A National Labor Relations Board ruling against the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette has been overturned by a federal appellate court, which sent the NLRB ruling back to the labor board for reconsideration.

The Third Circuit Court of Appeals on Tuesday ruled the NLRB had erroneously found that the Post-Gazette illegally dismissed two paper handlers after the expiration of their labor agreement in 2017. The court then ordered the full NLRB board to review whether the newspaper had properly bargained with the union over the company’s plans to switch to a digital format, which prompted the two layoffs in 2018.

After the layoffs, the union filed an unfair labor practice complaint with the NLRB.

In March 2020, the board’s general counsel found that the Post-Gazette had violated labor law by eliminating the two positions “because it was engaged in successor contract negotiations at the time” that had not reached an impasse. The general counsel argued the company failed to maintain the status quo during contract talks, which included a weekly work guarantee of five shifts.

Advertise with us

The NLRB’s general counsel went to the Third Circuit to enforce the board’s ruling.

But the court ruled Tuesday that the five-shift guarantee, which covered a total of 24 employees, expired in 2017 along with the labor agreement.

“The key issue, from our perspective, was the guarantee never became part of the status quo, so we didn’t violate the law,” Brian Hentosz, from the Downtown offices of Littler Mendelson, who represented the newspaper.

Union representatives were not immediately available.

The case now goes back to NLRB on the bargaining issue.

Advertise with us

The paper handlers were represented by Maneesh Sharma, counsel for the Graphic Communications International Union and GCC International Brotherhood of Teamsters Local 24M 9N. Veteran union lawyer Joseph J. Pass, from the Downtown firm of Jubelirer Pass & Intrieri, is local counsel for the union.

A strike by five Post-Gazette unions enters its 12th month in October. The walkout was sparked by a change in health insurance coverage that was made before what the NLRB called a true impasse in contract talks had occurred. The walkout by the largest of the five unions — the Newspaper Guild, which represents reporters and other newsroom employees — deeply divided the staff, prompting a mass resignation from the union.

About 70 reporters, photographers and editors continue to produce digital and print editions of the Post-Gazette, along with more than 20 newsroom managers. Just over 30 newsroom employees continue to participate in the walkout.

Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com