At Allegheny County’s bustling 911 emergency call center in Moon, few operators have been wearing masks during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Shift workers share crowded locker rooms and lunchrooms, while some sit side by side at their desks — without protective partitions.
In what could be a preview of the kind of debates that likely will play out inside workplaces across the region over the coming months, the union representing these essential workers is accusing management of not taking employee safety seriously enough, while county officials say they’re taking all reasonable steps they can.

Both sides agree that the volume and complexity of the call center duties mean working from home isn’t an option.
But with the coronavirus lurking, the facility has become a den of heightened anxiety, said Chuck Kuntz, a shift commander at the center and one of four chief shop stewards with the Service Employees International Union Local 668. The local represents the call center’s roughly 240 telecommunications officers who trade off duties as call takers and dispatchers.
Mr. Kuntz, who has worked in 911 dispatch for some 40 years, said worker anxiety has been compounded because not enough is being done to help protect the workforce.
“Management hasn’t stepped up and said we are going to follow what is seen as best practice by the professionals,” he said last week. “The attitude has been: We are different than everybody else. Your job is unique and you have to step up to the plate.”
“Management is working from home,” he added. “And we are being forgotten.”
The 911 center is a 24/7 operation, managing police, fire and emergency medical calls for some 130 municipalities countywide. So far, the county says, no one at the facility has tested positive for the virus.
Without more safety measures, the union fears an outbreak could be coming, Mr. Kuntz said — an outbreak that could be deadly not only for staffers but also for the thousands of citizens relying on them to get help quickly during a heart attack, kitchen fire or crash on the parkway.
“A lot of people are pretty anxious” about coming to work at the center, said one dispatcher who didn’t want to give his name because of possible repercussions. “In our line of work, we know we have to be there. But they could do more to ease the worries while we are there.”
The county disputes that safety measures at the nearly 70,000-square-foot facility are lacking.
“Allegheny County 9-1-1 and Emergency Services have been at the forefront of establishing improved work practices and safeguards throughout this pandemic,” Chief Matt Brown, the county’s director of emergency services, said in an email this week.
He said masks are optional because “physical separation has been implemented from the onset to provide at least six-foot clearance between all who are working.”
Mr. Kuntz said some progress has been made at social distancing, but not enough. Roughly five weeks into the pandemic, additional space was opened up so that call takers were separated by 6 feet, he said.
Yet dispatchers are still packed too tightly, he said.
In addition, he said, the nature of the job requires workers to interact. Sharing information means people “are going to be in each other’s faces.”
Plexiglass dividers between workstations like those installed at supermarket registers would help, Mr. Kuntz said. The union has been pushing for them, but so far management hasn’t responded, he said.
The county disagrees with that assertion. “The union has not asked for partitions,” Chief Brown said in his email, adding that partitions could be an option moving forward.
“We came to Chief Brown with specifics,” Mr. Kuntz said. “We told him what the cost would be and what the advantages were and how it would make the workers feel safer.”
Risk of transmission of the novel coronavirus is highest in enclosed spaces, making social distancing, masks and other mitigating measures critical. And keeping employees who are used to working side by side safe has been a challenge for many industries and organizations — as the struggles in the meatpacking industry illustrate.
“I don’t think we’ve asked for anything different than what the state and CDC [Centers for Disease Control] have listed as best practices,” Mr. Kuntz said. “It’s simple things.”
Like cleaning and sanitizing, which the union says has been spotty.
There are two janitors for the facility cleaning frequently touched doorknobs, surfaces and restrooms. There are no custodians covering the overnight shift, which is a particular problem for the restrooms, Mr. Kuntz said.
Chief Brown, in his email, said the county has used Bactronix brand spray cleaners at the facility “since the onset [of the pandemic] and treatments are repeated each shift.”
Mr. Kuntz said there have been two major treatments since the pandemic began. Sanitizing in between is handled with Bactronix-soaked wipes, which are rationed, he said.
“After people are sitting down at a dirty console, I’m instructed to hand out the wipes. Four or five people are sharing one wipe,” he said. “I assume the reason is cost.”
The union also has asked that a few interior doors — in and out of the operations area and one to the lunchroom — be left open so workers could avoid touching them, but management has not agreed to do so.
Besides being against the fire code, “Doors are secured where necessary for security, noise control and control and balance of the HVAC systems for the complex,” Chief Brown said in his email.
The union is arguing that more flexibility would be logical. “There have been a lot of changes during this pandemic that aren’t to code,” Mr. Kuntz said. “Why we can’t get a door open that is touched hundreds of times a day, why that’s a problem, I’m not quite sure.”
The union has suggested staggering shifts and other alternative work schedules to cut down on worker exposure, particularly in locker rooms during shift changes. “If I only report four days a week, I’ve eliminated 20% of my exposure,” Mr. Kuntz said, noting that staggering shifts is a common practice during the pandemic.
“No alternate work schedule will equally reduce the staff on hand, nor is this needed,” Chief Brown said.
He noted that employees undergo temperature checks and answer a health screening questionnaire when reporting for work. Masks also are available.
So far, “no staff member has tested positive” for COVID-19, Chief Brown said.
When asked if any call center workers had been off sick because of a suspected case of the virus, he wasn’t specific. Since early March, 21 of about 320 Allegheny County Emergency Services employees “have been off due to being advised to quarantine by their PCP or due to emergency childcare, as the result of closed schools,” he said.
Chief Brown said management has worked cooperatively with the call center’s union throughout the pandemic and will continue to do so.
Mr. Kuntz said management has been agonizingly slow to respond.
The union has had to fight to implement safety measures that should have been automatic, he said. “Why is everything we ask for a problem?
“Across the country, water fountains have been shut down. We asked to shut them off here and were told, ‘No.’”
“Eventually they did — seven weeks into the pandemic.”
Patricia Sabatini: PSabatini@post-gazette.com; 412-263-3066.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.