While economists continue their armchair debates about what a recession might look like, staffing agencies — the first responders of the job market — report the labor crunch of the last couple of years isn’t going anywhere.
“The Great Reshuffle is far from over, based on what we’re seeing,” said Patrick Gilchrist, who directs the Pittsburgh branch of management consulting company Robert Half. The national staffing agency largely recruits for the finance and accounting sectors, as well as helping place candidates in the administrative and customer support, technology, legal, marketing and creative fields.
In May, Robert Half surveyed 2,400 workers and found 41% looking or planning to look for a new role in the second half of 2022 — meaning right now.
Of those considering a change, many were looking outside an office. About 55% plan to pursue hybrid work, and 54% plan to go fully remote.
Though the survey listed salary, advancement and burnout as the reasons that many workers are seeking a change, Mr. Gilchrist said flexibility — whether in terms of location or hours — comes second after salary in Pittsburgh.

A number of employers who were already dealing with a tight labor market before the pandemic hit have taken note, offering remote work to help draw in workers and broaden the group of candidates to choose from.
Read More
“When a company elects to open up search remotely, it really opens the door to expand the pool in which they are looking for,” Mr. Gilchrist noted.
Pittsburgh-based GBU Life Insurance had planned to offer flexible options before the pandemic, said human resources director Rick Rodriguez. When COVID-19 came along, he said, “We were able to make that transition sooner into being an employer of choice.
“Because COVID hit, we got WiFi in the building, got everyone a laptop, loosened our securities controls,” he said. “By May, we were fully functional.”
Remote work became a key aspect of the company’s expansion, allowing it to double its workforce from 41 to 82 after 2020. Employees now work from as far away as California.
“If we didn’t have that ability, I don’t think we would be able to attract and retain the talent that we have,” Mr. Rodriguez said.
GBU Life Insurance, like many employers, had been examining its practices before COVID arrived because of strains in the labor market that had already been coming.

According to the employment services provider ManpowerGroup, 75% of companies surveyed are reporting talent shortages and difficulty hiring, the highest number in 16 years. Though the most in-demand skills are in IT and data, the increasingly tech-enabled workplace places a premium on soft skills, especially reliability and discipline.

The Harvard Business Review found the average monthly quit rate increased 0.1% every year between 2009 and 2019.
The shifting paused for a while in 2020 when workers hunkered down due to the uncertainty of the pandemic.
But in 2021 life started to return to normal and stimulus checks lined workers’ pockets: the quitting rate doubled as if workers were catching up for all the quitting they missed out on the previous year.
To recruit skilled employees in the tight labor market, Robert Half executive Paul McDonald said, “It's crucial for companies to address employees' priorities before they even contemplate a career move."
For many, these priorities now include flexible work options.
Mr. Gilchrist said, “Those workers who got used to working from home want to keep doing it, and those that haven’t had that chance are seeking it now.”
Where industries are unwilling or unable to offer greater flexibility, workers may leave.

“When restaurants closed, we had people looking for manufacturing sector work or office sector work,” said Megan Fitzgerald-Roman, who is regional manager of Monroeville-based Carol Harris Staffing. The agency places candidates primarily in the office, light industrial, and engineering sectors.
Sector switching has continued now even as the pandemic-induced shutdowns have eased. “We see some people coming from the service industry, from the medical sector who were experiencing burnout,” she added.
Things learned in those sectors often translate well to other industries.
Used to dealing with upset customers, servers can transfer their de-escalation tactics to customer-facing positions in the office sector. Those who’ve worked in kitchens have no problem keeping up with the frenetic pace of manufacturing.
According to Ms. Fitzgerald-Roman, “Individuals from the service industry have such a broad skill set, so they are much in demand in other industries.”
Blue collar sectors like manufacturing often cannot offer remote work, of course, but many workers prefer coming in anyway.
“It isn’t as big of a draw as it once was. Now that the world has reopened, people are happy to report to a worksite,” Ms. Fitzgerald-Roman said.
For many of those, flexibility means something different. Instead of remote options, workers are seeking commutes and schedules that allow them to spend more time with their families.
“We had one client [in the manufacturing sector] that created a 9 a.m.to 2 p.m. schedule during the pandemic, so parents could put kids on the bus, take them off the bus, or both,” said Ms. Fitzgerald-Roman.
Given the tight schedules of manufacturing to keep production running day and night, she said, “it was really notable that they were willing to work outside those parameters.”
As affordable childcare became scarce during the pandemic and has remained so, she added, “We saw parents from all different job sectors moving toward family-friendly hours.”
Many employees also don’t want to work as far from home anymore.
“Before COVID, it wasn’t unusual for candidates in the manufacturing sector to tell us they were willing to commute 45 minutes up to an hour,” Ms. Fitzgerald-Roman said. “Now we see that radius shrinking to targets of a 30 minute commute or less.”
Sure that saves on gas. But the underlying reason folks want to shorten their commute is the same reason they want to work from home, Mr. Gilchrist said: “It’s around work-life balance.”
Ethan Dodd: edodd@post-gazette.com; Twitter: @ethandasaxman




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.