For Azsa Coleman, the college search was easy. Hoping to break into the highly competitive field of animation, she had only one school in mind: the Art Institute of Ohio in Cincinnati.

It was actually getting into an Art Institute classroom that turned out to be the challenge.

Just as the Yellow Springs, Ohio, native was offered a $44,000 scholarship, the Cincinnati school closed — along with 14 other Art Institutes nationwide that stopped accepting new students in 2015. After she moved on to the next closest Art Institute, in Indianapolis, that school informed her in August it planned to phase out the animation program.

Ms. Coleman starts classes this week at the Art Institute of Pittsburgh, which has agreed to pay her scholarship and has assured her that it has no plans of closing.

Advertise with us

Her struggle is just one indication of the transition and uncertainty rippling through schools owned by Pittsburgh-based Education Management Corp. After years of financial trouble, the beleaguered for-profit education company announced in March plans to sell 31 Art Institutes, as well as the Georgia-based South University and California-based Argosy University school systems.

The $60 million deal, which got an initial blessing from regulators last month, would send roughly 60,000 students and 15,000 employees to the Dream Center Foundation, a Los Angeles-based nonprofit affiliated with a Pentecostal church.

Consumer groups and critics of for-profit education have opposed the deal, arguing the nonprofit has no experience in higher education and is tapping long-time for-profit education investors to lead the institutions.

Meanwhile, the Art Institutes are projecting an image of stability to students, parents and faculty — promising the sale won’t touch academics.

Founded on Sixth Street

Advertise with us

The school was founded nearly a century ago with a curriculum of art and illustration — later adding graphic design, culinary arts, video and photography fields — that prepared people for creative careers.

A model wears a dress by Elaine Healy, who won the most creative collection and best overall collection awards at a fashion show featuring the designs of Art Institute of Pittsburgh fashion design graduates, in 2014. (Photo by Tobi Makinde)

It started in a single 500-square-foot room in the Fulton Building on Sixth Street, now home to the Renaissance Pittsburgh Hotel, and moved at least seven times, each time upgrading to a bigger building. The school’s history is detailed in “The Art Institute of Pittsburgh,” a 2009 book by Jacquelyn Felix Fisher, a faculty member, and E.W. Goodman.

The Art Institute was nearly 50 years old when EDMC bought it in 1969 and turned the concept into a chain. Its flagship campus in Pittsburgh grew as the company opened Art Institute schools in dozens of other cities.

In 2000, the school moved to 420 Blvd. of the Allies, a building with 154,000 square feet; an illuminated lobby that showcased the work of students and alumni; and a brilliant red trim around the entrance. The “Ai” logo became a fixture in the Downtown skyline. Enrollment climbed toward 2,500.

Kelsey Swinford of Oklahoma City stops to admire the Tyrannosaurus Rex statue outside the Art Institute of Pittsburgh on Tuesday, August 31, 2010. (Michael Henninger / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

More recently, the Art Institute’s reputation, along with that of the broader for-profit education industry, has suffered. Federal officials accused EDMC of putting profit over the outcomes of its graduates, blaming such schools for ballooning student debt and underemployment.

Advertise with us

In 2015, EDMC settled a lawsuit with the Justice Department and dozens of attorneys general for $100 million, refunding some students who had been there for a short time and agreeing to disclose more information. It admitted no wrongdoing.

Art Institute of Pittsburgh: in debt and behind schedule According to figures EDMC provides prospective students, the Art Institute of Pittsburgh's graduates struggle to finish programs on time and likely have tens of thousands of dollars in debt. Percentage of students borrowing money, graduating on time

Created with Highstock 5.0.14Percentage of students78%78%81%81%93%93%86%86%76%76%76%76%88%88%83%83%82%82%81%81%72%72%76%76%87%87%89%89%76%76%81%81%80%80%79%79%9%9%30%30%29%29%19%19%16%16%16%16%12%12%29%29%18%18%24%24%12%12%25%25%8%8%58%58%27%27%24%24%15%15%8%8%Percentage students borrowing moneyPercentage of students graduating on timeBACHELOR'S DEGREEMedia arts and animationGraphic designVisual effects & motion graphicsDigital filmmaking & videoproductionDigital filmmaking & video productionCulinary managementHotel and restaurant managementFashion designFashion marketing andmanagementFashion marketing and managementGame art and designInterior designDigital photographyWeb design and interactive mediaASSOCIATE DEGREEDigital filmmaking and videoproductionDigital filmmaking and video productionBaking and pastryCulinary artsGraphic design (2-year)Digital photography (2-year)Web design and interactive media(2-year)Web design and interactive media (2-year)0%20%40%60%80%100%

Student debt

Created with Highstock 5.0.14DollarsMedian debt of graduateBACHELOR'S DEGREEGraphic designCulinary managementHotel and restaurant managementFashion marketing and manage…Fashion marketing and managementGame art and designInterior designDigital photographyASSOCIATE DEGREEBaking and pastryCulinary artsGraphic design (2-year)05k10k15k20k25k30k35k40k

Advertise with us

Cost of a bachelor's degree

Created with Highstock 5.0.14DollarsBachelor's degree025k50k75k100k125k150k175k200k22…225k

Source: Art Institute of Pittsburgh | Graphic: James Hilston/Post-Gazette

Last fall, as enrollment dropped to 654 students, EDMC announced the Art Institute of Pittsburgh would downsize for the first time. The school left the Boulevard of the Allies and now occupies about 43,000 square feet in the Penn Liberty Plaza II building in the Strip District, a low and long building tucked beneath the I-579 overpass.

