A data error by a major insurer may have led Pennsylvania businesses to pay higher rates for workers compensation insurance, the latest drama to roil the program that provides payments to workers injured on the job.

The mistake, discovered in mid-October and disclosed last week by the Pennsylvania Compensation Rating Bureau, overstated the insurance industry’s average cost of providing workers’ comp benefits by nearly 9 percent in the most recent filing. The insurer that made the data error was not publicly named in the most recent filing.

The disclosure comes as businesses and Republican state lawmakers had blamed a Pennsylvania Supreme Court ruling last year for leading to higher premiums. By one estimate, businesses paid $165 million more in premiums as a result of the ruling, which eliminated some required exams for severely injured workers receiving benefits.

Now, as a result of a new law passed in response to the hikes and the adjustments being made in response to the discovery of the error, businesses could see a 15 percent reduction in rates come January.

Advertise with us

The Pennsylvania Compensation Rating Bureau is an independent agency authorized by the state to determine the average costs of providing benefits. Its findings serve as a baseline used by insurance companies to calculate workers’ compensation premiums offered to Pennsylvania businesses.

It is unclear how much higher insurers have set their premiums since April 1, when the rating bureau set the average costs.

There is currently no way for the rating bureau to require insurance companies to reimburse businesses that have overpaid.

The Pennsylvania Insurance Department said it is reviewing the matter and how it might correct any overpayments.

Nine months of wrong assumptions have angered businesses that may have overpaid as well as workers’ advocates who accused state lawmakers of using the threat of higher premiums to justify legislation signed in October that restored the exams for severely injured workers, limiting their claim to compensation.

Advertise with us

“Many small businesses already struggle with the high cost of workers’ comp insurance, and these inflated premiums have made it even more difficult,” said Gordon Denlinger, state director of the National Federation of Independent Business in Pennsylvania.

“NFIB believes that insurance companies unintentionally overcharging small businesses for workers’ comp coverage as a result of a data error should give that money back,” Mr. Denlinger added.

A court ruling, a new law

Workers’ compensation has been a relatively stable program in Pennsylvania over the last two decades.

As workplace safety improvements have led to fewer accidents, costs of providing benefits have fallen nearly every year, according to the rating bureau’s figures dating back to the 1997. That led to lower premiums for businesses, which are required by law to pay for coverage.

Advertise with us

The recent turmoil began when the Pennsylvania Supreme Court in June 2017 struck down a 20-year-old provision that allowed insurance companies to require a follow-up exam for some of the most severely injured workers. The exams are one of a number of ways that insurers can limit benefits to workers.

Worker advocates hailed the ruling as a victory, while businesses — represented by the NFIB — pushed for legislation that would reinstate the exams.

Shortly after the ruling, the rating bureau filed for a 6 percent increase in average costs — the biggest increase in at least 20 years. That increase was based on claims data submitted by the more than 300 insurance companies that offer workers’ compensation coverage in Pennsylvania.

The NFIB sounded the alarm, warning that businesses could see double-digit increases in premiums. Rep. Rob Kauffman, R-Franklin, introduced a bill to reinstate the exams, estimating the 6 percent increase in average costs would translate to an increase of $165 million in premiums for businesses statewide.

That bill passed the House by a 115-80 vote and passed the Senate by a 34-15 vote. Gov. Tom Wolf signed the bill in October.

Advertise with us

The NFIB praised the bill for helping “assure stability and fairness in the system and control workers’ comp costs for employers.”

A routine audit

But, in October, the rating bureau discovered during routine auditing an irregularity in data submitted by a large insurer, said Bill Taylor, president of the rating bureau. He would not publicly identify the insurer.

Mr. Taylor said when the rating bureau calculated the April 1 filing, the insurer’s claims data had seemed “a little higher than usual” but he added that “the carrier that did this was always a good reporting carrier, so the data was accepted and used.”

While the average costs filing was inaccurate, Mr. Taylor argued, Pennsylvania’s competitive insurance market — in which about 325 providers write policies — likely filtered out any inflated premiums.

Advertise with us

“This doesn’t automatically mean that everyone was cheated,” he said, though he acknowledged, “on the face of it, it may look like that.”

The rating bureau has filed for an amended change that would decrease average costs by about 10 percent.

In addition, the effect of the new law that reinstates exams for severely injured workers decreases average costs by about 5 percent, the rating bureau determined. Both cost cuts could take effect Jan. 1, 2019.

Pennsylvania Insurance Commissioner Jessica Altman said in a statement that the agency was prepared to “give these filings our immediate attention, so any effect is in place as soon as possible in Pennsylvania.”

“As soon as we learned of this issue, we began working with the PCRB to encourage a prompt new filing with the department, so we could begin our review and approval process as soon as possible. We also immediately began investigating the issue and will take appropriate actions once the investigation has concluded.”

Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2743 and Twitter @PGdanielmoore