An Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas judge on Monday denied the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette’s request to curb picketing at a newspaper distribution center on the South Side, saying the paper had “not met any of the prerequisites” necessary to grant an injunction.

The ruling frees members of five Post-Gazette unions, who’ve been on the picket line since October, to continue picketing at Gateway View Plaza on West Carson Street, where some 60 part-time nonunion contractors pick up bundles of newspapers for home delivery twice a week. The order by Judge Mary C. McGinley followed a five-hour hearing in June where video clips showing picket line threats, property damage and altercations that delayed delivery of the newspaper were entered into evidence.

The court’s delicate task was to balance workers’ right to picket a job site with protection of private property rights, Judge McGinley wrote, but the Post-Gazette’s property damage claims “were not substantiated by the evidence” and the newspaper failed to show that “its property will sustain substantial and irreparable injury by activities of the union.”

To be granted the injunction, the Post-Gazette had to meet five criteria contained in the state Labor Anti-Injunction Act of 1937, which allows court intervention in certain labor matters, Judge McGinley wrote. But “the Post-Gazette has not met any of the prerequisites to enable the court to grant injunctive relief.”

Advertise with us

Union and management officials were not immediately available for comment.

The strike, the longest in decades involving Pittsburgh newspapers, followed six years of failed labor negotiations and a ruling in January by a National Labor Relations Board administrative law judge that the Post-Gazette had violated law by engaging in “overall bad faith bargaining” since 2019 for contracts that expired in 2017.

Prompting the walkout by several Post-Gazette unions in October was a change in employee health care plans before what the NLRB called a true impasse in contract talks had occurred. The company has appealed that decision to the full NLRB board.

After a 38-36 vote by members of the Newspaper Guild on whether to join the strike by unions representing other workers at the company, not all newsroom employees are participating. More than 65 reporters, photographers and editors continue to work on putting out the newspaper, along with about 20 newsroom managers. About 35 newsroom employees are participating in the walkout.

Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com