The building — though it lacks the bold facade and glowing entrance — features many of the same glass-front display cases to exhibit student work, lining a second-floor hallway.

Advertise with us

Creation Rex, the dinosaur mascot that greeted visitors outside the Downtown location, sits inside a lobby.

‘Where I want to be’

EDMC has declined to answer questions about the Dream Center sale, pending review by regulators and accreditors. The company also would not comment for this article or allow a reporter to visit the school and speak with admissions officials and faculty members.

Meanwhile, Art Institute students have been trying to focus on their craft. As the EDMC name was removed from the K&L Gates Center in Downtown, they continued to draw, prepare for public portfolio shows and fret about final projects.

During the recent spell of unseasonably warm weather, James Lynch sat near the front steps and recalled the school catching his eye while he was a student at DeVry University, whose Pittsburgh campus closed in 2015.

Advertise with us

He fell in love with the Art Institute because of its singular focus on art and its large Downtown building.

“You have Duquesne, you have Pitt, you have Carnegie Mellon, all those prestigious schools, and they have nice curriculums and stuff like that — but it’s not the Art Institute,” said Mr. Lynch, who studies web design and interactive media. “I saw this school and said, ‘Yo, this is where I want to be.’”

Since the relocation, Mr. Lynch described a downsizing that has whittled down his class sizes and required some professors to teach new subjects. It’s unfortunate, he said,”because I feel like the school should be taken care of more. We don’t have the necessary tools we need.”

Tori Kaiser, left, and Erik Maksymowicz are covered in snow as they carve a giant ice teardrop on their first attempt at ice carving in 2013. (Bob Donaldson / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Still, he sees a career path. He recently changed his major so he can gain skills in mobile phone apps and online animation.

Other students said they’ve heard about the Dream Center sale but weren’t worrying about it.

Advertise with us

“The financial aspect of how things are run here and then the actual instructors that teach us, those are very different entities,” said Molly Wright, who has studied media arts and animation for about three years.

“It’s expensive to run a school. That’s why they’re trying to get rid of them,” she reasoned. “And that’s why people are not going to school right away.”

Television screens are set up at the Art Institute of Pittsburgh so that students, faculty and administration officials can participate in the Titanfall Tournament, September 3, 2014. (Larry Roberts / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Animation has the lowest rate of on-time graduation, at 9 percent, among all bachelor’s degree programs at the Art Institute of Pittsburgh, according to statistics EDMC is required to provide prospective students. The median annual income for the school’s animation graduates is $19,438.

On average, across 18 bachelor’s and associate’s degree programs at the school, about 21 percent of students graduate on time. They leave with an average of $27,465 in debt.

Candid instructors

Advertise with us

For Ms. Coleman and other prospective students, the key is the promise of a career. Admissions officials and professors who met them at the open house in September did not seem to sugarcoat the reality.

“They were telling me stories about how they could have a full class and then by the end of it there would be one student left because they all leave or they can’t make it or they’re not working hard enough or they can’t pay loans,” said Ms. Coleman, who is studying media arts and animation.

She and her mother, Autumn, met with an animation instructor.

“She’s real ... which I liked,” Autumn Coleman said. “Because she wasn’t trying to sell it to everyone, like, ‘Oh, you’ll find a job right when you get out of here.’ She was very candid.”

Though it left Azsa Coleman feeling somewhat overwhelmed, it also gave her a certain degree of control. It’s a matter of determination and skill, she said.

Advertise with us

“Disney, they’re not just gonna hand me a job offer,” she explained. “You have to build yourself up to that. Sometimes it might take 10 years, but you have to start somewhere.”

Jon Bullitt of Washington, D.C., helps Jon Nesbitt, a freshman majoring in fashion design, move into his new apartment during move-in day for art institute students on Wednesday, Sept. 27, 2017, at Oak Hill Apartments. (Antonella Crescimbeni / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Negativity was also absent during a steamy afternoon last week in the Hill District, where Ms. Coleman joined other Art Institute students and their families in hauling furniture and stuffed laundry bags into Oak Hill Apartments.

When the school moved to the Strip, the Art Institute bought about 56 apartments to rent to students. Though they aren’t official dorms, Oak Hill touts amenities that mirror a college campus: basketball and tennis courts, a swimming pool, a grocery market and green space.

“I was so set on going to an Art Institute,” Ms. Coleman said. “I was, like, I have to go to one.”

Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2743 and Twitter @PGdanielmoore.