Avery Hsu wheeled a cart overflowing with cookbooks through the Art Institute of Pittsburgh on Monday, as someone played Semisonic’s “Closing Time” over speakers through the building — someone’s grim humor on what was a day of sadness and anger for many students and faculty.
Mr. Hsu, a 23-year-old culinary student who was roughly two years into a four-year bachelor’s program, was at a loss for what to do next after the historic arts trade school abruptly shuttered on Friday.
He said he had seen warning signs along the way — moving to a much smaller building, the loss of some prized faculty, enrollment dwindling — but Friday’s closure was a total shock.
“At first, I had my hopes up that this is not going to happen ... that they’re going to pull through,” Mr. Hsu said, sitting in an empty student lounge. “Doomsday came quicker than we thought.”
“Doomsday” was at times a fitting way to describe the mood at the school that, as it grew into a nationwide chain over nearly a century, blended the creative arts and the skilled trades.
Founded in 1921, the Art Institute of Pittsburgh offered courses in animation, graphic design, interior design, culinary arts and fashion. The school’s bright-red “Ai” logo became a landmark in the Downtown skyline on the Boulevard of the Allies until it moved to the Strip District in 2016.
Read More
The welcoming attitude appeared to end Friday at 5:30 p.m., when the doors locked and student key cards stopped working.
On Monday, students came to take art they had produced, library books and supplies. Many of the walls that once held artwork were bare, the wire and hooks that held them were left dangling.
While the front door was propped open through much of the morning, a security guard arrived in the afternoon and let in students with proper identification. The guard also checked some carts to make sure students weren’t wheeling out electronics.
Men in hard hats began moving heavy objects. The fate of the school’s famous dinosaur, which sat at the entrance of the school’s Boulevard of the Allies location, was undecided.
“It’s just a really awkward situation,” said Sheldon Crossland, a digital photography major, after wheeling a cart of library books out of the building. He saw the writing on the wall, he said, and took six courses and an internship this semester to get his degree before the closure.
An attempt to sell
The closure capped months of hand-wringing among the owners of several Art Institute campuses and Argosy University campuses nationwide.
Dream Center Education Holdings, a Los Angeles-based charitable nonprofit that purchased 31 Art Institute campuses in 2017 from longtime owner Education Management Corp. (EDMC), a Pittsburgh-based for-profit education company, had been mired in financial problems amid sinking enrollment and heightened scrutiny from regulators in recent years.
EDMC filed for bankruptcy in July 2018 and is liquidating.
In January, the Art Institute of Pittsburgh and several other former EDMC campuses were placed in federal receivership, citing financial hardships. Dream Center, in court filings, projected a $64 million loss in 2019 across the former EDMC schools it purchased.
Akin to a bankruptcy, federal receivership aims to keep the schools operating business-as-usual while protecting its operations from creditors and reorganizing finances.
That did not happen.
Dream Center submitted to Pennsylvania education regulators a plan to close the schools by March 31. The federal receiver halted those plans as he tried to find a buyer for the schools, claiming to have an experienced buyer in mind as of Feb. 7.
In a court hearing on Friday, the federal receiver, Mark Dottore, told a judge he was close to a deal with Eastern Gateway Community College, a school in Steubenville, Ohio. Jimmie Bruce, president of the school, confirmed to the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette on Friday that talks were underway to have Art Institute of Pittsburgh students take online courses at the Ohio school.
Hours later, around 5 p.m., Mr. Dottore sent a note to Art Institute of Pittsburgh students that “the acquisition of your campus fell through” and the school was permanently closed as of 5:30 p.m. that day.
It is unclear why the deal fell apart or if there is still potential for Art Institute of Pittsburgh students to attend Eastern Gateway Community College. Since the closure was announced, calls to Mr. Bruce were not returned.
Committed students
Even when news of the financial distress and federal receivership broke, students remained committed.
“I knew I had to stick it out and get what I needed,” said Mr. Crossland, a 21-year-old who moved to Pittsburgh from Hagerstown, Md. “For me, I knew this was my one chance at a higher education, and this the only thing I had.”
“It’s even worse for people who still need degrees,” he said. “I’m trying to advise people ... the one thing they can’t take from you is your knowledge. Look back at what you have been taught and go from there.”
He originally enrolled at The Art Institute of Washington-Dulles, but that school shuttered months before he was scheduled to start classes. He transferred to Pittsburgh, where he felt like he got a good education.
The Art Institute of Pittsburgh was founded in a single 500-square-foot room in the Fulton Building on Sixth Street, now home to the Renaissance Pittsburgh Hotel.
In the late-1960s, the school was purchased by EDMC, which took the Art Institute brand to other cities across the country under the for-profit education model.
In 2000, as enrollment climbed toward 2,500, the Art Institute of Pittsburgh moved to 420 Blvd. of the Allies, a building with 154,000 square feet and an illuminated lobby that showcased the work of students and alumni.
Mr. Hsu, whose parents immigrated from Taiwan, said he felt home in that building, which provided every major with an entire floor.
“Pretty much the best times of my life were spent in that building,” he said. “It was a fun time to be there, learn and do it yourself.”
He came to the Art Institute of Pittsburgh after two years at California University of Pennsylvania, where he wanted a change. “I was in a bad spot and I didn’t know what I wanted to do,” Mr. Hsu said.
His parents were concerned about him and he felt a need to find the right school.
“When I had realized I’m the first generation [raised in the United States] out of many, many generations born on that island, I had basically a lot to prove,” he said. “Schooling there is relentless and rugged. You are there basically every day of your life. You are nailing the books every day.”
For the time being, he said he’s picking up more work hours as a cook at Nola in Market Square. He said he might consider continuing his education at other schools, such as Pittsburgh Technical College and Manchester Bidwell Corp.
Students are eligible to have their loans forgiven if they do not continue their schooling elsewhere.
On Monday, La Roche College announced it would accept Art Institute of Pittsburgh transfer students. According to a formal teach-out agreement, La Roche will offer matching tuition and waive several transfer requirements to allow students who are years into schooling to complete their degree at the McCandless college.
Students can start as early as May, the school announced, and receive free summer housing with a minimum of six credits. Creative majors at La Roche include graphic design; interior design and film; video and media. La Roche is fully accredited by the National Association of Schools of Art & Design.
Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2743 and Twitter @PGdanielmoore





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.