Thousands of injured workers statewide could receive more benefits after the Pennsylvania Supreme Court struck down a key part of the workers’ compensation law that has governed how the state assesses workplace injuries for the past 20 years.
The 6-1 ruling, issued last week, was a surprising and significant shakeup of the law, which distributes payments to workers as they recover from injuries sustained while on the job. It also brought a favorable outcome for a 54-year-old Westmoreland County woman who badly hurt her knee when she slipped and fell at work 10 years ago.
“This is the most significant workers’ compensation ruling in Pennsylvania in the past 30 years,” said Thomas C. Baumann, a Pittsburgh workers’ compensation attorney who brought a case on behalf of Mary Ann Protz, who was employed as an hall monitor for the Derry Area School District, in 2011.
“It could open the door for thousands of severely injured workers to receive benefits more accurately aligned with the extent of their injuries,” he said.
The court’s decision eliminated the practice of using the American Medical Association guidelines to place a cap on benefits paid out to severely injured workers.
Insurance companies, under a section of the workers’ compensation law signed by former Gov. Tom Ridge in 1996, can require injured workers to see a physician after receiving workers’ compensation for two years. The physician, during what’s called an impairment rating evaluation, was directed to use guidelines from the medical association to rate the worker’s injury as a percentage.
If a worker’s injury, according to the guidelines, fell under a 50 percent threshold, insurance companies could reduce the payments to reflect a partial injury and cap benefits at 500 weeks, or nearly 10 years.
After her knee injury and complications with surgery, Ms. Protz received a 10 percent rating for her injury in 2010. In appealing for a higher rating, Mr. Baumann argued that the entire 1996 provision was illegal. Two decades of citing a private medical group in workers’ comp injury ratings, he told the judges, amounted to an illegal “delegation” of power by the General Assembly, he said.
Justice David Wecht, in a majority opinion dated June 20, said while the General Assembly in some instances can enlist other groups to carry out laws, the legislature could not properly control the AMA’s methodology.
Among other things, Justice Wecht pointed out, the General Assembly “did not require that the AMA hold hearings, accept public comments, or explain the grounds for its methodology in a reasoned opinion, which then could be subject to judicial review.” The law did not require frequent updates to the guidelines. (It has published two updates since the 1996 law.)
“The General Assembly gave the AMA de facto, unfettered control over a formula” that determined state-administered benefits, he wrote.
Justice Max Baer dissented. In his separate opinion, Justice Baer wrote that eliminating AMA guidelines “does not safeguard any constitutionally protected interest but, rather, hinders the accuracy of claimant impairment ratings in workers’ compensation cases.”
While workers’ rights advocates hailed the decision as a victory, business groups warned of “havoc” and increased health care costs as policymakers begin to digest how to handle workers’ compensation cases going forward.
“Small businesses with a limited staff already have a difficult time when an employee goes on temporary disability,” Kevin Shivers, executive state director of the National Federation of Independent Business, said in a statement. “This court decision prevents a doctor’s review of that worker’s progress and their ability to return to work.”
Notably, the court left open the possibility that any injured worker over the past 20 years who has let the 500-week clock run out — or has settled a workers’ compensation case before hitting that cap — could be eligible to re-file.
Elizabeth Milito, a Washington D.C.-based attorney with the small business group, defended the AMA standard as providing consistency and said most people were shocked when the ruling came.
Research is sparse on how influential AMA guides are in other states’ workers compensation programs but one count published in 2010 by LexisNexis found that 31 states used some form of AMA standards.
“The idea was to cut down on the variability with one standard that’s been vetted,” Ms. Milito said. “There’s huge uncertainty likely in any case where an [impairment rating evaluation] has already been performed.”
Due to the nature of workers’ injuries and the AMA guidelines considered, very few physicians returned a rating greater than 50 percent, said Rhett P. Cherkin, a partner at Caroselli, Beachler & Coleman, LLC, a Downtown-based law firm.
Mr. Cherkin said the firm is compiling a list of cases where an impairment rating evaluation played a role and plan to ask employers to voluntarily commit to following the court’s order. He said lawyers for at least one employer declined to sign a commitment letter, and he expects to petition in court that each individual employer follow the standard.
“I think it’s going to create a lot of litigation in the short-term,” he said, “until people see how judges are handling this.”
There are other ways for insurance companies to cap benefits, including providing evidence that the person can perform some duties or offering a settlement, which Mr. Baumann said many of his clients take.
But the void where the AMA guidelines used to be will likely create some confusion until the General Assembly comes up with new guidelines or the judicial system clarifies whether severely injured workers can reopen old cases, Mr. Baumann said.
“What happens going forward is that impairment ratings are dead,” he said.
Ms. Protz was unavailable for comment Monday.
Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2743 and Twitter @PGdanielmoore.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.