the food quality couldn't be compromised. And that's what I think people appreciated.”
The Blue Line Grille opened at a time where many small businesses struggled to stay afloat. The restaurant was able to get by for the first few years, but as rising costs of labor, products and everyday expenses kept up, the DeMartinos made the decision to close.
During the Blue Line Grille’s run in South Park, the owners made it a mission to engage with the local community. The business, while owned and operated by the DeMartino family, welcomed the help of several locals and retirees during the week. On weekends, you could find Mr. DeMartino cooking and serving food while chatting with regulars who came in every weekend for breakfast or lunch.
“I came in not knowing anything about cooking, which I learned a lot on my own,” Mr. DeMartino said. “I was taught by one of our cooks and my brother taught me a lot. My mother would be so proud. I mean, she would always cook for everybody that visited our house.”
Beyond serving everyday customers, the Blue Line Grille participated in local events and fundraisers and catered for local softball teams, town community days and school spirit days.
“I'm going to miss the people,” Mr. DeMartino said. “That's where the memories are, with the friends that I have made. Just owning the restaurant and having steady guests come in and talk and you get to know their families.
“I learned at a young age how you treat a guest in your home,” he said. “Your house is mine. My house is yours. The point was we just appreciated every guest that came in and I really enjoyed going around and getting to know the guests.”
Although the restaurant has said its final goodbyes, the co-owners hope to eventually bring the restaurant back one day — “It’s a see you later, not a goodbye,” Mr. DeMartino said.
“We had people that would come in literally every Sunday for breakfast,” he said. “Those are some of my fondest memories, just the people that I have met over the years. And working with my brother too. I mean at the end of the day, I’m just glad it was something that we could do together. Because again, it was something that I really did enjoy.”
Ciara McEneany: cmceneany@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.