Sue Greenert

Butler Pre-Owned Auto Sales and Butler RV Center

General Manager

In 2003, Butler Pre-Owned Auto Sales owner Ed Ferree and general manager Sue Greenert decided to add new and pre-owned travel trailers and fifth wheel campers to the inventory dominated by cars.

Advertise with us

That decision proved crucial when the recession hit five years later.

It has been well-documented how the 2008 recession affected the auto industry.

Two years ago, a report from Northwestern University’s Kellogg School of Management noted that car sales dipped from 16 million in 2005 to under 10 million in 2008, and not just because people were losing their jobs. With the sudden tightening in the credit markets, even people who could afford a new car didn’t necessarily qualify for a loan to buy it.

Butler Pre-Owned’s car sales turned downward, too, Ms. Greenert said, as families opted to repair their car rather than buy another one.

For some reason, though, sales of their smaller, pull-behind trailers barely dipped.

Advertise with us

Ms. Greenert’s theory is that although families were willing to hang on to the family wheels, they weren’t willing to sacrifice family vacations.

The choice then became matching the cost of multiple airfares, a hotel stay and restaurant meals for a Disney trip against paying $25,000 for a 25-foot, half-ton trailer they would use for years.

Q: What is your most vivid memory of the Great Recession?

A: “My most vivid memory of the car and RV business during the recession was of our controller and myself sitting for hours and ‘cutting the fat’ out of the business. In other words, poring over expenses and cutting out expenditures that weren't absolutely necessary for the overall health of the company.”

“Traveling is getting so expensive and so scary. I think 9/11 changed people’s mind,” she said. “People deep down are family people and I think they want to get back to the family experience.”

It also helped that Butler offered a dozen finance options plus its own in-house financing service.

As the economy started to improve a few years later, trailer sales “just boomed,” said Ms. Greenert. From 2009 through 2011, sales rose 50 percent; they then saw another 30 percent jump in 2012, flattened out for a year or two then set another record last year.

Advertise with us

Where 70 percent of Butler Pre-Owned’s sales were automobiles in 2008, today it’s 70 percent trailers and RVs. The business is still called Butler Pre-Owned Auto Sales — a cobalt blue beacon south of town — but it’s the 130 or so RVs and trailers lining the Route 8 property that catch the eye.

After 35 years in the car selling business and nearly 15 featuring recreational vehicle sales, Ms. Greenert freely admits that selling RVs is more fun.

“The RV customers are always in a good mood. They don’t have to buy one, like they might have to with a car. They’re doing it for the enjoyment and for the family time.”

Steve Twedt: stwedt@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1963.