WASHINGTON — The scientific discovery that allowed the speedy mass production of COVID-19 vaccine was published to little fanfare in a 2005 edition of a journal called Immunity — and was achieved with funding awarded by the National Institutes of Health at a time Congress was doubling NIH’s budget.
That study is a prime example of the importance of federal research dollars, Sudip Parikh, CEO of the American Association for the Advancement of Science, said this month during a talk with the National Press Club in Washington.
Now, with the nation doling out vaccines to stamp out the COVID-19 pandemic, President Joe Biden has pledged to reinvigorate American research and innovation. His $2.2 trillion infrastructure plan calls for $50 billion in the National Science Foundation, $40 billion to upgrade facilities at federal laboratories across the country, and $30 billion in funding for research and development with a focus on under-served areas.
The funding boost would come after years of federal disinvestment in scientific endeavors, Mr. Parikh said, which cut off riskier studies — those that often result in scientific breakthroughs, like the use of messenger RNA in vaccines — from support. Today, fewer than one in five research proposals are accepted for federal funding, he said, down from one in every three proposals that were funded when lawmakers were increasing the NIH budget.
Mr. Biden’s plan “is transformational,” said Mr. Parikh, whose 173-year-old organization represents about 120,000 scientist members. That level of funding would “impact not just the basic research but also see it translated into technologies and products that drive the economy.”
In the Pittsburgh region, greater federal research funding could lead to a boom in jobs and economic activity.
Read More
Carnegie Mellon University and University of Pittsburgh are academic research engines fueled in part by federal dollars. And the National Energy Technology Laboratory, with locations in the South Hills and in Morgantown, W.Va., target energy-related developments like carbon capture and storage, rare earth metals and methane emission reductions.
The science funding proposal could be a point of agreement between Democrats and Republicans. Policy-makers in Washington have expressed bipartisan concerns over declining federal R&D spending, which, by one measure, hit a 65-year low in 2018.
The country’s innovation efforts have also become more concentrated in fewer cities. From 2005 to 2017, five U.S. metro areas — Boston, San Francisco, San Jose, Seattle, and San Diego — accounted for more than 90% of the country’s growth in the innovation sector, according to a report in December 2019 published by The Brookings Institution and the Information Technology and Innovation Foundation.
Half of the nation’s 382 metro areas lost innovation-sector jobs, the report found, while identifying Pittsburgh among about three dozen cities, mostly in the Midwest and Southeast, that were strong candidates for federal investment.
Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y., and Sen. Todd Young, R-Ind., have collaborated on legislation that would allocate $100 billion to the National Science Foundation and other agencies, in addition to $10 billion for innovation centers. The Senate Commerce Committee will hold a hearing Wednesday on that bill
Last month, Sen. Chris Coons, D-Del., a close ally of the White House, reintroduced a bill to authorize $80 billion over nine years for so-called “innovation centers” — a label that researchers have suggested should apply to the Pittsburgh region.
The Innovation Centers Acceleration Act would target regions far from Silicon Valley with the potential to grow existing innovation engines, such as research universities, and the ability to match funding from state, local and private sources.
U.S. Rep. Conor Lamb, D-Mt. Lebanon, a member of the House Committee on Science, Space and Technology, has leaned on research at the NETL as a way to make fossil fuels cleaner.
Mr. Lamb announced last week the U.S. Energy Department would open up $35 million in grant money to research technologies that reduce methane emissions in the oil, gas and coal industries. More than 50,000 engines, 300,000 flares, and 250 mine shafts produce methane emissions, and Mr. Lamb moved this month to strengthen federal methane standards, rolling back Trump-era rules.
“We don’t have to choose between climate, jobs, energy, and security if we can invent the best greenhouse gas-reducing technologies,” Mr. Lamb said in a statement. “Methane reduction is a critical priority for shale regions like western Pennsylvania and will be a strategic advantage for the United States.”
The methane reduction funding comes under the Advanced Research Projects Agency-Energy program, known as ARPA-E. The energy research agency is modeled on DARPA, a Defense Department program well-known for investing in CMU robotics ventures for military purposes. Mr. Lamb has proposed tripling ARPA-E’s budget to $1 billion.
More science funding proposals could be released in the coming days. On Thursday, Mr. Lamb and others on the House committee heard from CMU president Farnam Jahanian who, along with other panelists, called for more federal R&D spending.
Last month, the CEO of Wabtec, the North Shore-based rail equipment manufacturer, pitched lawmakers on federal support for a new Freight Rail Innovation Institute with CMU and a rail operator as founding members.
The attention on research dollars is exciting, said Mr. Parikh, who has a Ph.D. in biochemistry from the Scripps Research Institute in San Diego, because public officials should be leaning on scientists more than ever to find solutions for food and water insecurity, public health, climate change, and electric grid modernization.
The pandemic highlighted the often unrecognized value of such efforts, he said. The 2005 study on messenger RNA laid the groundwork for the Pfizer and Moderna COVID-19 vaccines. The new type of vaccine relies on messenger RNA to instruct cells to produce a protein that triggers an immune response, instead of injecting a weakened or inactivated germ.
“This is the seminal piece of research that went relatively unnoticed at the time — because, a lot of times, seminal pieces of research do go unnoticed,” Mr. Parikh said.
Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, Twitter @PGdanielmoore




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.