Sara Smith’s passion for animals began at an early age, when her parents would bring home all sorts of interesting critters. The house was always full of pets.
But she discovered her love for more exotic creatures, including snakes and lizards, all on her own.
“I’ve always been a bit of an oddball,” she said. “I like the animals that maybe don’t get as much love from everyone else. I think they’re so fascinating.”
Sara’s Pets and Plants — a pet supplies shop and exotic animal rescue in Sharpsburg — will close its doors on Oct. 8 after five years. The exotic animal rescue aspect of her business (which she refers to as Feathers, Scales and Tails) will continue, she said. But not the for-profit pet store, because “functioning as a nonprofit rescue and a store is tough.”
Her path to Sara’s Pets and Plants began years ago and many neighborhoods away.
As a kid, Ms. Smith would frequent Alan’s Pets and Plants, a pet supplies shop in Squirrel Hill, further fueling her passion for animal care. In 2018, the owner decided to retire after 49 years in business, and asked Ms. Smith to take over the shop.
Read More
Ms. Smith changed the store’s name to Sara’s Pets and Plants and took on the role as owner later that year.

“I decided to renovate the store, just fix up some things and get it a little more organized,” she said. “And then I quickly decided to switch it from a normal pet store, as you would commonly see, to not only sell pet products, but also focus on exotic pets that had been rescued and need to be re-homed.”
Ms. Smith thought that having her own storefront would allow her to educate prospective pet owners on how to care for their animals, a service she believes is lacking at some other pet stores.
“I was really excited to have a platform to provide a safe space for exotic animals,” she said. “I have a good amount of experience and education in animals. I think a lot of stores don’t put proper checks in place to make sure that the new pet owners are going to take proper care of exotics. So I was really excited to provide that to the Pittsburgh area.”
The store only offers pet supplies that Ms. Smith would be comfortable using for her own pets, she said.
She decided to relocate the shop to Sharpsburg in January 2020 after finding the rent in Squirrel Hill to be cost prohibitive.
Then COVID hit.
“The pandemic was obviously tough for everyone,” she said. “I did not receive funding from the government at all, though I applied. Thankfully, I was able to get enough donations from supporters who wanted me to succeed and stay open.”
As the pandemic slowed down, so did customer support. Eventually, she made the tough decision to close the store and focus solely on her rescue efforts.
“There’s never been a time in the last five years that there’s been a huge profit,” she said. “I’ve always taken it month to month. It just depends on the amount of support and adoptions that are coming in. I don’t mind putting in the work because I believe in it and I really wanted to make it work, but I think I hit a point where I’m so unsure of the future.”
Her main goal, Ms. Smith said, was always to provide a safe space for exotics and educate people how to care for them. And that part of the journey doesn’t have to end with the store.
“The good thing is, as much as I wanted a physical location, I don’t need one in order to do that,” she said. “So I’m just going to switch over to a foster-based rescue.”
Community members sad to see Sara’s Pets and Plants go have wished her the best as she moves on.
“Everyone has been very supportive which is nice to see,” Ms. Smith said. “But I’ve had a lot of sadness. I think people are upset that they won’t be able to go to the store anymore. I wish I could do more.”
Ciara McEneany: cmceneany@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.